Is religion now a force for good or evil within western society?

Question

According to this article in the Journal of Religion and Society, the most religious of the western countries seem to have the highest rates of murder (see Figure 2 half way down if you don't want to read it all) plus std's, teen pregnancy, abortion etc.
http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/2005/2005-11.html

In addition, although it's not nice to say it, many western countries who have accepted a large muslim community, seem to be suffering from an epidemic of rape, by a small minority of 'muslim' men against non-muslim women and girls
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=20646

Do you agree with the conclusions of the articles, that religion creates an 'us and them' mentality within society, whereby people who do not adhere to the values of another person, are considered less-human and 'fair game' by many people?

Or is there another explanation?

No offensive answers PLEASE, we are all human

i guess 'Let's Talk' is one of the people described in the articles

Answer 1

I think that religion definitely creates an "us" and a "them". By uniting one group of people with the same values it creates a group that doesn't have those values. Many people place to much worth on whether or not you are the same as them and with what word you define your belief with. In actuality, most religions hold the same morals and values in high esteem, but they also say that if someone belongs to a different religion, they are the enemy.

Answer 2

We are all human, yes. I wish more people would remember that.

But it is only my opinion, but I think that the "Religious Right" is intentionally making it so - religion a force for good or evil.

Why? I don't really know, but I bet the bottom line is $$$

Answer 3

Yes, if the believers are willing to place their religion ahead of their own lives (if you were asked to die for your religion, would you do so?) Once that happens, it's very easy to place your religion over others' lives as well. Also, since you're a believer, and your religion is more important than your life, non-believers automatically become inferior to you.

Answer 4

I don't know, but if we are going to survive this century we need to throw a lot of funding at some extensive and unbiassed research to discover whether religion benefits society as it claims to or whether those claims are false. But do you think it's likely that funding will be provided for research like this?...it really should be.

Answer 5

If someone follows the true teaching of his or her religion, the problem will not occur. Every religion in this planet, urge people to do good and avoid evil.

Answer 6

i think of there is tension to coach understand to each faith. yet i do no longer - religious human beings could desire to pay attention opposing viewpoints, particularly for any of them who're secretly doubting all the nonsense they have been taught. by refusing to coach understand for ideals we expect of are bunk we supply a manner out to those who could elect to stay greater efficient, greater ethical lives.

Answer 7

i would say 50/50

Answer 8

you are so very sad