How to convince the TABLEEGUE JAMAATH that they are wrong and committing a SIN and misguiding people !?

Answer 1

The Tableeghi Jamaat takes its teaching from the book "Fadhaa.il A'maal" (Virtues of the deeds) authored by Muhammad Zakaria Kandalvi on the suggestions put forward by Ashraf 'Ali Thanvi, the two so called greats of the school of Deobandh in India.

The ideology propagated in this book is nothing but grave worship, supplication to other than Allaah and the 'aqeedah (beliefs) propagated in this book has nothing to do with Islaam but with Paganism and may Allaah (Subhaanahu wa Ta'aala) protect us from it.

Please visit: www.fatwaonline.com/deviant groups/

Then select jamaa’ah at-Tableegh/teachings of shirk in the book-fadhaa.il A’mal-part-1, part-2. and part-3.

Zainab and jurgen, (and whosoever is interested) please post your comments after reading all the three parts.

Eco-Savvy and metalserenade Please read on...

The Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh does not uphold the manhaj of the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) and that which our Pious Predecessors were upon.

And if the situation was such, then it is not permissible to go out with them because it defies our manhaj in calling to the manhaj of the Pious Predecessors. So in the path of inviting to Allaah, then an 'aalim can go out with them but as for those (ignorant - without knowledge) who go out with them, then it is obligatory upon them to remain in their countries and (study Islaam) seek knowledge in their masaajid until there graduates from amongst them people of knowledge who hold study circles inviting to the path of Allaah.

As long as the situation is like that, it is upon the student of knowledge to invite these people (those from Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh) to study the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah and invite people to it.

And the Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh, with respect to da'wah to the Book and the Sunnah, do not intend by it a starting point, rather they consider that to be a divided call (da'wah)/approach; And because of this, they most resemble the Jamaa'ah of al-Ikhwaan al-Muslimeen.

They say their da'wah is based upon the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah, however this is mere idle talk for certainly they have no 'aqeedah upon which they are united (which unites them) - so you find some are Maatureedee, others are Ash'aree, whilst others are Soofee and even some who have no madhhab (affiliation to any particular ideology).

This is because their da'wah is built upon amassing (the people), then gathering together and culturising/instructing them, and in reality they do not really have any culture. More than half a century has passed and there has not appeared from amongst them a scholar.

As for us, then we say instruct them, then gather together, such that the gathering together is based upon a foundation in which there is no doubt.

So the da'wah of the Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh is that of the Soofiyyah, they call to good manners, as for correcting the differing 'aqeedah of the group, then they do not exert themselves one iota. This is because they believe this will cause differences (and splitting apart).

It came to pass that a brother, Sa'd al-Husayn had much correspondence with the leader of the Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh in India or Pakistan and it became clear from that they acknowledge (belief in) intercession and seeking help (from other than Allaah) and many other such things. And they require their people (members) to make bay'ah (oath of allegiance) based upon four issues: amongst them the Naqshbandiyyah methodology. So it is upon every tableeghee (one who ascribes to the Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh) to make bay'ah of these fundamentals (issues).

A questioner may ask: Indeed this group has corrected its faults (returned to Allaah) as a result of the efforts of many individuals and quite possibly many non-Muslims have accepted Islaam at their hands. Is this not sufficient (proof) for the permissibilty of going out with them and participating in that which they call to?

So we say: Indeed we know these words and hear them a lot and know them to emanate from the Soofiyyah! For example, there is a Shaykh whose 'aqeedah is incorrect and does not know anything about the Sunnah. Instead they deceitfully take from the wealth of the people, so together with this, many open sinners seek forgiveness from them!

So every group which invites to good, then it is imperative they should be in adherence (to the Qur.aan and the Sunnah), and (this) our approach is pure, so what are they (others) calling to?

Are they calling to adherence to the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah of the Messenger (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) and the ;aqeedah of the Pious Predecessors, abandoning blind following of the madhhabs to such an extent that they adhere to the Sunnah over and above their madhhab!? So the Jamaa'ah at-Tableegh do not have a knowledge-based (manhaj), rather, their manhaj is according to the place where they are to be found, so they change their "colours" to suit themselves.

al-Fataawa al-Imaaraatiyyah of al-Albaanee

Answer 2

I dont agree that the Tableeque Jamaath(TJ) contravene any law of the sharia as a group and at such commiting sin or misguiding people does not arise.

More often people just felt embarrased when approached by the TJ for various reasons.Instead of blaming TJ for making us feel guilty , we should rather take it positively as an advise .

Answer 3

Deobandism or call it Majnooism (sufism) they do taqleed. Personality worship is top in the list.

Facts from my younger bro he is Amir. He says now Fazaile amal is totally out.
He has accepted that it contained daeef hadiths.

So we have to keep on debating things will change for sure, as u see now they say bismillah while eating. Earlier bismillahi wa allah barkatillah .

The worst book I have read is Bahiste Zewar. So much filth was introduced.

TJ's are good for those ppl who know nothing about Islam, they have done good work going door to door with thier RAGSACKS.

May Allah guide them with correct AQEEDAH

for sareena: Arabs are following Riyadus saliheen most of the hadeeths are authentic.
They do not know our own corrupt version of RS is Fazile amal

Answer 4

assalamalikum these people are not at all deviant u dont know what are the works these people are doing u just sit in home and bark on others that they are wrong and this is wrong the ummah is on the verge of loosing faith in god and these people are travelling in the villages and backward areas and trying to bring ummah on the right path . and its a old phenomenon that people like u and others always target fazail-e-amaal what does it mean benefit of deeds and in fadail daif hadees can be taken because it is not shariath its virtue of deed even in BUKHARI shareef the most authentic book thers are 70 daif hadees. zakaria(ra) had just collected these hadees from different books he dint wrote them and it is not like that only tj people read only fazail e- amaal ther are other books and u shuld be knowing that there alhamdulilah millions of workers all over the world and infact thousands of arabs are taking part in it if it was wrong it would have not got these many people approving it
so u better instead of sitting in home and barking on other look for urself what u have done in the field of dawah and and best of the dawah is dawah to selfcorrection and working for our own correction may Allah provide unity among ourselfs AMEEN
WHY ONLY SEE THE DARK SIDE OF IT WHEN BRIGHTER SIDE SHOWS US THERS SO MUCH GOOD IN IT

Answer 5

Tablighi jmat is a gift of ALLAH for muslims. These people do not have any personal or political purposes. They just want people to carry out basics of islam like namaz, fasting etc. They do not ask about your creed of affiliation. The book fadail e aamal is just used to motivate people towards namaz ,keeping fast and other basic vitues of islam. Hundreds of thousands of people around the globe have changed their lives by joining tablighi jmaat. Fazail e amal is the most read book after Quran paak, this shows the popularity of this in masses and acceptance before ALLAH. just join it and see the difference your self.
Reards.

Answer 6

Maybe look at things from a different angle they believe in God and so do u but we should never oppose one another. i have lots of tabligh friends and ultimately we believe in one God so if anyone is doing wrong He is the true judge.

Answer 7

Don't. They are not wrong. Your way may be best for you, but there are other ways that are best for others. God wouldn't make a world with so much diversity and have only one way be correct!

Answer 8

Well of course they are not Christians of the Swedenborgian denomination so I don't know what they believe! To google!

Answer 9

like d chino m said y dont u mind ur own buisness?

Answer 10

Your view is appreciated. There are so many accountable and responsible for this. Why you want to waste the time on a futile attempt?