think ! is it really so important to sing "vande mataaram?
it is one of the cunning ways by which the respected political party can diffrentiate muslims as traitors ....as because muslims will never sing tat song.....cause except ALLAH a muslim will never do "vandana" or "bandigi" tat is worshp .....he will only worship ALLAh. but then again singing "jai hind " has never been a problem for muslims ..please response......i want only logical and relevant answers ..thank you.
2006-09-08 09:38:45 · 8 answers · asked by TARIQ 1 in Society & Culture ➔ Religion & Spirituality
I have no idea what your trying to say? I understand why singing the vande matram maybe be something muslims dont want to do, however, it is not a way of casting out muslims.There are so many religions in India, I fall into one of the smaller ones also. But the truth is India is a Hindu country and they have a right to their anthem. Raised in Canada our national anthem relates more to the European settlers, I dont feel left out, they were just the first ones to think of it. What is wrong with Jai Hind, Hail India, every Indian should say that!!!!Regardless of religion.
2006-09-08 12:18:55 · answer #1 · answered by Amira 2 · 0⤊ 1⤋
The whole issue is with a hidden aim to create a religious rift among Hindus/Muslims. To an Indian who is honest to his/her nation, this doesn't matter. But for others it matters.
Vande Maatharam is a song wrote with an aim to create that patriotic feelings in the mind Indians to take part in the freedom fights. A person who sing need not be necessarily patriotic to India and its solidarity. BJP is trying to use this issue as an opportunity to take revenge on the Muslim community.
I am not supporting many moves of Muslims being Indian Citizens. There are many Muslims in India, who work behind the sabotage of peaceful life in India. And the Muslim religious leaders (the so called scholars) are silently supporting it. If the Indian Muslims stop working against the nation where they live - then there will be difference. The whole situation will change. The Muslim community as a whole has the responsibility to do that.
Any faith that can easily get hurt means it is baseless. If a Muslim's faith is damaged by singing Vande Maataram means either his faith is baseless or he doesn't understand what exactly he follows.
2006-09-09 05:37:38 · answer #2 · answered by latterviews 5 · 0⤊ 1⤋
Do you think saying "Jai Hind" made them true Indians !
See, corruption does not know any religion or caste or community - it is a religion by itself, no matter whether you yell "Jai Hind" or render "Vande Maataram" !!
2006-09-11 06:53:00 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
Singing of vande mathram or jai hind will not make any official honet as much as worshiping any God does not make one a saint or a hones t man full of love and affection. these thngs do not make a man. a human being even. if that is true no one would be killing any one for nopr agreeing with him or accepting him.
Buy saying vandhanam, one doesn ot worship anythoing or anybody as God . One salutes the God . Worship is Puja . Vandhanam is just like greeting one like saying vanakkam. Muslims say vanakkam to other persons in Tamil . namaskar in hindi , By saying namaskar to any one yo are ot doing puja and offering parayer to any one as God . in themname of religons people wnt to do politics . do not muslims call their country as mother land or father land else where . Is the country in thatcase a fahter or a mother ? i have seen muslims sitting and bending over and kissing the earth while praying , do they consider thearth as God ? If singing vandematram is worshiping a God , what is it when they kiss the earth like the hihdus falling at the feet of elders ? If the muslims consider that by virtue of being a muslims they can not owe any alligence to this countryand would swear alligence to a foreign counrty while ciontinuing in this country despit ehaving a specific parcel of land being given unto them purely on the vbasis of religon alone , they should be in for trouble as the bahaviour would be unjust and simply idiotic . they ahve been given asepate land whre it is a theocratic state . they can not treat a secualr state as their teocratic state . It is the unreasonalb elbehaviour and their incongruence with othere culture that leads to problems all ove the world today. if htey want sone thing exclusively for themselves then they must confine tehmselves to the parcel fo land they got by demand exclusively for them .they can not claim a state with in another state where they have chosen to remain despite having a separate state on religous ground . They must alsoi consiuder if any muslim theocratic state anywher in theworld give any right theat the muslims enjoy in India .Forgetting this fact the muslims seem to demand special previleges and status as the special class citizens over other people in evey other country in the name of religon. they must do well to understnd that such an incongruent behaviour would isolat ethme allove r the world . the other countries would be force to declare themselves as theocratic states . so it would be good to behave like any other citizen in any country and not to work aginst the interest of any country that they live in.Just consider this hoinestly and genuinely and seriously if you think that everybody has a mind to judge every othr person just as we do of others . We shall not do unto otheres what we do not want others to do unto us. my religion might require me to be naked as God created me . Can i be so in the open street and in a muslim area ? will this friend just ignoe it and honour muy religious sentiment s? Answer honestly. If a muslim considers religion alone is the rallying point on anything , can a muslim of Inida trusted as a citizen of Inida in case of any dispute between and pakistan? answer honestly? there are a few good muslims . I do not mean to offend them by this question , but to make a genuine and reasonable point .
I do not mean to offend the questioner also .I wnat him to understand the issue in all its real aspects
2006-09-08 23:22:23 · answer #4 · answered by Infinity 7 · 0⤊ 1⤋
well muslims bowed their heads all thru the history to kings and queens and all others who are either elder or superior ,the even now bow in fornt of every other person n say salam n so on ,but they cannot bow in respect to their nation n say i bow to you in respect to you ,well looks very strange.
its for muslims to make an issue out of nothing and jus escape,
Jai means .....you must know
n Hind means India....so ................any answers
2006-09-09 12:02:24 · answer #5 · answered by aathrey 3 · 0⤊ 1⤋
why suddenly this vande maataram has become very famous....everybody is talking about...my state says it is not compulsory....I have no idea about it.
2006-09-09 00:11:35 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
thanx for question
you real indian.
i think nobody become bad person if money not involve in our life
corrupt officers and leader are enemy of our country.
hang them
shoot out them
out from country them
because they are cause of our powerty
2006-09-08 16:53:00 · answer #7 · answered by dr b 2 · 0⤊ 1⤋
.moslims can lie to further their goal
2014-01-22 20:12:43 · answer #8 · answered by V 1 · 0⤊ 0⤋