Is the Fixed postition speed camera a substitute for the Highway patrol?

Question

The NSW opposition and the police union claim that the fixed position speed camera is being used as a substitute for the highway patrol. I think they are right, the police officer pulling you up can breath test you for alchol and other drugs, check if there are any outstanding warrents etc and what is more you will slow down after being booked by the Cops. The speed camera only takes photos of the car.

Answer 1

Sounds like you are in Australia and I am here in the US. But, the cameras you mention are used widely on the Autobahn in Germany. I don't think they are a substitute for Highway patrol, just a way to augment their activities.

The speed camera is just monitoring one activity (speeding) in one fixed location. A patrol officer is mobile and adds the human element of sight and judgment to the policing activity. A patrol officer can spot:
1) reckless/drunken driving
2) a stolen car based on the license plate
3) vehicular infractions (such as illegal lights, expired registration, etc.)

And, of course, a mobile patrol officer can also respond to accidents and requests for assistance from motorists and/or pedestrians.

So, to argue that a speed position camera is used as a substitute for a patrol officer is an absolute fallacy.

Answer 2

to me that is entrapment by police officials. I don't agree with the cameras that police have at stop lights either. I know that they are nice if there is an accident to see who's at fault if one side of the party involved ran the red light, but a far as giving tickets, i think it is wrong.
plus they give the ticket to the person the car is registered to and that might not be the person driving the car at the time.

Answer 3

those cameras were recently all shut down in my city because a judge ruled they were unconstitutional and a violation of due process rights.. the camera could only tell the police the car's license info, but not who the actual driver was.
The ACLU said that the police need to ticket the driver, not the owner of the car.
ACLU is American Civil Liberties Union

Answer 4

It is only a replacement for red light runners. It takes a picture of your car license and then they send you a ticket in the mail with the photo.
I know my girlfriend got one. There is no way you can deny it was you who ran the red light. This also stops the cops from pulling you over for running a red light and then you both go to court and it becomes a he said she said ordeal.

Answer 5

what's the main deadly approximately that is which you're freaking out, kinda watching gps, kinda observing highway alerts, kinda observing your velocity, kinda staring on the line. using like that on the comparable time speeding is extra unfavourable than somebody in basic terms speeding and paying concentration to the line. while your ideas is everywhere the situation and you may desire to be getting worked up emotionally on an analogous time as using, that's doubtless extra unfavourable. would you may have made it homestead on time had you remembered your backpack and pushed the cost shrink? If the respond is constructive, you will maximum in many cases have your curfew cost ticket dropped when you consider that is a conceivable tale and human beings fail to keep in mind issues many cases. You being a in basic terms suited student, of direction you will flow lower back on your bag. that doesn't excuse speeding. i'd have inspired what you're already doing appropriate to your speeding cost ticket. Taking a motive force direction previously than the court date especially. make certain that's a direction that the dep. of Motor autos recommends as a qualified direction. make certain you keep in mind your varieties for the making use of type to your court date. community service would desire to or won't assist you. you may't be sentenced to community service for a regularly occurring speeding cost ticket. You maybe dropping a while with the help of making use of volunteering, until you assume good approximately volunteering a while to assist persons, then God bless you for that, and take care of volunteering while which you would be able to. The final analysis is which you have been speeding, and you would be convicted of speeding. i'd assume the settle directly to scale down it to fifteen over pondering the certainty that of what you may desire to be doing previously court. he will shrink the regularly happening and shrink the climate against your license. with the objective to assist with coverage no longer going up as intense too. do no longer ignore your workplace work to your court docket date. you does not prefer to get a rushing cost ticket on an analogous time as going lower back to get it! in basic terms suited fulfillment.