Why do Doctors contradict each other?

Question

If I had a full bottle of medication that is more than a month old the nurse practitioner flushes my medication as an "intervention" and writes me a prescription for a narcotic, am I in the wrong for refusing to take any medication or go back and deal with it, when I have 3 people who went to medical school who cant make up there mind what I need to take.

Answer 1

Because you posted this in Mental Health, I'm assuming these medical "professionals" you're describing are in the mental health field. Basically, it sounds like they're behaving like quacks who have no idea what they're doing. But with psychiatry, that's not unusual. Their Bible, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for the Diagnosis of Mental Illness is vague and ill-defined and their trying to correct for chemical imbalances that they say you, the patient has, but yet cannot prove it by any objective medical test. Here is an excerpt from two college professors who wrote a book on how unreliable the DSM is:

Herb Kutchins of California State University, Sacramento, and Stuart A. Kirk of the University of California, Los Angeles, authors of Making Us Crazy: The Psychiatric Bible and the Creation of Mental Disorders:

“The developers of DSM assume that if a group of psychiatrists agree on a list of atypical [new] behaviors, the behaviors constitute a valid mental disorder. Using this approach, creating mental disorders can become a parlor game in which clusters of all kinds of behaviors (i.e. syndromes) can be added to the manual.”

Psychiatrists claim that a person “needs” a drug to combat their “chemical imbalance” in the brain which is causing a person’s “mental disorder.” However, the concept that a brain-based, chemical imbalance underlies mental illness is false. While popularized by heavy public marketing, it is simply psychiatric wishful thinking. As with all of psychiatry’s disease models, it has been thoroughly discredited by researchers.

In 1996, psychiatrist David Kaiser said, “...modern psychiatry has yet to convincingly prove the genetic/biologic cause of any single mental illness...Patients [have] been diagnosed with ‘chemical imbalances’ despite the fact that no test exists to support such a claim, and...there is no real conception of what a correct chemical balance would look like.”

I strongly recommend that you NOT see a psychiatrist or anyone in the mental health field for the problems you're experiencing. Here is what you should do: You should find a competent medical doctor at http://www.alternativementalhealth.com to find the underlying reason you're experiencing these emotions. Have them do a complete medical workup on you followed by an extensive panel of blood tests. (real doctors do tests, quacks do not) Your bipolar-like symptoms could be the result of a lack of certain amino acids, a vitamin deficiency, toxicity, low thyroid function or a hormonal imbalance. All of these possibilities can be tested for and treated successfully.

If after that, you still desire treatment, perhaps you want to try something a little gentler and more homeopathic. There are many herbs that have helped people with their emotional troubles. A great orthomolecular psychiatrist who deals with herbal treatments is a Dr. Hyla Cass who's practice is located in Pacific Palisades California ... her website contains a wealth of information and she will even consult with you by email for a fee. Here's her website: http://www.cassmd.com

Answer 2

The medical profession is the biggest scam I've ever seen. I worked in a hospital for 12 years and have seen it all. The scariest thing to me is that could care less about your health. They are only worried about making the payment on their showcase home and car. "Hey look what I have". Be carefull, Dr's kill more people by medication than just about any other cause of death. And If there are Dr's. out there and see this. dont try to act like it aint true. like I said, Ive seen it all.

Answer 3

A nurse practicioner did not go to medical school and she had no right to interfere with your doctor's treatment. A narcotic sounds like the last thing you should have.

Answer 4

the place there is doubt, there will be no healing. Doubt is a faith killer. Jesus mentioned if we had the religion of a mustard seed, that's the smallest of all seed, we are in a position to declare to a mountain to %. up and be tossed into the sea and it might take place. The devil is the guy who's consistently there planting his seeds of doubt. Rebuke the devil and he will flee. He has no potential over the saints. in basic terms that which we grant him with the aid of our believing his lies and not the word of God.

Answer 5

Diagnoses is based on opinion.
Your best bet is to find a Dr. whom you can agree with.
It's you life, your body & you have your own opinions, make your thoughts clear.
Good Luck.