Is it wrong to have a vasectomy? Christians only please.?

Question

My husband had a vasectomy, do you think it is wrong in the eyes of God, if so, is it no different than using any form of birth control?

Answer 1

Well, I think you’re right in classifying it as just one more method of birth control – which it is, just a long-term one.

So the question is more, “Is birth control wrong?”

I don’t really know a solid answer to that. The two basic sides are:
(1) Birth control interferes with the natural process that God established, so it tries to “play God” and shouldn’t be used.
(2) People only have limited resources in life and are responsible to God for managing those resources.

Both arguments have some truth to them, which is why the issue does not die.

The main reason I think birth control has created issues is because it has separated the sexual act from the procreative act. Without effective birth control, sex was not just sex, it was also the very real possibility of creating another living human being – so it was always understood and lived out in that context.

And that context tailored how people viewed the “sex” element – love and commitment really had to be part of the sex act, idealistically. It would result in a family.

Nowadays, since sex can be easily separated from procreation, we have lots of people having sex outside a committed relationship and later being hurt when the relationship is broken. We also have children being born to people who are not committed to establishing a family, resulting in negligence, abuse, or abandonment. We have abortion for those who don’t or can’t deal with the idea of a baby. Birth control helps us manage our practical resources better, but it has also changed how we view and act within our relationships.

I wish there was a definitive answer. At the very least, a couple has to reach their decision together, with lots of prayer and evaluation of what God has given them. In any case, children should always be looked upon joyfully, as new and growing individuals.

Answer 2

each and every so often a vasectomy is mandatory, no longer for the guy yet for the girl. If a woman has particular well being circumstances and is advised it would be existence threatening for her to alter into pregnant then its in all danger that any surgical treatment (hysterectomy, tubes tied) may be risky besides. it rather is then stated that the husband have a vasectomy. I additionally think of its honest, via fact the girl did supply beginning, and that's no day on the park. men who refuse a vasectomy for no reason are selfish. okay to answer the question, Catholics view any variety of beginning administration (aside from 'ovulation watching") as a sin. Its ridiculous. i think intercourse is organic and birth control is clever. Catholics exchange their innovations actual speedy while their unwed teen daughter comes abode pregnant. Do what's terrific for your self and your companion.

Answer 3

The Bible doesn't speak against either birth control or sex for reasons other than procreation.

When Onan was killed (Genesis 38:9), it was because he was refusing to father a child in his brother's name. As long as no child was born, Onan was the heir, but if the child was born, he would be the heir. He was slain for disobedience and greed.

Part of the reason people think that sex is only for reproduction is the false view that the flesh is evil, and therefore anything good to the flesh is evil. Flesh is not evil; cut off your arm and see how many crimes it commits without your spirit to restrain it. The ancient Gnostics thought that a perfect God couldn't have made sinful flesh, and thought that God made a lesser god who made a lesser god, and that we are all children of a lesser god. They thought that women were evil for taking perfect souls and imprisoning them in evil flesh in conception. This is also where the false belief of the perpetual virginity of Mary comes from, also (it would have been sinful for her to remain a virgin, 1Cor 7:5).

Answer 4

It would be considered a sin by the catholics. No birth control allowed - only the rhythm method. There's no medical reason to have a vsection, other than prevention of pregnancy. And they're very very down on that.

Answer 5

NOPE. I've heard of box male and female getting it done, and still having a baby. nothing wrong with birth control. Iy you dont want kids, do it.

Answer 6

God gave all of us right to do what we want, as long as we are not hurting anyone.If you want a vasectomy me ,you should have it done,GOD will accept it.



Giselle

Answer 7

.....absolutely not......if UR really sorry 4 it or anything else U have done that makes U feel bad about UR self and notice ABOUT URSELF.....GOD does not condemn anyone were 2 busy condemning ourselves and EVERYONE else .........what a game we play....GOD loves U no matter what U have done or failed 2 do......GOD knows were all F.U.C.K.E.D. and basically mentally ill....just pray 4 his meds 2 help U everyday....im a minor catholic and had it done but felt jewish guilt and i talked 2 my priest .....he just smiled and said im kiking myself 2 much in life and just ask GOD 4 my daily meds

Answer 8

Nah, if God really wants you to get pregnant again, there will be a "miracle baby".

Answer 9

If you have for the right reasons..that you both agree ..have no more children..its right,,,,beside bore them now let him do his thing

Answer 10

no way, my mom is a true christian n zhe has had tubectomy. i don think it is wrong or else my mom wud rather be dead than do something lyk this.......