what is the religious belief for circumcision in Muslims and Jews is it the same or different ?

Answer 1

Circumcision, being an act of fitrah, reflects Islam’s keenness on preserving man’s health and personal hygiene. This is further clarified in the following:

Circumcision is a universal practice which is greatly influenced by cultural and religious traditions. It is the most frequent operation on males not only in Islamic countries, but also other parts of the world. For example, in the United States of America more than one million male infants are circumcised each year. The performance of circumcision is one of the rules of cleanliness in Islam.

The word fitrah in relation to cleanliness can refer to the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), with regard to this matter, and fitrah also 'implies an inner sense of cleanliness in man which is proof of his moral convictions and mental health.'

Male circumcision means removal of the foreskin of the penis. The Islamic scholar Al-Mawardi said, 'The ideal method is to remove the skin completely from the beginning of the glans, and the minimum condition is that nothing is left to cover the end of the glans." The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) recommended performing circumcision at an early age. Al- Mawardi stated that the chosen time is the 7th day after birth, but it can be carried out up to 40 days after birth or thereafter until the age of 7 years, depending upon the health of the infant or child at the time.

There is an ongoing debate on the value of neonatal circumcision. Indeed, the position of the American Academy of Pediatrics since 1975 has been that there are no valid or absolute medical indications for routine circumcision of newborn male infants. On the other hand, the results of recent clinical and epidemiological studies are supportive of the practice of circumcision in newborn and infant males. From a two-part study involving cohorts of 3,924 and 422,328 infants respectively Wiswell and Roscelli found a higher rate of urinary tract infection in uncircumcised compared with male circumcised infants. These investigators observed that as the circumcision frequency rate decreases, the incidence of urinary tract infections increases. Infection usually begins in the foreskin which becomes swollen and difficult to retract. A medium for bacterial growth and further spread of infection is provided by the fecal material trapped between the foreskin and glans of the penis. Such a condition probably leads to other more serious complications.

Proper hygienic care of the penis, which includes regular washing, will prevent some infections, but among children this is difficult to maintain and is probably not as effective as circumcision. Some conditions, such as phimosis, often lead to circumcision at a later age that could have been prevented if it had been performed earlier. The possible risk for long term urological complications in the infected, uncircumcised male infant has not been properly studied. It is known, however, that as many as 50% of male infants with urinary tract infections will subsequently reveal demonstrable radiologic abnormalities. Thus, the performance of circumcision and the practice of sunan Al-fitrah as recommended in Islam is medically beneficial and reflects the wisdom of the Islamic statements.”

Excerpted, with slight modifications, from http://www.islamzine.com

Answer 2

you've had lots of reliable solutions so I merely favor to say to @MZT the justifications all and distinctive seems thumbing you down is because this theory which has prevailed contained in the USA of a for therefore long. that is that the foreskin is a breeding floor for germs. Has been shown to be thoroughly incorrect! truly that's in straightforward words the alternative the enzyme equivalent to that produced with the help of the interest is an awesome destroyer of infections making lower than the foreskin between the most Hygienic places on the body. besides the undeniable fact that that's not 100% fool info ! you spot nature under no circumstances predicted human beings to change into keen about seeing the uncovered glan and hence did not assume stupid moms, fathers and medical doctors to commence yanking the foreskin back to bathe it that is what facilitates the an infection to take carry contained in the first position that's something human beings of Europe and Scandinavia have recognize for nicely (for ever) and strange ingredient is of each of the persons who migrated,to the USA of a and which now make up a large type of the gene pool of the USA of a nicely except for the Jews none of your ancestors circumcised or necessary to because additionally they recognize this ! What occurred did evaluation take a step back us of a or have you ever male change into genetically defective or per chance someone IS DOING something incorrect !

Answer 3

In the old testament there are physical works mentioned with prophecies to be fulfilled

but the new testament works are spiritual works fulfilled and almost all the old testament prophecies fulfilled.

Old testament – question paper & new testament – answer sheet

The generation of Abraham the twelve tribes who were slaves in Egypt – old testament where as the Generation of Christ from twelve disciples who are rescuing people from slavery to sins.

Old testament – children of Israel “ physically Jews from the tribe judah”

New testament- spiritual Jews.

So I can go on to explain the seed of Abraham, the sanctuary, the sacrifices, many prophecies, the law were fulfilled in one & only Christ Jesus.
But the following will explain what is circumcision, today, spiritually means:

Romans 2:28 For he is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outward in the flesh:
2:29 But he is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and circumcision is that] of the heart, in the spirit, and not in the letter; whose praise is not of men, but of God.

God bless.

Answer 4

It's the same reason on all 3 major mono-theistic religions, Jewish, Christian & Muslim. The Christians don't seem to be as fussed about following this Old Testament rule.

Answer 5

Desert dwellers where water is scarce didn't & possibly couldn't wash properly and so this was a brutal remedy...

There are no proven health benefits to circumcision , washing is the best way to maintain hygeine and condoms are the best protection against sexually transmitted diseases.

Answer 6

Same meaning. As in Torah ( old testimony) and Quran it is mentioned to do.

Answer 7

for jews its just the sign of the covenant with god. i dont know why muslims do it.

Answer 8

it is not a belief,,,, it is to clean yourself,,,

if u do it then when u pee it wont scatter,,, and your body will not leave any dirt inside,,,

something like that