Whose land is this?

Question

the land where israel is, its a part of palastine its not their land,before 1918 there was noting called israel ,they came to palastine which was invaded by england.... they wanted to expand their land by invading syria lebanon and egypt....... why do every body encourage them to take more lands of middle east....... america wants to help them taking more lands of lebanon and syria by this way.........they will have all the middle east........but they are losing now in lebanon.......... i mean usa didnt help them yet......to take lebanon........u'll tell me they r fighting hezbollah...so why they are attacking whole towns and killing its people,destroying bulidings,bridges,cars,schools and every thing good ......... and now who r terrorists???????

Answer 1

Firstly...I do not support the sensless bombings of Lebanese and Palestinian civilians nor do I support the heinous rocket barrages on Israeli civlians. I despise the notion of an Evil Islamic Empire and I despise the Intolerance and ambition of Zionists...

To your question...the true narrow-mindedness of your beliefs stem from the fact that you have limited your view of history to 1918. Many other peoples have lived in that sand pit other and before the Palestinians and that includes the Jews (remember the Jewish/Hebrew Kingdoms of David and Solomon...if you are a Muslim you should also know these guys).

Oh and If I were to fall for your logic...then that means that we should throw out all Muslims and Christians from places like China, South East Asia, Africa and India, because the peoples who originally lived there were not (and never wanted to be) Christian or Muslim. and we should remove all Latin, African and Caucasian Americans from ALL the Americas because those lands truly belong to the Mayas, Incas, and other American Indians. If this is too much then maybe we should deport all people who do not belong in any particular land (like the illegals in America).

Answer 2

Do you have any knowledge of history? Do you ever read a newspaper? The Jewish people have been in the Middle East since Biblical times. Palestine as a state existed for only a short time. The Arabs who wandered over that land did nothing to improve it. There is no oil there. After the Holocaust, the land was divided between Israel and Jordan and no one ever asked that Jordan be turned back to Palestine. The Israelis turned the barren land into farms, vineyards, businesses, cities and resorts. When the Arabs saw that, they wanted the land back.
Israel tried in every way possible to live peacefully with its neighbors. They are surrounded on all sides by countries that harbor terrorists. From the day Israel was established, the attacks began. The Israelis even bulldozed their own settlements and gave the land to the Arabs, but nothing short of the annihilation of Israel would satisfy them. The suicide bombers got on Israeli school buses and went into the market places. Missiles were aimed at resorts and cities and hundreds more were poised on the border. Israel even built a wall but it didn't keep the terrorists out. When 2 soldiers were kidnapped, Israel had enough. The did what the US should be doing; they went after the terrorist's headquarters and training grounds. These are the same terrorists that attacked us on 9/11 and have attacked Britain, India and other countries. Israel is the only ally of the US in the Middle East and the only democracy in the region. They have a right to defend themselves

Answer 3

Need I remind you that before the British occupation, there was no Palestine, either? It was assorted tribes that lived under the rule of the Ottomans, and before them, the Persian Caliphate, and before them, the Arab Empire, etc.

Palestine has never existed as an independent state; Israel, on the other hand, has - both in the last 50 years and for the several hundred years preceding the Roman conquest of the region.

Answer 4

Why does Hizbullah hide in apartment buildings and private houses? Why do they store weapons in mosques? Why do they use the poor civilians of Lebanon as their human shields?

Beirut is still standing, Tyre and Sidon are still standing...in fact, all of Lebanon is still standing. Israel has attacked the Hizubullah infrastructure, and Lebanese Army units giving them support.

Who invaded Israel in 1948? The Arabs. Who threatened war in 1956? The Arabs. Who told the UN to pack up and leave Sinai and massed on Israel's borders in 1967? The Arabs. Who invaded Israel in 1973? The Arabs.

Answer 5

This is GOD'S land.....

You should go back a lot further that the year 1918 for your information. God's great earth was here before that.

God told Moses to tell Pharaoh, let my people Israel go. If you don't believe in the Bible that is your choice. I am not pushing anything on you at all. I believe in God, the Lord Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit. I also believe that the bible is truth.

You are saying a lot but your question is sort of mixed up.

Answer 6

I agree with you.Israel have taken virtually all of Palestine.They will never give a state to the Palestinians.Why are all the arab states abandoning Palestine and Lebanon to this barbaric Israeli goverment.

Answer 7

It's kinda dull. I'm a Jew, and I recognise the Bible says God gave that land to the Jews, and it additionally says God gave plenty of different lands to different peoples. The reality is, companies of individuals have constantly moved round. In historical past there have been constantly tribes and stuff and individuals fought and received and misplaced land, or moved given that assets ran out. Even within the final four hundred years, have you learnt how in many instances nations in Europe have long gone out and in of life and borders moved? It's an phantasm that any institution of individuals thinks they possess a designated land. To the first-class of my expertise, within the struggle that began after Israel formally grew to be a state, the Arab nations advised their fellow Arabs to get out of the way in which given that they had been coming by way of and that once they had driven the Jews into the ocean, they would come again and feature all of the land and stuff the Jews used to possess. Well, it did not figure out that approach given that the Arabs misplaced. So, plenty of the displaced individuals are displaced given that of that, and the Arab nations may not permit their fellow "Palestinian" Muslims transfer into their nations. It is to their advantage to hold the ones individuals as "Palestinian refugees" to make Israel appear unhealthy and to make use of as a political tool in opposition to Israel. I believe it is all political and individuals in vigor use faith to fireplace individuals up.

Answer 8

It's called Palestine. Always been there long before the so called state of Israel and will always be there long after Israel is gone.

Answer 9

Historically, Moses led the jews to the promised land (Israel) 8500 years ago.. Israelites date from 1382, Where is Mesopotania now.. ITs now Iraq, Iran and Kuait...
Dont hear any laments for te Mesops,,

Answer 10

The Jews were originally in Palestine. The Romans removed the Jews after they revolted in 132.

The Palestinians were squatters.