To all Muslim men AGAIN...?

Question

Maybe the readers are misunderstanding my previous question. I have nothing against any muslims. I am just asking about a man that completes hajj. If he completes hajj does this make him a good man. In your opinion and from people you know would a man that completed hajj ask a muslim woman to have sex with him. I know it is wrong this is not a christian versus muslim thing. It is just specificly about Hajj. I told someone that just because a man completes hajj does not make him free of sin he can still be a bad man and go thru hajj and for him to ask a muslim girl younger than him to have sex to me proves he is not a good muslim. Any thoughts or opinons on this matter...from muslim men please i am not interested in women or other religions opinions.. Thank you in adavance..

Answer 1

Yes, you are right. Though Hajj is a great virtue in itself it does not make you good. It provides one an opportunity to ask forgiveness of ones previous sins. If one is still to seek illegitimate sexual relations (which is a Grave Sin in Islam), there is no point in saying that he is a good man.

But let me clear one thing. The illegitimate sex in forbidden whether it is with younger girl or an elder one. If the sin is performed with mutual agreement, both are equally responsible and will meet SAME consequences unless true repentance is sought.

Answer 2

dear

hajj is not a relefe from sins in advnce
but if i had a sin and then completed hajj if god has accepted my hajj the sin would be removed

and since every man/women on earth is supposed to make mistakes so any sin i do after i lose degrees ~means i can't commit adultry after hajj

one of some muslims bad behavior is they do sins before hajj now i'm not sure but god knows better how to joudje them

Answer 3

There's nothing wrong with your state. You're right.