catholics and christians?

Question

if they both follow the bible, then why are the beliefs so different?

Answer 1

One could make a very good case that protestants, due to their own faulty and relatively recent faith traditions, allow themselves to make use of only about one third of all true Christian teachings and beliefs.

It's no wonder such people would have a hard time understanding things like sacraments, intercession, propitiation, atonement, the Mass, the church hierarchy, and much, much more.

The protestant view of Christianity is limited to only what appears in scripture, yet no where in scripture is that rule of faith to be found.

Following many different pastors, but lacking a true, God appointed earthly leader, just about anything passes for protestant dogma, even false traditions and outright fabrications.

And if you're not happy with your present flavor, don't worry. You have 20,000 more variations of protestant dogma to choose from! Just pick another congregation.

Catholic beliefs and practices are complete and uniform, just as they have always been.

The Catholic church, according to God's grace, has withstood the test of time as well as the constant attacks of Satan, and it will continue to do so, until time ceases to exist.

Who cares if some claim that God's original, and one, true church is not Christian?

On the day of judgment, all things will be revealed.

Answer 2

Some Christians do not recollect Roman Catholics to be truly Christians, and those are in general protestants. But pretty much, Roman Catholics are Christian however no longer all Christians are Catholic. Roman Catholics are lead by means of the Pope in Rome. Protestants do not admire the Pope's authority and are geared up into 1000s of unique denominations. The Eastern Orthodox(Greek Orthodox, Russian Orthodox) additionally don't admire the Pope, despite the fact that their teachings and ceremonies are similar to the Roman Catholics. The Eucharist is meant to be Jesus's Body and Blood, this can be a Holy Sacrament, an overly most important side of Catholic church rite. I do not feel in it. I can type of realise the proposal however I am no longer Catholic or Christian. Never be petrified of asking questions of your priest or fellow parishioners.

Answer 3

Catholics are Christians! We were the first Christians. And we decided the books of the Bible, too. The first Protestants basically believed mostly what we believe, but did not understand or accept some doctrines or teachings, and thus started their own denomination.
Catholics have a Magisterium and 2000 years of Tradition to explain the Bible to them. For Protestants, every minister/pastor explains it how he likes, and they all come up with something different.

Answer 4

I guess you never heard of the Protestant reformation starting with Luther.

Simple put, Protestants believe the bible is the only source of divine revelation. Catholics believe in both a written and oral tradition; this means that Catholics use more than the bible and have a hierarchical system headed by the pope to resolve any contradiction.

I hope that is enough information.

Answer 5

The Catholics created a different Bible. They added and removed what they wanted. The last page of my Holy Bible tells what happens to those who do this.

Answer 6

Catholics are the first Christians. Protestants invented a new religion with the Reformation. And now there are over 33,000 different Protestant versions of Jesus and Christianity.

Answer 7

The bible can be interpreted in many way, it is not clear at all. It also has been translated in many different languages and following different decisions, depending on the times.

These differences of interpretation are the basis for the differences between different heretic branches.

Answer 8

I am a Protestant, so are my parents, my brother, two of my 5 uncles, their wives and 3 cousins.. the rest of the 30 people in my family are catholic. It can get interesting if we start talking religion in my family.

My mom was raised catholic. From what she has told me, the catholic bible has stuff added to and taken away from it, like someone else said, but this stuff makes their bible contradict itself.

Also, the Catholics believe that you must go to a priest to confess your sins. Protestants believe that we can talk directly to God because Christ is acting as our mediator. The bible says we are reconciled unto God thru Christ. As sinners, we can't talk to God, but when we believe in Christ, he speaks to God thru us. Many catholics believe that good works will get you into heaven. I'm not sure where this comes from.. the bible says "Not by works of righteousness which we have done but according to his mercy he saved us.."

Answer 9

Christians believe in the Word of God. Yahsua Christ Jesus. It is a reality to them. Catholics follow a religion created by man, Catholicism. They don't read or study the Word of God but allow others to tell them what to think and do. Its a cult. God hates religion as it separates His children from Him.><>

Answer 10

Protestant Christians believe in ONLY the Bible.
Catholics believe in the Bible AND TRADITION. Catholics have kept the traditions of the church from the apostles and bishops that have folllowed in the last 2,000 years.