should Muslims be called book holders, like Jews and Christians?

Question

they have a book from god, but they blow it by following faked books that are full of lies and non sense, of bukhari and muslem. i really can't see the difference. where are the true muslems!

when ya'juj and ma'juj will invade earth, they will throw there arows at the sky, and blood will drop down, i wonder who was killed!! i read it in muslem's hadith book, that's what i call nonsense crap.

god had a fight with god and beat god, i read that in bible, that's what i call pure nonsense.

sorry, jacob had afight with god

bukhari and mulim inveted CIA 1000 years ago. they where spying on mulems to know there political thinking, to help the imperialist authorities. what they did was a sin, god said: don't spy. of course collecting hadith was a cover. quran is perfet, by a perfect god, no need to cmplete it by any thing. god can destroy mohammed, jesus and mary, god doesn't need any one. as for bukhari who said that the prophet was maried to 9 years old kid. well he can go to hell.

Answer 1

not heard of that saying before

Answer 2

well.. the muslims considered the jews and the christians as the ppl of the book too.. so i think it would only be proper if they are considered the same dont u think? About the books by albukhari and muslim.. they are called "Hadith".. and Hadith are just words, advice or actions that were believed to have been done or said by the prophet during the time when he was alive. And these words and actions that he does were then being told by his disciples, family and friends to other muslims and was survived till today through compilation by ppl like AL bukhari and Muslim. The accuracy of the book are debatable.. and the words that were written might not be completely accurate to what the prophet might have said or done. They are just words from ppl who knew the prophet.. could be exploited for all we know..
But to the muslim.. the Hadith are just an alternative guide.. but the main book in ISlam is the Quran.. and all muslim take the Quran as their main guidance.. As to the belief of all Muslims, the Quran has been unedited word by word and the authenticity of the book has been preserved since the time it was revealed to the prophet.

So to answer ur question.. there are a lot of difference between a Hadith and a Quran.. and what u mentioned here is merely the Hadith.

Answer 3

MY friend u clearly hav no idea about Islam.We follow the Holy Koran as it is the word of God and for evry matter we revert to it.The 2nd most imoportant is the sunnah of the Prophet PBUH which is recorded in the books like Sahih bukhari and muslim.We try to be and act as much as the beloved Prophet as he is the most excellent example to follow.It most certainly is NOT nonsenseof any kind .As for the Bible and other books are concerned these books hav been deteoriated by their followers and are not in the form as God sent them .The only book in the sama form is The Glorious Quran it is the same as it was recorded 1400 yrs ago .D o u know why?? because God himself has taken its responsibility

Answer 4

Muslims are book holders because they have a book from Allah--just like jews and christians before them.

They are supposed to follow the holy book along with the commands of their prophet PBUH. The Bukhari and Muslim books --named after their writers-- are just documentations of Hadith--the speech of the holy prophet PBUH-- and are not invented by their authors. So they should be followed too.

No one can ever deny the honesty of those books as they were very carfully narrated by very honest men. Any Hadith is preceeded by its narrators beginning from the holy prophet PBUH and ending by Bukhari or Moslem. And if any narrator in between was known to have lied once or more in his life even if he was telling a joke, the hadith is rejected and not documented until narrated by another trusted man.

Bukhari and Moslem have created a whole category of science not known in their erra. They created the science of men; which aims to study the men--or narrators of Hadith-- and wether they are worth trusting in this critical task.

Now, after all these well-known evidences, how dare can you say that those books are full of "lies and nonsense"?

Answer 5

Answer me, Should Jews and Christians be called book-holders?
Well sure there are true Muslims but few. This also means that there are few true Christians and Jews as well.
Ya sure Muslims can be called book-holders except for the terrorists.

Answer 6

Hitler will flow to hell of direction you're able to be a Muslim devoid of understanding you're one. Being a Muslim is submitting to God. that's the main serious area of it. we don't sentence all human beings to heaven or hell, God does. you do no longer must be a Muslim to flow to heaven, you purely must be a competent guy or woman and believe there is a few thing greater desirable than your self. you're thinking of the Christians. BTW Jews believe every physique can flow to heaven (or get a advantages in the international to come again) they do no longer must be Jewish in any respect. purely be stable people who carry on with the 7 Noachide policies.

Answer 7

Are Christians really called book holders? I am a Christian and I only follow the Holy Bible.

Answer 8

I think that Mohammed, who authored the Qu'ran was very conceited and bigoted. I read the book. I found it very contradictive.

Answer 9

i'm a muslim..and i wonder why the thing you said(which is not true) bothered you? we have Al-Quran, and hadiths which i believed u knew nothing about it..so don't acting like you're smart about muslims matters.

Answer 10

i have never heard of that. Do they hold books???? how do you know what is a lie and what is truth. maybe what you are reading is a lie. think about that. judgement day will reveal all. until then, YOU dont know what is a lie, so why judge others.

Answer 11

I was christian, i was confused and lost! The Bible are full of contradiction, and full of bullshit! That's why i left Jesus!