why do Muslims write down what Muhammad said, although the profit clearly, according to them, said not to?

Question

why do you disobay the profit, you say a lot of nonsense excuses but you have no proof, not from quran, not even from sunna. that hadith is mutawater, the one that's transported through seveal lines, so if there is one liar, there is still a chance. don't write what he said down, what's so unclear about that. it's clear that he wanted us to concentrate only on qur'an.

shaikh doesn't mean correct, it means old man. bukhari (ibn barzawaih) and muslim, lived hundreads of years after muhamed and they didn't hear him. quran tell us every thing about praying, rukou', sojud, times, from dawn to noon to sunset. the rest are not basics, any way we took it from the prophet by doing it not writing down. a father took it from agrand father, these no need to disobay the prophet and write any thing.

as for the verse love is great wrote, if you read the context, it was about ghnaem, what's gain from wars, waht the prophet gave you take it. any way what the prophet gave us is only qur'an. if the prophet was alive and told me to do some thing i will do it, but don't tell me to obay bukhari and muslim, i don't know the guys. and there are no holy or sacrade people in islam.

well god is a believer and god said muhamed is and is not, and i do say blessing and peace be upon him in my heart i don't have to write it down to show of.

this is hadith mutawater, i'm sorry i can't write it down, i don't want to go to hell. it's abou t what i said in the end of it there is some thing about people who would lie at the prophet and there seat in hell. there is a clear order, don't write, in arabic:لا تكتبوا

just listen to what you are writing lisa, is it possible that the words of a god would be mixed with the words of a man, non sense. any way it's a clear order, why do you argue and make excuses, just show me where he said write down what i'm saying.

well that's nice mr h, what they did was spying on muslims, there political views, what they are doing, and there is a clear order in qur'an: do not spy! god! you are just making it worse. and how do we know that the people who were spying are good, clearly not, they didn't just dis obay a direct order from the prophet, but another direct order from god. what's wrong with you muslims! where is your reasons, minds.

Answer 1

it's what we in the west call
hearsay.

talk but not written.

Answer 2

Other answered you well ... but i want to add something very important ... our scientists in Hadeeth from long time after our prophet Mohamed (صلى الله عليه و سلم ) Died not only check the words and if it wright or wrong .... not they check every body his name is in between the words and till you got the name of Mohamed (صلى الله عليه و سلم ) and you will wonder if you know they searching in this names kind of life how they dealing with others ... if they follow the Islam or not ... if they found any one not passing from the very hard conditions they refusing the hadeeth and announce it as not correct also if they found someone good but he is not known to the or they couldn't find his history they announce hadeeth ( is not trust )
and Moree and more ... there is a very huge studies in this subject from 1300 years ago
one mor thing ... for your information ... The Muslims only have a prove of what they believe in all matters of they religion all is fact's but it's need from you to go in the wright way and you can ask any qualified person in this field and easily he will guide you to the books you suppose to read first.
thanks .... and my best wishes

Answer 3

You're wrong.. do you know why he told us not to write what he said???
it's because he didn't want people to mix between his sayings and God's sayings because even the Quran wasn't written then.
but after they wrote the Quran and there was no fear, prophet Muhammed found that it was the best to write what he had said, so it won't be forgotten or changed..

Answer 4

We have a proof. Our proof is Quran because it is the last book and Prophet Mohammed is the last prophet. Nobody changed Quran. Because Quran doesnt tell us how to pray prophet Mohammad tought muslims how to pray.

Answer 5

Sahih Bukhari and Muslim are TOTALLY correct, that's why they were called "Al-Sahee-hayn" or "The two correct". Holy Qur'an for example doesn't say how to pray, it simply says: "Pray". Muhammad (PBUH) said HOW TO pray, by an inspiration from GOD. Noble Qura'n: "And what the prophet came to you by, take it (do it), and what HE forbidden you to do, don not do it"
"و ما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه و ما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا"

Answer 6

first of all muslims dont say muhammad said...... muslims say prophet muhammad (pbuh) said......and i dont get the point 'although the profit clearly, according to them, said not to?' ... are you trying to say the prophet said not to write down what he told....well thats a wrong information you have.... when qur'an was revealed to him the first word he wrote was 'read' ...... how come others read when you dont write first....so thats a false info...

Most of his teachings are from taken from qur'an which has been unchanged since it was revealed.....whilst hadtihs are his doings reported by his companions....these are always cross verified from multiple sources.