LCD or CRT for photo editing ?

Question

I have both LCD and CRT monitors on 2 different computers which i use for photo editing. Problem is - images that look good on LCD appears like crap on CRT and vice versa....any solution ?

Answer 1

Try printing it out and see how it looks. I have both monitors as well but I usually print it out and see if my editing program is out of sink.

G.G.

Answer 2

yeah , nice question .The picture in LCD looks little bit more sharp than on CRT as the LCD driver and resolution technologies makes the picture to look more crisp on LCD monitors.
I always prefer the CRT monitors for editing.
But even the CRT can't give the accurate colour due to brightness and contrast settings.
The final printout will be the best solution.The colour tint slightly varies with the printers also.
Because they are all pre programmed by the manufacturers.
So the best solution use always only one set of system ,CRT monitor ,printer and software . You get used to that system you will find it more easier to edit with that system, very easily, because you get to used to it's output.

Answer 3

CRT is considered the gold standard by graphic arts pros.

This assumes that the crt is is still working within the original specs, and that the graphics card driving it is also working to spec, and the crt is adjusted correctly, and that the correct color options are selected on your computer.

That's a lot of "ifs"! And you have 2 different computers to worry about too.

If your crt is not old and is generally clear, I suggest that you try to tune the color settings to match a known color chart (available at a camera store).

First, check out your color settings in Control/Appearance and Themes/Display/Settings (in WinXP). Make sure that you are using 32 bit color. It's also best to use your display's "native" resolution (the one it was built for. Check your specs.).

Then use your crt's controls to try to match your color chart. Your crt user manual may have some advice on color adjustment. This should also include "gamma" adjustment.

Adjust your crt in a darkened room.

If your crt is in good condition, you should be able to get close to good looking, accurate color.

You can also adjust the LCD monitor in the same way. Maybe it will be better than your crt at this point.

Once you get your display devices satisfactory, you have to use "color management" strategies to make the screen match the printer output. But that's for another day...

Good Luck

Answer 4

Do a color calibration of both CRT and LCD. and check the photos after that.

CRT is much flexible, has a much better range for color but if is old ...I mean to used...the color temperature and other parameters can be out of normal range.

for LCD - use "the native resolution" stated in user manual.

Answer 5

I prefer decent CRT screens. People who do image editing for a living generally prefer whopping expensive CRT screens. Whatever type of screen you use, if you're serious about image editing, invest in a colorimeter. This a a package of hardware and software that lets you calibrate your monitors and printers (and keep them calibrated).
The Spyder2 is a popular model at a 'decent' price. Here's a package for $150: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home?O=productlist&A=details&Q=&sku=426716&is=REG&addedTroughType=categoryNavigation
You can find other kinds from around $70 to over $1000.

Answer 6

the two are the same thing the only diferences are that crt refresh more fast than lcd but for photos shounld be a problem but for games yes

Answer 7

That is strange, it shouldn't be that way.