Girls if a guy wrote a song for you would you want him to perform it on stage?

Question

I wrote a beautiful love song for my girl but she doesn't want me to perform it. Do you think I should sing it anyway?

Answer 1

no would i hell for one my fella cant sing he sounds like a cat being strangled, jesus just think of all the windows that would need replacing

Answer 2

hmm it depends how old r u both. cous as i know teenager can be a little shy about it. i m 21 and i would love if guy would sing for me.. if off course he is talented. but also if not so also would listen him. but some girls this can make shy then if she really serious told u that sje doesn't want u do a perform just don't do. just sing for her when u r alone. some ppl like to love just in two.. why all world hv to know how much u love her. enough u show it her.. and u wrote song.. i m sure she is happy for that. but if about me also. u should not hv asked if she wanna just do it, maybe she would not get angry. but all depends how old is she..

Answer 3

I had this really amazing and talented guy write not one but two songs for me...(i lucked out...) and it was so very intimate and meant so much to me that he performed them for just me although, I wouldnt have minded if he performed them for others because they were really good songs (and no im not being biased...). However, she might not want you to because they are special to her and she wants those songs to be for her and just her which I completely understand. I think before you perform them, you should talk to her about it. I mean I understand they are your creations but is it really worth it to sing them at the expense of upsetting the one that they were originally written for or about? Good luck and just talk to her about it first and maybe she'll come around....

Answer 4

respect her wishes
if it was ''for her'' then its for her and her only if you sing it on stage some other girls might think its about them. BUt if you really want to perform it ask your gf if you can dedicate it to her or when on stage say you wrote it for her.

Answer 5

i would love if someone wrote a song about me but if she isn't comfortable change the name and sing the song she should be happy, most girls would like that

Answer 6

if a guy found the time to think about me and to care enough to write me a song i'ld say hell yeah i'ld want him to perform on stage coz it only shows how special i am to him so nomatter how awful he sounds i would love for the world to know i'm appreciated and loved and my man wants the world to know he loves me...but if she doesnt want u to sing it then it's all good anyway,i'm sure she has a very good reason for it.

Answer 7

i stumble on it annoying. i do no longer choose to pay attention a toddler, i choose to pay attention the band. BQ: a lot of circumstances. i replaced into in band from seventh -12th grade, and that i think of we did a play interior the third grade. Marching band replaced into the terrific in spite of the undeniable fact that. BQ2: i pass with you in this one. I heard a narrative that Paul McCartney as quickly as desperate to apply each and every tool interior the studio in one music. It did no longer sound sturdy.

Answer 8

I'd want you to sing it on stage! Yeah!!! Why doesn't she want you to sing it? Who knows... It may be the typical woman thing - I say no, but mean yes!???

Go for it - you studdly romantic you!!!

Answer 9

Id play it for her in private and if she likes Id sing it for her in public.

Answer 10

Dont do it if she doesnt want you to. It might embarrass her. She probably really loves the song but wants it to be just between you too.