A Comparison between Jesus and Muhammad. Muslims how do u explain this?

Question

http://www.carm.org/islam/Jesus_Muhammad.htm

Answer 1

They can't.
They will BLUSTER.
Then they will report you for HATE HATE HATE.
Their favourite word--HATE.

Answer 2

Well, the chart is clearly made with facts and research with the Bible and hadiths but one has to admit there is a some what bias. Besides that fact, there are somethings to consider. First of all, muslims are not all just one unit. They are divided just like the catholics, baptists, protestants and many more. Muslims are divided into Shites and Sunnis, majority wise. For example, I don't know which group of Christians but one group believes in 12 disciples, just like that the Shites believe in 12 imams after the Prophet Muhammad while the Sunnis do not. There are major difference between the two sects and there believes.
Another thing to consider is that, the Muslims DO BELIEVE in Jesus but not a God or son of God. Muslims believe that Jesus was a prophet like Muhammad out of the 124000 that came upon the earth. Furthermore, Moses and Noah are also prophets to the Muslims. The difference here is that Muhammad is a prophet while God is the most merciful and totally different.
The chart has facts about Muhammad that are true but they are written and portrayed in a bad manner and are not completely true as well. For instance, the Quran was not the only miracle for Muhammad. Ask any Muslim that knows there religion.
In conclusion, one should not compare prophets from a muslims perspective. All had there duties which they had to fulfill and were assigned to a specific group like Moses to Jews, Jesus to Christians and Muhammad to Muslims.
For more information, consult your nearby mosque with a priest. Make sure to consult two different mosques because of all the shites and sunni differences. Take the chart along with you so that you can tell about the comparisons that are listed. Compare the the two books (bible and quran) and see for yourself. This will be more satisfying than people telling you.

Disclaimer: This is information with pure facts and this was not a response to offend any one, just a scholarly reply.

Answer 3

A lot of the information about the Prophet Muhammad and Prophet Jesus in this chart are way off. There is a misrepresentation of information on both side... also, facts are partially or bias in their presentation. I would not trust this chart if I were you. A person who is a true and sincere seeker will go to the source (The holy books, the followers of the faith, scholars, unbias biographies, etc) to find the truth, not this ridiculous chart.

Answer 4

Here's a huge ******* difference in theology.

Muslims don't worship Muhammed(pbuh) in the way that Christians worship Jesus! It is against Islam to worship idols and according to Islam, the worship of a man, no matter how "divine" he claims to be, is forbidden. Muhammed and Jesus are both prophets in the Quran. Comparing them would only make sense if you wanted to choose which man you wanted to worship. Muslims choose neither. They only worship Allah, the one true G-d who does not have a back up squad.

Answer 5

Nice comparison indeed!!!

Similarities:

Both were trustfull, humble, generous messengers of GOD.

Both were human beings.

Both spoke the truth, guided mankind to follow the commands of ONE Creator.

Both were given revelations by GOD to make mankind understand better the teachings of GOD.

Differences:

Jesus was born miraculously by the Will of GOD without a father to the virgin Mary (On them be Peace)
while Muhammed was born as a normal human being (Peace Be Upon Him)

Jesus was given the job of guiding his people only till his work is finished.
while Muhammed was given of guiding the entire mankind without any time limitation. Muhammed is the last and final messenger of GOD, he was sent to affirm the true message of the Christ and guide the entire mankind till the last Day.

Know more about the comparison:

Watch the videos on Comparative religion studies:
http://www.irf.net

Answer 6

Dear, First thing :This comparison not illustrated or complete ,Examble : They mentioned that jesus not fought but mohammed fought but they didn't mentioned that muhammed fought to return rights & fought when the other side forced him to fought,he was not the beginner but he replied also he didn't killed child or woman like some presidents nowadays.
Second thing :Muslims beleive in jesus & mohammed both
Third thing : Try to read Qura'an ( Muslims book ) & judge after reading.
Thank you

Answer 7

first ur site is christian site and we muslims dont trust this sites as its responsible for bad interpreting of islam to make ppl hate islam u can find that all islamic sites talk the truth about christianity ,,if u wanna compare jesus&mohammad(pbuthem all)i can give u asite http://www.answering-christianity.com/abdullah_smith/jesus_and_muhammad_compared.htm it compare also from the bible

Answer 8

Nothing to compare as Jesus and Mohammad were both Prophets....and why should we agree on any BS site you post.

Answer 9

The "information" in the link is not objective, but deliberately biased and propagandistic. It also states many commonly accepted truths.

Answer 10

My myths are better than yours! Did that make you feel better about yourself?

Answer 11

got to see these ansewers