Ok I am gona believe Islam is true.
In Islam says that if you do something bad then Allah will send you directly to the hell.!!
My argument:
Islam appeared 1400 years ago,so what is the judgment of your Allah about Milions of people lived and died before 1400 years, and before apearing of Islam?
If your Allah wants to send them to hell because of their sin then if they say we didn't know about Islam at that time so you cannot send us to hell !!
How would your Kind Allah solve this problem?
or do you think with out any jugdment they would be sent to the hell by your kind Allha?
If you want to say there were many prophits sent before Islam, about 170000 prophit !! to guide people to the right way.
So please give a good prove of them in a scientific historical book?
2006-08-22 04:26:49 · 26 answers · asked by Hitomi Love 1 in Society & Culture ➔ Religion & Spirituality
Dear Hitomi,
You had ask very normal questions but your asking style is bad...Anyway...
I am a Muslim(Alevi).
I will try to answer your questions.
Islam do not say that "if you do something bad then Allah will send you directly to the hell".
Islam say that " If you do not be respectful to the people,if you do not use your brain and talent,if you use your mind for bad things and not control yourself.You will be punish in the world or in the other world".
You are saying " Your Allah" it is not respectful.Allah has 99 different name in our language.Allah means God in english.There is only one God and it is our God.Our=All over the worlds people.Accept or not...
"what is the judgment of your Allah about Milions of people lived and died before 1400 years, and before apearing of Islam?"
God did not give us electric.We found electric tousent years later.We found it with our brain right? Because "Our" God gave us mind.So before Islam all humans had brain and mind too my dear friend.We could think what is good what is bad and make our behaviours on this way...Islam did not gave us brain.Just put light on our way... What were the people doing before Jesus Christ?
"Your kind Allah" Did you see what you write?This is not respectful.That's why it is sin for us.You are not showing respect to our religion. So will you burn in hell for that? I don't think so...God has own way to give you punish or solve your problems.
God do not give you hammer when your are reparing your roof or not look after you when you are ill.But he can make the weather well when you are working on the roof and can give you nice person who will look after you when you are ill.Who can knows his way of help or punish?
"please give a good prove of them in a scientific historical book?"
Can you give me a scientific book about Jesus? ok...Can you give me a scientific book about Zeus or Hercules?
You are asking a question with out thinking...
God Bless You my dear friend...
2006-08-22 05:14:13 · answer #1 · answered by TURKISH 4 · 0⤊ 0⤋
" ........ How would your Kind Allah solve this problem? ......."
There is not a problem, problem is yours .
When I read your question, and before reading the part related to the previous prophets, I thought you really want the truth you don't know, but once I've read the last paragraph in your question, I felt like you are just trying to make fun of our beliefs as Muslims .
And about your demand for a "good proof of them in a scientific historical book" it's completely invalid, as simply science was not interested in this stuff of Prophets, religions or whatever, science didn't even take an organized form at those old times .
Or else Christians also are required to give us "a good prove of them in a scientific historical book" .
Come on, you are not interested in the truth, you just want to put Islam in an embarrassing situation, but I'll be glad to tell you that neither you nor the world put together can do so because simply Islam is the only true religion now in the world .
2006-08-22 11:56:24 · answer #2 · answered by Green visitor is back :D 5 · 0⤊ 0⤋
First of all, please don't make it sound like Allah is a different God or the Muslim God because this is pure bull****. Allah means Almighty God in Arabic and was used by Arab Jews and Christians long before Islam ever existed and actually until today.
Secondly, if you do something bad God will NOT send you to hell right away. What we believe in is that the person is judged by the outcome of his work (words, actions and heart). No person is free from sin. Everybody sins, the question is at the end of the day were you a good person or a bad person overall.
It actually makes perfect sense that if you are a killer or a rapist you deserve to be punished for your sins. However, if you repent to God he will forgive you if you are sincere. It's just common sense. Read the Quran instead of talking crap. Sorry.
Now about your question, first of all it is quite clear form Islam and other religions that if no prophets were sent to you then God will not judge you based on your belief because no one was there to warn you. God will not judge people except if they were warned. God loves all his creatures especially mankind and will judge people relatively. This means that God will judge people based on what they understand and what they have inside of them. If we were raised in the same house and live together all our lives we would still be judged differently. One thing to be sure of is that GOD is FAIR and MERCIFUL and his WISDOM and KNOWLEDGE are INFINITE.
Peace...
2006-08-22 11:59:19 · answer #3 · answered by Zero 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋
Good Question. Allah will not send the other ones to hell who existed before Islam because it is called in Arabic 'Zaman AL Jahiliya' which means the time of no-understanding either the religion itself or the sins they did (which are not counted as sins though), because they didn't know that what they were doing is not accepted and forbidden or is correct and allowed or simply a must.
After my answer, I have to say: I am not GOD.. so God Knows the answer.. I could be wrong & I could be right. I heard and read alot about this subject.. most of them say "leave such mysterious questions behind that only GOD himself knows the answers to them and you will know the answers on judjement day.
Sometimes it's just good to leave the answer behind you and continue your normal life without thinking about the question again. I hope my message is understood.
2006-08-22 11:46:29 · answer #4 · answered by Unique 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
"give a good prove of them in a scientific historical book"
That about sums up this post. Islam is based on precisely the same precept that Christianity is, that is, three quarters or more of the planet are condemned to an eternity in hell for the sin of not-believing by a merciful and loving God.
It presents a philosophical dilemma that can only be overcome through faith, and not by quoting a "historical scientific book"
2006-08-22 11:36:47 · answer #5 · answered by corpuscollossus 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
We all know that Allah the Almighty, being the Creator, Protector and Sustainer of the universe has taken the responsibility of giving guidance to the people. For this purpose He has sent Messengers to all places in all times with glad tidings for the good doers and severe warnings of punishment to those who reject the divine Message.
Allah has revealed divine books and pages of instructions to several prophets. But all the prophets before Mohammad (pbuh) were sent to a particular time and to a particular community. Their messages were confined to their respective areas. That is why the books revealed to them are not found now in the original form, though some copies with enough additions and omissions are kept with some communities and they consider it divine still today.
A sincere attempt to see the actual conditions of these scripts reveals that Allah has sent Taurat to Moosa (Moses), Injeel to Isa (Jesus) and Zaboor to Dawood (David) - peace be on them - before the prophethood of Mohammad (pbuh). Originally all these were from Allah with divine instructions to their community. But by the passage of time the followers of those books misinterpreted the verses and made their own words in the book so as to suit and safeguard their interests.
2006-08-22 12:23:25 · answer #6 · answered by Affu Q 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
The main, basic premise in Judaism, Christianity, AND Islam is the worship of only one god - God. And the concept of the Golden Rule. Basic, common sense stuff. All of the prophets throughout time tried to get this same point across to the people. Including Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad. The same message every time. Muhammad was the final prophet - God has not given us any more chances after that.
If people throughout the history of time heard the message that all of these prophets taught - One God, and the Golden Rule - and still chose to ignore it and do what they wanted, then how could they deserve Heaven? No more excuses!
2006-08-22 11:42:53 · answer #7 · answered by Mahira 3 · 1⤊ 0⤋
There's a HUUUGE misunderstanding here. It's very unfair and illogical to assume that as a non-Muslim.
God said that he's the One who forgives all sins. No one goes "straight to hell." God is all merciful. He said he loves his creatures and forgives them.
Secondly, those who lived before Islam will be judged according to their faith at that time. For instance, the Jews will be judged as whether they properly followed Moses and their holy book. The same applies to the Christians.
Adam, the first man created on earth, was a prophet who had the same message as any other prophet. He called for goodwill and forbade evil. So those who did not follow God's teachings that were sent to Adam will be judged according to that. The same idea applies to all people who lived during all the eras of all prophets.
2006-08-22 11:54:38 · answer #8 · answered by Confused 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
im a muslim myself and i'll tell u that they wont be sent to hell or heaven without judgment,Islamic rules are based on the truth,and the good behavior,that all ppl believe such as being kind to others and even animals ,not to be mean ,stingy ,bad tempered and so on which r not good ion all cultures,so our Allah judges ppl.he is so kind...
follow this link ,u'll find lots of answers of ur Qs and more u can ask me i will be glad to answer them:
http://www.sultan.org/
peace be upon u
2006-08-22 11:57:23 · answer #9 · answered by samane 2 · 0⤊ 0⤋
as you said there were many praphits before prophit mohammad
you must know that islam has many ruls many dificult ruls .so if God would have send to the people at first islam because of the dificulty people would not agry with that so God send many prophits to let people to come to him step by step .and at last he send prophit mohammad to continue these steps to him.and i am dont saying that every moslam people are not going to hell even if they say that they belive God its not true because if they belived god and his is allways looking that them then they wouldnt do thing that God said to not do.
so how ever no one is going to hell .i mean the ones who believed and blieves God .and does good things.and if you like or you dont our God is one. islam belives christian & jewish and mayby you guys dont.but we go for one with difirent rules.
2006-08-22 12:00:15 · answer #10 · answered by dizy r 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋