Were people allowed to discuss decisions given by prophet Muhammed?

Question

Islamic history tells that there were two men who had a dispute over some financial issue and they went to prophet Muhammed to seek an arbitrary decision. When prophet Muhammed made a decision, one of those men did not accept it and asked to appeal it; therefore they went to Omar Ibn El Khattab and told him the story. What Omar did was that he KILLED the man who was trying to appeal the prophet's decision.

Many muslims know that story and this is the reason Omar kattab was called "Farouk", which means "the man who distinguished between what is right and what is wrong".

http://haqiqa.jeeran.com/archive/2006/8/81749.html

My questions are:

(1) The dispute was purely over a financial issue. And It is their right to appeal a decision if they did not like it. So, why did Omar kill the man?

(2) Neither of parties in the dispute was muslim; and therefore it was their right not to believe that a decision made by prophet Muhammed was a holy one that should not be disputed.

Answer 1

i have no idea who told that in there was no muslim one was muslim and the other one was a non muslim
OK i know that story remember PROPHET MUHAMMAD was the best person in that village the 2 men one of them was a Muslim and the other one was a non Muslim OK when they went to to open the case and PROPHET MUHAMMAD made the DECISION in the favor of non Muslim so the Muslim one thought that if i go to Omar Ibn El Khattab and tell him the story so he might revers the dision in my favor coz i will tell him i am a Muslim and he is a non Muslim but when Omar Ibn El Khattab came to know that PROPHET MUHAMMAD has AL ready made and given the decision in the non Muslim favor he came out killed the Muslim coz the Muslim one wanted to prove the justice wrong which was done by the PROPHET MUHAMMAD and remember in ISLAM everyone is same if u are a Muslim or a non Muslim so this tels us the story tells us that ISLAM is a peace loves peace i hope u understand this answer

Answer 2

yea i m in favor of Haroon. in that dispute one was a known hypocrite muslim amongst the muslims whereas the other was a jew. jew accepted Prophet Mohd's decision but the muslim did not. so he took the case to Omar for a favor. the jew narrated how Prophet Mohd PBUH has made the judgement, omar got enraged and he killed the hypocrite muslim saying that if you did not accept Muhammad's (Peace Be Upon Him)decision then you are not a Muslim you are a hypocrite.

Answer 3

I never heard the story but the ethics sound right, to a Muslim you are nothing if not a Muslim.

Answer 4

this person is imitating a good Muslim and asking anti-Muslim questions.