Why does Indian muslims dont want to sing Vande mataram..?

Question

Is there something in the song that is anti Islamic ? I have always faced this topic in the media, and now its again happening in Jharkhand. Can someone give me a neutral answer without any religious bias in it..

Answer 1

Whatever our netas may say,the loyalty of Muslims to this nation is always remained a point of doubt. without the aid of Muslims in India terrorist from Pakistan and Bangla Des cannot come here and sabotage and do terrorist activities successfully. our police can raid temples and Hindu Mutt but can they ever dare to step inside a mosque to question what is going on there?
So the Muslims keep searching for some issue to disrupt the peace of the nation. Can I ask one question. During the independence struggle the Muslims also raised the slogan Vande mataram. if that is so from where did the new objection originate? Secondly Vande mataram means i bow to my mother
probably Islam does not allow salute to one's mother. Thirdly Muslims are controlled by Mullahs. The educated and progressive Muslim is handful in number and they have no voice with in their own community. No one can speak against the mullah whether he is right or wrong.
The easiest way to negate my argument is to brand me as Hindu fanatic as if there are no fanatics in Islam.
If we see terrorism in the world it entirely belongs to Islam and 100 % terrorists are Muslims. Our netas would like to mince the words just to protect the vote banks.
This shows that There is not a single Hindu neta who is a patriot and loyal to mother India
My poor mother vande maataram!

Answer 2

Don't you have any better work than Singing Vande mataram?
Even Hindus are against Vande Mataram or any patriotic song..
Bhagavad Gita First teaching is you are not his Body.
what will you achieve by simply singing Vande Matram..

If you are patriotic then work for the welfare of people. Singing will not give you any thing except entertainment.

Singing Vande matram is not same as Prayer to God.
In Prayer to God, just by Praying you get lot of benefit.

But praying to Piece of land or government, will get nothing ...In-fact Such prayer is criticized in Bhagavad Gita.

Answer 3

Is there something in the song that is anti Islamic ? I have always faced this topic in the media, and now its again happening in Jharkhand. Can someone give me a neutral answer without any religious bias in it

Answer 4

Well i think if muslims say that they cant pray a Country and the only one worth of being prayed is 'Allah' - then its fine because different religions have different things to pray and we being INDIANS should respect all schools of thoughts.
Having said that muslims then should have no problem saying Jai hind or Jai bharat maa ki because it does not mean worship bharat maa or anything like that.
and moreover i think all this is a political sandstorm which will wind down as suddenly it got up, because if it really was a major issue to muslims then this would have been a problem since making of our country.
Jai Hind

Answer 5

actually i never knew the meaning of the song until i saw someone posted the meaning of the song. i guess it contains names of Hindu dieties, no wonder(rolls eyes). may be u should let them be. i mean, wont u have a problem saying Allah is the Greatest or singing a song that says bow down to Allah.? same way man.

also some one pointed out that THE SONG IS INCOMPLETE. so why do u wanna sing an incomplete song. hey i thought ur country was a free one without any probs, how wrong of me.

hey dude!!!!!!!!!!! tell ur countrymen that LOVE FOR THE COUNTRY SHOULD BE IN UR HEARTS NOT IN THE SONGS U SING- esp IF THE SONG IS INCOMPLETE.

Answer 6

almost everyone sang it while fighting against "Britishers";
but now - our so called wisemen "Politicians" are used to arouse "Public sentiments" and go back-door ;
enjoy the tamasha;
for all you know- hindu & muslim politicians would join hands in late night shows - merry making - going after and sharing W & W;

they make us fool; successfully.
we are foolish enough to fall pray to their tricks;
again and again;

so, we must praise the land / mother which gives us so much;
she does no politics............


or - do the following test:

"show real angry stone to those guys" in case you are so determined to know;
if they are dedicated to any real cause they would "bow in politeness"; instead if "they are armed with stones"; means they have achieved what they wanted-
"hatred" at any cost ; by any means; destroy fellowmen at "others" instructions; since they are just the "dangerous toys / puppets" being signalled / keyed / programmed from elsewhere;

so; "neutral" answer is -
it - Vande mataram - is in praise of Motherland, which is beautiful;
full of bounties; for us - children- to enjoy in Her lap;

you sing it the way you can;
if your voice is not melodious - it would become when you praise your dear Mother from your heart;

any ques - left;

many-ques!!!

Answer 7

They take the plea that Holy Quran does not permit them to sing Vande Mataram. However, neither Holy Quran nor Hadith or Shariat does not say any such ban.

Problem here is Muslims in India, although they live in India, owe their allegiance to Pakistan. They have to follow the instructions of Pakistan mullahs.

Answer 8

most of the muslim people do not have any objection to sing regarding this song but some of the muslim have problem like when hindus are donot sang our song so why we? acually there is nothing anti islamic in this song this is just neutral song

Answer 9

Here is the answer to the question given on yahoo news today.

This all thing is just for the word "Vande"

Answer 10

I totally unagree with u this my half of the realtions are settled in India.... I hear from them these words as they are feeling vry proud by saying them.... Nations song is always for all citizens of nation and not even anti for minority it is my belief