What are good reasons to convert to Catholicism, asking Catholics?

Question

How do you know it is right for you, how did you know in your case. Thank you.

Answer 1

There is but one reason and that is love of God. You should pray and if you take the scriptures seriously, do as the apostles did, fast, pray and give alms.

Stop your life a little and give up something. Reduce your food intake or alter its composition. Every time you eat, or are hungry, you will think about God. Pray. Take the money you saved from eating less and give it to a food pantry in your area. Pray.

Pray and pray again.

If you are being called by God to do something, then it is right for you. It might be uncomfortable for you, but it is right.

Pray and be sure that is what God needs from you.

Answer 2

I can't really give you good reasons to convert to Catholicism because that has to be something that you want for your own reasons.

For me, I was raised in the Catholic Church, but I was also brought up to respect all religions and have an open mind. By the time I got to college (and out of my parents house, meaning I could do what I wanted), I found that Catholicism worked for me. I don't agree with everything that comes out of the Vatican, but the core beliefs and the expression of those beliefs resonates in me. It just "fits." It's not a perfect fit, but it's the best I've found.

The rituals and "pagentry" as someone else called it are organized expressions of prayer and faith. As with anything like this, some people, groups, churches do them better than others, and one size will NEVER fit all. Some people want the big overblown expression because for them, it is giving God the very best they can. Others like barebone simplicity because for them, it is a purer expression. I personally fall somewhere in the middle of the two extremes.

Answer 3

I've always been Catholic I dont think you should need any reason other than a genuine belief in the religion to convert otherwise why bother? Having said that I made my First Holy Communion when I was seven and Confirmation when I was twelve and for a lot of kids it's all about getting money...but making your Communion and Confirmation is kind of a big deal and usually the family meet up and have a formal meal together so it's something you always remember

Answer 4

It's fuller, deeper, culturally and spiritually richer, and more universal than any other denomination. I was raised Catholic and have stayed that way. The teachings all seem to make sense to me, although of course they aren't easy to follow!

I would say that the major reason I find Catholicism to be so appealing is that it's very fulfilling. It's strict, but it doesn't juvenilize its followers like so many other denominations do. We aren't evil, and we aren't angels - but we have a destiny, and Christ waits for us to take up our own cross and share in His glory as heirs of God. That sort of a mission means that there's always something to dedicate yourself to, because everything is important - everything has meaning.

I also like that Catholicism is so moderate. On the surface, it seems naive and unappealing, but underneath you'll find that it's very sound psychologically. It leads to joy and is also a consolation.

I can't imagine that a faith which can do all of that could be anything but true. Good luck - please feel free to contact me with any other questions, or just to talk. God bless!

Answer 5

Ask Questions. Make sure the answers you are given are based in the teachings of the Church. If you want to read on your own, start with the Catechism (vatican.va/archive). If you'd like to hear some food for thought from some well educated former Protestants, try going to saintjoe.com and look up conversion stories (Scott Hahn, Kimberly Hahn and Tim Staples are great). If you know a little about Catholic doctrine and have questions about specific items, you can certainly find great audio material at saintjoe.com and getfed.com, but if you go to biblechristiansociety.com, you'll find a number of mp3 downloads that address many of the common objections folks have to the Catholic faith (the 2 minute apologetics is a great one).

God bless and good luck. (email me anytime for other questions you may have).

Answer 6

Hmm...I was born into Catholicism, so I'm really not quite sure what it's like on the other side. I'm still not even really sure if it's right for me, but I'll figure it out.

I mean, who wouldn't want to be part of a community of a billion people who share your faith? While in mass, you're reading the same text that a church in Africa might be reading at the same time. If that doesn't make you feel connected with the world, I don't know what does. =)

I like the fact that our faith has been around for the better part of 2,000 years. Yes, there HAVE been numerous incidents, accidents, cover-ups, power-grabby-ness, and other not-so-Catholic things in our history, but stilll...the heart and core of our religion is still true and shining. It's really beautiful, to be part of something so old, something so deep, so meaningful to so many people.

That pretty much does it for me.


Kudos to you!

Answer 7

In my case, I grew up a Catholic. But unlike my siblings, I stayed Catholic - that was my choice. Why?

I was comfortable with my beliefs. I strongly believe in The Catholic Church's teachings. I'm no saint, and some of my fellow catholic are better than me when following the teachings and keeping the practices.

I stayed Catholic because I find peace with the relationship I have with God. Because I feel close to his presence, specially in times when I am sorely tested - when trials come, not in trickles, but in downpours. I stayed Catholic because I believe. Because even when I am alone, I can feel loved - and realize I'm not alone, and never will be.

Don't get me wrong, I'm still stubborn and will continue to look for the meaning of it all. But I am content.

Answer 8

Because, they possess the complete Bible. They have a continued chain of Command. They are kindhearted to all nonCatholics, including Jews and Muslims. They, among the Christians, have a prestigious, degree awarding Institute for Oriental and Islamic learnings. Get a Ph.D from there. They are better organised. Their priests are more like priests. *** This writer is not a Catholic, just a student of InterReligious Studies. Treat me as an impartial person, please...

Answer 9

I watched EWTN..see if you have it. I dunno why i converted, everything just..made sense. one main reason, however, was the fact that Catholics are pro-life, which I'd believed in all my life..and Catholicism seem to really value doing the right thing no matter what

Answer 10

it has no acrobatics in the form of preaching.it is a calm religion and it is all about you and your God-leads to more personal relationship.

for me i was born in it and then grew in it and liked it more and more.