Birth of Islam from my point of view, whats yours?

Question

The Quran was written some time in 600 AD or later, which is some 600 years after Jesus Christ came into this world, which means that there were a lot of people who knew the teachings of Jesus Christ and accepted it.

Now comes Mohammad the prophet, looks around, sees the following for Jesus, and says, hey why can't it be me? and then starts his own religion and notices that people are not coming to him.

So what does he do?

Makes changes to the contents of the bible with the help of some learned men (got access to it somehow by plundering someplace) to his liking (keeping in mind that he cannot say anything too bad about Jesus Christ)(Probably fearing for his life from more powerful tribesmen, who follow Christianity).

Creates terrorism by killing & terrorising people who do not follow his ways, and Islam is born,

He's also hidden or destroyed parts of the original Bible & then says only the Quran is Original.

What do you people think, could it be this way?

Answer 1

Thank-you very much for this Info.
I started to Study this Religion while back.
This Idea of your's could Explain Alot of what I have been Studying.
Thank's.

Answer 2

Of course not. This is total nonsense.

These words, the words of the Quran, are revelations from the very same God who gave the Bible its words and meaning. This is why much of the words, concepts and meanings are similar: because Prophet Muhammad was preaching the words of God, the true words. You say he changed Jesus' words; it happens to be that the opposite is true. Followers of Jesus decided that they didn't like some of what Jesus said, so they made the decision to change the parts they didn't like but keep the other parts. This gave birth to differences in Christianity, such as Catholicism, Protestantism and so on.

Muhammad (pbuh) did not say that only the Quran is original. He said that there had been an original Bible, but it had been corrupted. All of you Christians acknowledge the fact that the Bible has been written many times over, translated, and even had words written differently in some cases. You say that it was changed, but the meaning in general has stayed the same. How do you know this? How do you know that the meanings and metaphors haven't changed too?

The Prophet did not create terrorism, either. Read up more on the true story of the birth of Islam, and you'll see what the people of Mecca used to do to him. Terrorism? I don't think so.

Answer 3

The Quran according to Islam is directly from God and not written by Muhammed. It puts Jesus and Mary in high regard and even dedicates chapter on Mary. It also mentions that Jesus was the only person born without sin. Jesus is also mentioned much more than Muhammed. Evidently based on the Quran, God holds Jesus as a VIP but Islam holds Muhammed in a higher regard?

I have yet received any satisfactory answer to my questions regarding the Quran.

Answer 4

He was an ILLITERATE and was a MERCHANT.

illiterate = not educated
Now i ask you, can someone who is not educated make a great book like Qur`an? Hadiths that can make people healthy sipiritually and physically? Can He?

'Probably fearing for his life from more powerful tribesmen, who follow Christianity'. Mmmm.... I think not. Please read more about his biography, the time, etc. He even sent a message to the king of the roman empire, and persian empire, to convert to Islam.

merchant = unreligious
Now, should I ask you again?


He is a real miracle. Sent to people from Allah almighty.

Some Miracles:
When recieving Qur`an, His body shakes and sweats even when it was cold, He was crying then. Can anybody make a false tear?

Answer 5

look .. i donno if red the Quran or not but i did cuz i know arabic well and i pretty sure that these words will never come from a human ,
2nd if the islam was just a religion like any religion u wouldn't find ppl likes it and ppl hate it , and don talk about terrorism cuz if u can look around u u will find wars every where in the world and the only ppl who does the mess in the world is america and israel and u watch the news u will find america and israel is a part of any war and any fights , 3rd the original Bible is alive in Rome if u wanna see it but u can't read it cuz u will find facts that will change ur mind about everything in our world .

Answer 6

The birth of Islam was not to oppose basically Christianity but Hinduism because at the time when Prophet came into existence there were not many Christians in that particular region where Prophet came into existence but Hindus (or Aryas as they were called at that time) were all over and that is why that most of the teachings of Islam go against Hinduism like - Vegetarianism, Bigamy, Idolatry etc. etc.

Answer 7

ROFLMAO!!
Good imagination, there Bucko...hey, it could have been this way!
I doubt it, but hey...it could have!

But...what parts of the original Bible did the little troll hide or destroy? That's what I wanna know! I mean, if I were gonna do it that way, I would have definitely gotten rid of the whole Abraham-Sarah-Hagar story. Anyone who reads and understands that story is gonna know right away that Ishmael (the father of Arabia) is NOT the Son of Promise...heck, the kid isn't even legitimate! He got himself and his mom kicked out with his attitude...making fun of the lady of the house who was nursing the heir probably wasn't a very bright move, especially since his own mom was nothing but a slave of the house, and owned by that same lady, to boot! Nope, I definitely would have gotten rid of that story. I wouldn't want to advertise the fact that my entire nation springs from a wise *** kid who had no more brains than an insect. Otherwise.....

Answer 8

no. Mohammed was born in Arabia, not places like Jerusalem and Bethlehem. and the ancient Arabs were pagans - they worshipped Nature, not Jesus. they did all sorts of stuff to please Nature and have rains and good crops and stuff. Mohammed received a Revelation brought to him by Angel Gabriel in the cave of Hera, and he was instructed on how to guide his people, the pagan nomadic Arabs. Mohammed didn't create terrorism - he didn't terrorise people, it was the people of Makkah, the people of his own tribe - Qu'raish, who turned and plotted against him. Mohammed and his friends and followers fought because the Quraish people were attacking them - they meant to kill Mohammed. but Mohammed knew he had to go on preaching his religion, whatever the situation - and hence, after a period of time, the Arab pagans finally accepted Islam.

Answer 9

Congratulations , you CAN rationalize ..
Bit insulted u call mohmed "prophet" , but
otherwise ok..

100 years BC , had only the Sun , Moon
and Mars to pray to.
SOMETHING WENT AWRY ! ....

Damn those bloody goat-shepherds ., with
nothing better to do ....

Answer 10

that is the birth of Islam from someone without any knowlege at all, some who is likely to be on crack