If Scientology was created 5,000 years ago, do you think it would have been as popular as Christianity?

Question

You say scientology makes no sense. If Chrisiantiy was created just 50 years ago ( like scientology) wouldnt a "god" make absoloutely no sense as well?

Answer 1

No. Christianity appealed to the poor and disenfranchised, Scientology appeals to the rich and famous.

Answer 2

Even as a hypothosis this question makes no sense.
Scientology was never "created" it emerged in this century after many years of research by Hubbard into sacred knowledge that had existed for more than 10,000 years. It was combined with new discoveries he made about the nature of the human spirit.
As a result of this he was able to develop a workable path that anyone could travel to reach higher states of spiritual existence and understanding.
This is the underlying goal or hope of all religions. This was the teachings of Buddha, Moses, Jesus, Mohammed... they were all teachers ( Messiahs) with a message for mankind, that there was something better.
Whether a religion is "popular" or not, isn't the point.
How well it works and helps mankind to achieve spiritual freedom is the point.
Scientology could not have been discovered , researched and developed 5000 years ago. The necessary scientific and technological advances did not occurr until the last century.

The knowledge and religious philosophy that Scientology is based on has been in existence probably since the beginning of time, but, as I said earlier, was first recorded in the East in written form 10,000 years ago.

If you are looking for popularity, almost two thirds of the world's population in the East were practicing some form of dharmic/buddhist religion 2000 years ago when Christianity first came into being in the Middle East and spread into the WEST.

Answer 3

Scientology was created by science fiction author, L. Ron Hubbard, in the 20th century.

I do not think Scientology would be very popular, 5,000 years ago, because people knew very little about science and science fiction did not exist at that time.

5,000 years ago, people worshipped gods that controlled the earth and made idols of them.

This is a 20th century invention. I doubt that it could have existed much before the Industrial Revolution. People would have no foundation on which to build or understand it.

Answer 4

The information are that Scientology could no longer have been based 2000 years in the past. The the scientific understanding that enabled Hubbard to do all his study into the strategies and spirit and make the discoveries he made that resulted interior the Scientology faith, only did no longer exist . that's only been interior the final 70 impressive years that technological know-how greater a procedures sufficient interior the West. it is somewhat an identical targets and interntions that Guatama Buddha had for mankind 2500 years in the past. at that factor only there became only the wish that guy ought to realize a greater helpful state of life ( "bodhi" it is termed interior the East) very few have been able to prevail in this state in one life time. Scientology, that's understanding and technologies have given mankind a conceivable course or bridge to those states that now absolutely everyone can holiday...... in the event that they are looking for a street to actuality, and attain religious freedom in one lifetime. that's no longer approximately popularity besides. that's approximately workability. maximum religions have at their center the salvation of mankind, yet have they have been given functional conceivable recommendations? There are at the instant over 10 million Scientologists in greater advantageous than 163 international places international huge. it is an impressive growth cost for a faith that has only existed for fifty 3 years. the genuine tale of Scientology as a faith is going like this: a million. A logician developes a philosophy approximately life and loss of life. 2. human beings discover it interesting. 3. human beings discover it particularly works. 4. human beings bypass it alongside to others. 5. It grows.

Answer 5

I dont see how that could happen. Scientology is a collection of exercises and teachings gathered from many sources which wouldnt exist then. Altho a decent non-denominational religion showing up 5000 years ago might have been nice.

Answer 6

It couldn't have been around that long ago. A lack of SCIENCE for one thing, but also because people as a whole were different then, and none of them would have understood the basic precepts. The idea of using your mind to heal yourself, in a world where people were burying toenails under mushrooms by the full moon to get rid of a wart - the two ways of thinking are at totally different ends of the spectrum.
No, your question is moot, because it just isn't possible.

Answer 7

Have you even looked at Scientology? Lord Xenu packing a bunch of frozen aliens into intergalactic DC-8s and dropping them next to volcanoes which he then nuked? It makes no sense whatsoever. And it couldn't have been invented 5000 years ago; they use those E-Meters as one of the main parts of Scientology. I don't think they used electricity back then.

Answer 8

the world didnt really need Scientology 5000 years ago, people were more spritually aware and didnt do so many stupid stuff. you can still do it today just Scientology makes it alot easier than sitting under a tree for a year! lol
(no offense to buddusim intended.)

Answer 9

Yeah it probably would have been. I mean how hard could it be to see a metorite fall and think...Aliens which would then have translated to "The Gods". Espeically 5000 years ago when agriculture was brand new. So the answer is yes.

Answer 10

Scientology is still a fairly new concept to people these days and most poeple fear change... Do you know what happened to Galileo when he said the world wasn't flat but spherical... they excommunicated his ***.