Do you believe that the Electoral College should be eliminated from the US voting process?

Question

In a day and age where almost everyone in the United States is well read and educated, why does such a government body still exsist?
I personally believe that this institution totally defeats the purpose of democracy, and probably contributes somewhat to the reason many people do not vote (especially after the 2000 elections).
As I will be able to vote this next year, I really can't find it in myself to want to vote when I know that a) the canidates usually suck, and b) the electoral college makes the final descision anyway.
What are your takes on this, and if you do believe in eliminating this institution, how?
Particularly in a day and age where most politicians just care about their own advancement.

Answer 1

Eliminating the electoral system would NOT lead to a mass of parties (like in Italy) as long as the person with the most votes wins (i.e. one only needs a plurality to win).

The reason the electoral college is still around is because of small and medium sized states. These states (especially the medium sized ones) still mean something in the electoral college system. They would mean little if the electoral college went away. Candidates could target their campaigns toward a few key population centers. The Democrats would target the cities and the GOP would target the suburbs.

The ills in our system that you bring up are legitimate, but eliminating the electoral college would not fix them. It is a very good question though.

Answer 2

No. The Founding Fathers set it up the way it is so that there would be a clear majority winner in elections. What you ask for is undiluted idiocy. Italy has had about 50 governments since WW2. Israel has a new one every year or so. You want that here?

Contrary to your statement, many Americans are not well-read or well-educated. Just read the atrocious grammar and inscrutable spelling on these pages, and you'll soon come to the conclusion that most people are too stupid to vote in the first place.

Answer 3

"in case you think of it is bigoted, foyer YOUR STATE to pass UP THEIR DATE. end playing the sufferer." Wow, you rather thought that one out. Yeah, only foyer your state. i'm specific which will artwork. Brandon A., you're suitable that lobbying is secure via the 1st amend., yet i did not understand abolishing the electoral college equipment grew to become right into a "neolib" place. the place did you pull that one from? in case you think of lobbying your state or representative is going to alter the electoral equipment then you certainly're living in a delusion worldwide. The electoral college is right here to stay. in spite of the shown fact that, the Iowa and New Hampshire and Florida and etc., etc., caucuses are an absolute shaggy dog tale. forget approximately the reality that electorate in states like Iowa and New Hampshire are honestly nuts (see Alan Keyes in 2000 Iowa caucus). the reality that qualified applicants, who could desire to probably do o.k. in a nationwide election, would possibly not even get the prospect to run for president would not sound constitutional or democratic to me, yet nevertheless, every physique who knows something knows the U.S. is a lot from a democracy (this is honestly a representative republic for people who's probably not responsive to).

Answer 4

The electoral college should go. There is no good reason why the president should not be chosen by direct vote of the people.


I do urge you to vote, however, regardless of your misgivings. The only check and balance against the power of corporate America is the government, and if we disable the government, then corporations are the only force left. And how well do YOU fare in disagreements with firms ranging from Microsoft to GE to McDonald's? You might get fries with that order, but health care? Forgeddaboudit.

Answer 5

I personally think the electoral college is a good thing. It provides the smaller states with a say in who runs the country. I know most people from the larger populated states assume we in the smaller populated states are not as smart as they, but we do provide our positive contributions.

With out the electoral college there would be no need for the smaller states to even vote..

Not only that but with out the electoral college we might have had al gore or john kerry as president, and that would have been a major mistake!

Answer 6

It should be eliminate, then every vote would count. Right now u do not the right to vote. U Think u do