Why do you think man invents gods?

Question

No matter if we are talking about christians, muslims, etc. The need to believe for them must be strong, to believe in something that doesn't give one shred of evidence. Is it weak minds?
I believe it is a way to deal with the unknowns of the universe, the fear of death, etc. What do you think? Will there be a day when science disproves supernatural beings so even the

Answer 1

Its called mythology. One needs it for most religions too. Thats why they are called belief systems.

Answer 2

The most primal instinct any creature has is that of survival.
Therefore, the most obvious fear would be that of not surviving.
Humans are intelligent enough to take that to the next level -
not just surviving for the next minute, but what it means for
a life time.

We know that we won't survive, and that terrifies us, at least
on one level.

The way we deal with that terror is to simply make it not
true - there must be an afterlife because I can't die because
I don't want to not survive.

The thing is - we have no tangible evidence of this other
state of being - but every time something happens that
we can't explain, the thing must be caused by things in
this other state - and those things become Gods.

By that logic, I suppose, people would assume that
all who die become Gods - that's not what I am getting at.

Our own fear of death makes us crave a place that is,
in some ways, magical. Gods are a logical extension of that.
They are also a logical extension of having events happen
beyond explanation.

They also form the ultimate tribal leader - that is, the
ultimate protection. Again, we seek protection against
that which we cannot explain.

As we are able to explain more and more, the need for
God becomes less and less primal and far more philosophical.

Answer 3

Science = Natural
God = Supernatural

There will never be a way for science to disprove God, as the supernatural can't be proven or disproven with natural methods.

As for weak minds turning towards God, I'm sure there are instances when this is true, but some of the strongest minded people I've seen have been firm believers in God. This just isn't a one-conclusion-fits-all situation (and I've found that very few situations are).

Answer 4

It is pretty clear that men and women invented gods to try to understand the complex world around them and provide the first attempts to control that world.

To a primitive mind which would interpret the pleasant wind as a good spirit, or shadows in the forest as a evil spirit, it is quite reasonable to explain the world that way.

The ego or self of a person is the process that attempts to keep the body alive. It is reasonable for that process to buy into any religious idea that by saying some magic words the self can get eternal life. The self is easily fooled.

Religious dogma will end when the average IQ is raised 50 points and the average person has the where-with-all to not permit their self to be deluded. That should occur within the next 100 years with genetic engineering.

Answer 5

you're just looking for trouble aren't you. you know ancient philosophers and mathemeticians like scotrates and pythagoras worshipped a multitude of gods, so no it's not weak minds. unless you're so egotistical as to believe that you must be oh so intellectually superior because you're an atheist.

science will never disprove supernatural beings. And i'm not going to back this up with my personal beliefs that a God exists, but by the mere fact that the beings you're trying to disprove are 'supernatural' they evade reason and logic, which is the very core of science, that we are able to understand everything, that everything has an explanation, if only we can find it. Part of the concept of Supernatural beings is that they AREN'T fully understanable, they DON'T have a logical explanation- they're out of man's reach, no matter how hard we try. There will never be the sort of solid, concrete proof that you're looking for to disprove (or prove) the existence of beings that are beyond our brain's capacity of understanding.

So perhaps one could say that it is weak minded to believe that there is no higher power. You say that people probably 'invent' Gods to deal with the unknowns of life, making them weak minded. But really, believing in a God seems to prove otherwise. Someone who believes in a higher power is willing to push away this instinct to stay within the limits of their understanding and believe in something that they have no concrete proof for, no evidence. Like, it's easy for me to believe in my keyboard. I can see it, I can feel it as I type, I can hear it as I type. I have solid, concrete proof that it exists, so I can believe that it exists. However, I can't see God (in a single concrete form), I haven't physically heard God, I cannot touch God and see that He exists, but I still believe. It's hard, sometimes I wonder, and that's just because I'm human and seem to need to see, hear, feel, smell or whatever that something exists. But I still believe, and as I believe more, I start to develop a sixth sense, so to speak, that the God I believe in does exist. It's so hard to explain...but i'm done now. long answer I know.

Answer 6

There is no way to disprove faith. Faith is just there, which is why claiming something is true by explanation of faith is not science.

In answer to your question, I agree that man creates supernatural beings to explain what they cannot explain. Why they continue to worship gods after the unexplained is beaten into the ground with scientific evidence, I have no idea.

In my more cynical moments, I tend to believe that man created religion to control the masses. We're lucky I'm not cynical right now.

Answer 7

Fossil evidence. Do you think a dinosaur from 100 millions years ago really care about a "God". Do you know another animal in this planet that believe in a supernatural being?
You have to choices: believe by faith or believe by proof, It's your decision. Yes, humans invented the "Gods".

Answer 8

New physics string theory has hinted at 11 parallel universes co-existing on a single plain of space. Thats pretty supernatural to me. What if science proves the opposite?

Answer 9

Yes, man historically has attributed whatever was currently unexplainable to "gods". The Greeks had different gods for lightning, hurricanes, the sun, etc.

All of these phenomenom were explained by science throughout the ages, so belief in these gods disappeared.

Don't worry about current nutjobs who believe in religion, religions are always behind the curve when it comes to advancement.

Answer 10

The fact that we "invent" gods is evidence that a God does exist. It is innate in us that we try to know our maker.

Science will never disprove supernatural beings because by definition they are out of its realm.

Answer 11

If faith is the superb thank you to regulate a mass inhabitants, then why have the previous oppressive international locations been atheist? the U.S. and Nazi Germany shouldn't are becoming the memo. faith is an incredibly undesirable thank you to regulate the masses anyhow by way of fact they are going unlikely to lend a hand and are going to combat. So my component right it incredibly is that controlling the masses does not have plenty to do with faith. human beings do go with some thing to have self assurance in. This hankering for faith seems very abnormal as far as evolution is going. If there isn't any God, then the 1st human beings that got here up with the belief of God might have been at an evolutionary draw back- having to sacrifice cows, spend time praying, whilst they might have been out doing some thing efficient. The Egyptians placed a extensive volume of attempt into the pyramids to make particular the emperor's good afterlife. A godless civilization might have a extensive income over them. as far as motivating the masses, if there isn't any God any type of motivation ought to artwork only as nicely, so the respect of the rustic or tribe ought to have worked fantastic and been greater effective. different than it did no longer. enormously much each way of existence has had a faith, and people who tried to banish it like the U.S. fell aside. So why does faith artwork so nicely? It could no longer have developed over the years to inspire human beings as time-honored above, it no longer likely functional, so the only different answer is that there is a God who has located a ought to worship him in human beings. Now absolutely everyone isn't all understanding so it doesn’t look like too numerous a stretch to assert that some human beings understanding that there is a God pointed out Him incorrect and commenced yet another faith. So there got here to be many different religions. No i comprehend that isn't undeniable evidence of God, only good circumstantial information. For some reason God has desperate to no longer provide undeniable evidence, he needs us to have self assurance. it incredibly is comprehensible, if He revealed himself to absolutely everyone in complete glory; absolutely everyone could be afraid and worship him out of worry. yet God needs us to love him freely and consequently has given us a decision via last hidden, so as that if we nevertheless worship him our love would be freely given and propose plenty greater.