who was right?
both couldn't be right because there wouldn't be a war between them?
the JAMAL war
http://mb-soft.com/believe/txo/shiites.h...
2006-09-05 02:05:38 · 9 answers · asked by nicky 3 in Society & Culture ➔ Religion & Spirituality
haroon I think I already gave alink ,go search Ayshas name ,or any were that has written about her life the Jamal war is there.
both SUnnies an dShia believe that this war happened.
2006-09-05 02:11:00 · update #1
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisha
2006-09-05 02:17:49 · update #2
Ali (A.S.) was imam for shia and caliph for sunnies, to go against the caliph or imam, who was choosen by majority for muslims at that time is wrong.
2006-09-05 02:35:59 · answer #1 · answered by smak110 2 · 2⤊ 0⤋
that`s a very good question
fanatic Sunnis will say that Aisha was right
Fanatic Shias would say Ali was right
well, I`m a moderate Sunni & I say both were wrong becase they were living in the same house & they were close relatives, they shouldn`t have allowed an argument like this to be extended to a war??? the conseqences of this war were horrible, Muslims started dividing into sects untill today & we rarley became united since then
2006-09-05 02:11:17 · answer #2 · answered by ahmed_mo2nis 4 · 1⤊ 1⤋
The answer is simple.
Ali (s.a) was surely on the right side. The most clearly visible proof to this is that He(s.a) was the Khalifa of Muslims at that particular time and Aysha was the one who quarralled Him. The Musilms of that time needed to be with Ali(s.a).the Quran states that clearly.(Chp:49, verse:9)
2006-09-05 02:16:18 · answer #3 · answered by Shabbir T 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋
Aysha, as all of the wives of our great Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), is considered the Mother of every Muslim.
Ali, is the cousin of our great Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and the forth Khalifa and one of the first and the greatest Muslims.
So , to me , both are too high for me to judge base on unclear history of that time, even though, I will still consider myself too small to try to think about them being wrong or right, that will be for Alla to judge.
I am a Sunni, and feel great love and respect for both of them for ever and a day.
2006-09-05 02:18:45 · answer #4 · answered by Abdulhaq 4 · 3⤊ 1⤋
1.It does not matter you are sunni or shia it is important that you are muslim or at least a good person
2.Shia in arabic means party (like political party). Before the death of Muhammad people used to call the close friends of Ali (cousin of muhammad) Shia.
3.Right after the death of Muhammad while Ali were busy with funeral, Abu bakr and omar and 4 other sahaba were busy with who gets the power after muhammad!!! They all disregarded Muhammad saying that suggested Ali directly and indirectly as the leader of umma after his death. like Qadi Khomm or lots of other hadith,....
4.Omar killed Fatima, the daughter of Muhammad (wife of Ali) with a baby inside and unfortunately sunni scholars especially wahabbis do not like talking about this part of history and if you ask them why the tomb of Zahra is unknown they will become angry of you. This incident made shia very disapointed and sad.
5.Jamal war also were another story that Aiyasha and some sahaba went to war with Ali and after Ali defeated them, he respectfully returned Ayasha to medina/mecca
6.Karbala incident where Yazid killed Hussain were another sad historical point that shia wanted separate themselves from those who call themselves muslims and say Allah o Akbar but beheaded the grand son of Muhammad.
7.Shia love Ahlul bayt and shia is the enemy of the enemy of Ahlol bayt.
8. Yazid were son of Moavai and moavia were son of Abu sofian whose wife killed and eated the liver of Hamza in ohod war. Guess who put Moavia in shaam? Omar your second Khaliff. Guess who went to war with Ali in Seffain war? Moavia
9. http://yshia.blogfa.com/
2014-04-14 10:54:11 · answer #5 · answered by Dave 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
indeed jamal war happened due to misunderstand regarding punish the criminals who slaughtered kalipah uthman , indeed this war ignited by KARIJI group who killed kalipah uthman.
*my opinion on this war: arab always fight each other for just pretty issue, thats y islam lost its clear vision, and rename as terrorist.
2006-09-05 02:12:33 · answer #6 · answered by i_am_a_victim 1 · 0⤊ 1⤋
there was no war i never ever heard about it plz give us some link or from were did u hear that and the link which u gave is not working ok
2006-09-05 02:07:36 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 3⤋
Because the muslims like to fight everyone.
2006-09-05 02:10:57 · answer #8 · answered by Michael S 4 · 1⤊ 4⤋
cause they're idiots!!!!
2006-09-05 02:07:42 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 5⤋