Why would shooting illegal immigrants that try to enter this country be considered inhumane?

Question

After all, they are breaking the law and we shoot prison inmates that break out of prison every single day. I'm not racist, and this is for all illegal immigrants (haitian, mexican, jamaican, cuban, etc) Tell me what do you think!

Shooting at illegals is a human rights violations because people can be processed properly and allowed to return peacefully to their country not inside coffins or death bags.

I hear what you are saying, but wouldn't shooting make them think twice about crossing the border or coming by ship, etc?

Im not in favor of concentration camps, AND I LOVE ALL PEOPLE!!! regardless of race or ethnicity!! But I personally feel that illegal immigration is a serious problem that need to be dealt with. In one of my questions, one person said that the best thing to do would be to shoot them on site, but he also said that would not be the right thing to do. Therefore I asked this question to get everyones feedback.

Thank you for all people that are answering the question intelligently!!

Answer 1

Shooting at illegals is a human rights violations because people can be processed properly and allowed to return peacefully to their country not inside coffins or death bags.

Answer 2

Not As Target Practice

Deadly Force Should Be Authorized WITH DISCRETION
There Are Other (Non-Lethal) Alternatives

Shoot To Kill Should Be An Option
But As A Last Resort

Our BORDER PATROL AGENTS Acted Accordingly
They Were On The Job Performing Their Duty
They Stopped A Truckload (800 Lbs.) Of Marijuana

It Could Have Been A WMD

Our BORDER PATROL AGENTS Should Be COMMENDED
For A Job Well Done
They Were PATROLLING The BORDER
And Defending Our Nation
A Disgraceful Perversion Of Justice



WHAT Due Process??
Why Drag An ILLEGAL ALIEN Into The Judicial System ??

When You CATCH HIM JUMPING THE FENCE
Or Arrest Him In Commision Of A Crime
And His Immigration Status Is ILLEGAL
He's Discovered
WHOOOPS !!
Traffic Stop ??
Expired VISA ??
Car Accident ??
Hospital Visit ??
Domestic Disturbance??

You're An ILLEGAL ALIEN ??
You're Discovered ??
You're Deported ...

Due Process ??
What About The DUE PROCESS
Of IMMIGRATION LAWS??
Those Dont Count??

You Want Due Process Only When Its Convenient,
But When Due Process Is Too Much Of A Hassle
You Wanna SKIP That Due Process


DEPORT ALL ILLEGAL ALIENS UPON DISCOVERY

Charge : ILLEGAL ENTRY Of The Nation
Disposition : GUILTY
Sentence : IMMEDIATELY DEPORTED UPON DISCOVERY
No Judge
No Jury
No Jail

You Have The Right To Speedy Transportation
To One Free Humane Military Style Planeride
To The Point FARTHEST From The USA
In Your Nation Of Origin
Courtesy Of The Taxpayers

Thats An Easy Trip Home Compared To A Desert Crossing




WTF Are You Talkin About Extermination ??
Concentration Camps ?? HaHaHaLMFAOff

Nobody Gettin Exterminated
Just Quickly DEPORTED UPON DISCOVERY

We're Gonna Reunite Them
With Those Heartbroken Families They Left Behind
The Ones They're Always Tryin To Break Our Hearts With
The Ones They Send Billions Of US Dollars To
The Ones They Abandoned
To Stupidly Cross The Desert
And ILLEGALLY Enter The USA

Answer 3

Cops aren't allowed to shoot unarmed suspects in the streets. The people crossing the boarder are suspects and not even of a felony. If the border patrol agents stopped a suspect van and found it full of illegals would you advocate them opening fire into the back of the van? What about Cubans coming to Florida? Should the cops stand on the beach, wait for the people to come ashore, then open fire? We can handle this problem without becoming barbarians. It takes a combination of money, diplomacy and political will.

Answer 4

You say that "shooting make them think twice about crossing the border or coming by ship, etc?" and I tell you, It is the fact that they are hungry and need a job, the reason that they don't think twice and cross the border, or violate their visa permit and stay. It is proven that the majority of illegal immigrants are not here because they crossed the border but because they got a visa and decided to stay. Wouldn't you go find a job anywhere, if your family was hungry? or would you let them die.

Answer 5

While I do not like it that our country is flooded with illegals. I am NOT in favor of shooting illegals. Law enforcement has many tactics they can rely on without shooting first then asking questions.

If that starts happening they are only going to come across the border armed. Which will open a new can of worms.

Answer 6

because our united states is run via a set of pansies who're more beneficial in touch with being re-elected than the more beneficial solid. in the experience that they get up for the regulation, they are going to be offending someone who might want to have a chum right here illegally, and then they would not get their vote. Or they are afraid they are going to be offending a particular nationality and then they would not get lots of of votes. AWWWW! not helping unlawful immigration does not make someone a racist. it truly is the type of crock. Being an unlawful immigrant is a criminal offense (for this reason the be conscious unlawful)!!! in the experience that they prefer to be in this united states and artwork flat out and flow by ability of the right channels to get citizenship, it truly is a thoroughly honorable and good element. there's a Hispanic guy who works at Walmart, and that i have a large number of recognize for him. Why? because on that "Day without immigrants" element, he confirmed up for artwork!! He had to be there and had each and every good to be there and became happy with it! His statement spoke more beneficial to me more beneficial loud and sparkling than any of those people available who're whining about how unfair it truly is to deliver people abode who do not belong right here! If people favor to go back stay in this united states, it truly is wonderful, do exactly not destroy the regulation and suck off of taxpayers even as doing it!

Answer 7

Its against the law to shoot someone that has broken into your home while they are exiting. That is inhumane,so is shooting an illegal that is trying to break into America.Inmates have been charged with a crime and convicted.Not every crime warrants being shot.

Answer 8

For an educated man who would not confront his accuser when your black race was insulted by the post "Lynch Mob," -- you answered his question and showed who the better person was by signing him off with your blessing.

Your question is 180 out from the intelligence and class you showed to Lynch Mob's insult!

Here, you take the same brain power and post something as ridiculous as this. Oh, no, you're not a racist; you just don't understand due process within the laws of the US. What a farce!

Inmates have already been through due process, and even they have rights; you don't go out much, do you?

Answer 9

First of all, you can't go around shooting illegals, that's not the way our system works....Its called due process "No person shall be... deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law...." Its about their human rights, which they are still entitled too.....In your world, would you have concentration camps all along the border and eventually exterminate these people, they are still people, not animals!?

Answer 10

I was born in Jamaica and I've never heard of a Jamaican who was trying to enter the country. They usually come then they decide to stay afterwhich they start the process of legalising themselves. I think shooting illegal immigrants is inhumane and your sick to even think of something like that.