If a person commits suicide, will they be punished the same as committing murder?

Question

In the eyes of God?

Answer 1

An interesting observation.
Self murder.
You gave it forethought.
You planned it.
You carried it out.
The way we say murder.

You have a valid point.

The other side of the coin is insanity.
If crazy, are you held responsible?

I'm glad He is the judge, aren't you?

Answer 2

How can they be punished like a murderer if they are already dead? Now, if you are talking about ATTEMPTED suicide, that's different. That is punishable by law but I do not believe to the same severity as a murderer.

Answer 3

i grew to alter into into raised Catholic, and so I understand your chum's recommendations-set. it truly is doctrine that suicide is a mortal sin; i grew to alter into into taught that it truly is a rejection of the present of existence that God has given us. Logically inspite of the undeniable fact that, our souls are immortal, so what's to reject? The physique is definitely much less substantial in that philosophy than the soul is. yet it is Catholic doctrine. i'm no longer Catholic any further, yet as quickly as we are discussing mortal sin, it inevitably might desire to be from the Catholic recommendations-set, through actuality i do no longer think of of any of the a number of faiths have the thought-approximately mortal sin. through actuality you're soliciting for our suggestions on the concern--i'm no longer Catholic any further, as i discussed, so i do no longer think of in mortal sin any further, or perchance judgment inevitably. i've got have been given faith that we %. our own strikes in accordance to our guy or lady ethical and ethical codes, and can gain this for further considerate reasons than uncomplicated advantages/punishment.

Answer 4

That's a question you'd have to ask God himself - but, I believe personally that there should be an ear of caution put there...afterall, couldn't suicide be called "Self-Murder"?

Meanwhile, anyone who committs suicide isn't in their right mind, so WHO KNOWS FOR SURE!???

God is the only one who can determine for sure the destination of such an individual.

Answer 5

You cannot get PUNISHED if you DIE.
And this has nothing to do with GODS EYES.
IF you ATTEMPT SUICIDE and do not make it you will be taken to a MENTAL WARD to be locked up for 24 minimal hours or MORE for observation, then you will be STRONGLY encouraged to go to therapy and take DRUGS...to 'help' you with these thoughts, those DRUGS will ruin your life and mess it up worse than before.

Answer 6

I don't believe in God so I'd say neither. If you kill someone lets just hope the cops get you and you get to stay the rest of your life in prison. If you commit suicide, well that's selfish for whoever you leave behind....

Answer 7

i dont believe in god either, but id say that no theyu shouldnt be punished that same and comiting murder, because murder was takign someone elses life, someone who wanted to live. by murdering you forceivly take everything from someone. with suicide you are willingly taking you own life. it is your decision, and a choice you make with free will. you shouldnt be punished for that, its just what you think is best.

Answer 8

All sin is a violation of God's will and commandment. Sinners need a Savior who will/did bear the punishment for their own sins.

Suicide is the ultimate act of selfishness.

Only God is worthy of determining the answer to your question.

Answer 9

All sinners will be punished the same. To a perfectly holy and righteous being, disobedience is disobedience. To us, murder is much worse than lying, but to the creator of the universe who is much greater, the difference is nil. This is why we must repent of our sin and turn to Christ's sacrifice to be cleansed.

Answer 10

THE tragic news of a suicide does not close a chapter in the lives of relatives and friends; it opens one—a chapter of mixed feelings of pity and anger, sorrow and guilt. And it raises the question: May we entertain any hope for our friend who took his or her life?

Although self-inflicted death is never justified, never righteous, the apostle Paul did hold out a beautiful hope for even some unrighteous ones. As he told a Roman court of law: “I have hope toward God . . . that there is going to be a resurrection of both the righteous and the unrighteous.”—Acts 24:15.
Many theologians have long dismissed any suggestion that the resurrection of the unrighteous might offer hope for those who commit suicide. Why?

Centuries ago, churchmen introduced a non-Biblical concept: immortal souls that leave the body at death and go straight to heaven, purgatory, Limbo, or hell. That concept clashed with the Bible’s clear teaching of a future resurrection. As Baptist minister Charles Andrews asked: “If the soul is already blissfully in heaven (or is already justifiably roasting in hell), what need is there for anything further?” He added: “This inner contradiction has remained to plague Christians throughout the centuries.”

One result of such errant theology was that “since Augustine’s time [354-430 C.E.], the church has condemned suicide as a sin,” says Arthur Droge in the Bible Review, “a sin beyond redemption, just like apostasy and adultery.”

Jesus told a criminal sentenced to death: “You will be with me in Paradise.” The man was unrighteous—a lawbreaker rather than a distraught suicide victim—guilty by his own frank admission. (Luke 23:39-43) He had no hope of going to heaven to rule with Jesus. So the Paradise in which this thief could hope to come back to life would be the beautiful earth under the rule of Jehovah God’s Kingdom.—Matthew 6:9, 10; Revelation 21:1-4.

For what purpose will God awaken this criminal? So that He mercilessly can hold his past sins against him? Hardly, for Romans 6:7, 23 says: “He who has died has been acquitted from his sin,” and “the wages sin pays is death.” Although his past sins will not be accounted to him, he will still need the ransom to lift him to perfection.

Only God can fully understand the role of mental sickness, extreme stress, even genetic defects, in a “suicidal crisis,” which, the National Observer noted, “is not a lifetime characteristic [but] often a matter only of minutes or of hours.”
Granted, one who takes his own life deprives himself of the opportunity to repent of his self-murder. But who can say whether one driven to suicide might have had a change of heart had his fatal attempt failed? Some notorious murderers have, in fact, changed and earned God’s forgiveness during their lifetime.
Thus, Jehovah, having paid “a ransom in exchange for many,” His Son, is within his right to extend mercy, even to some self-murderers, by resurrecting them and giving them the precious opportunity to “repent and turn to God by doing works that befit repentance.”

The Scriptures encourage us to see ourselves, not as immortal souls, but as valuable creations of the God who loves us, who treasures our being alive, and who looks forward with joy to the time of the resurrection.

4000 years had passed from Adam & Eve, Jesus said to a Religious Leader that no one had gone to Heaven, and millions of people had passed away in death. This is a quote from the King James Bible:

John 3:13 " And no man hath ascended up to heaven, but he that came down from heaven,"
it seems to me, this would eliminate the "immortal soul" belief, not only that, if you go to Heaven or Hell when you die, you completely do away with the resurrection that the Bible speaks about, because the resurrection is suppose to take place after Jesus comes the second time, and that has not happened.