Where does the fish come from in the story of Jonah? Is it right for God to be Angry even to the death?

Question

Jonah 1:17 Now the LORD had prepared a great fish to swallow Jonah. And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights. Chapter 4: 6 And the LORD God prepared a plant[a] and made it come up over Jonah, that it might be shade for his head to deliver him from his misery. So Jonah was very grateful for the plant. 7 But as morning dawned the next day God prepared a worm, and it so damaged the plant that it withered. 8 And it happened, when the sun arose, that God prepared a vehement east wind; and the sun beat on Jonah’s head, so that he grew faint. Then he wished death for himself, and said, “It is better for me to die than to live.”
9 Then God said to Jonah, "Is it right for you to be angry about the plant?"
And he said, "It is right for me to be angry, even to death!"

(New King James Version)

Answer 1

So, you got a two-fer (as in two-fer the price of one) in your question.
Question 1) You asked, "Where does the fish come from in the story of Jonah?" I find your question interesting, since the answer is in the text, "Now the LORD had prepared a great fish". Where did the fish come from? It was a special fish prepared by God.

Question 2) You asked, "Is it right for God to be angry even to the death?" God asked Jonah if it was right for him to be angry about his shade being taken away when he should have been happy that God had spared the city of Ninevah through Jonah's preaching. You took the verse out of context if you think that God was 'right to be angry even to the death'. God cannot die.

Answer 2

God sent the fish to save Jonah. The storm, the fish & the rescue were all orchestrated by God to show Jonah that he couldn't run away & hide.

And Jonah had free will, so he had the right to be angry, but look at what it cost him. His anger over God not doing what he wanted cost him his happiness and his contentment.

Jonah is one of the most interesting figures in the Bible, because he is mirrored in so many contemporary people. Even after seeing the power and the wonder of God he still rejected God because God didn't give him what he wanted. In essence, Jonah treated God like a "Santa Claus" figure like so many do today (myself at one time included), then became angry and turned away from God when God didn't deliver on cue. Sounds like many I hear today who define their own God and then are let down when the One True God doesn't conform to their own selfish beliefs.

Answer 3

Jonah hated Ninevah which is the third city built by Nimrod. God picked Jonah in particular for this purpose. It was important for this fish to swallow him and spit him up on the beach at Ninevah. You see the Ninevites worshipped the fish god and when they saw Jonah come out of a fish, they believed him to be a prophet. God used a pagan symbol and their beliefs to bring them to him. Jonah did not want to do anything with them and God destroyed a plant he was shading under because he was burned by the fish. It is an amazing story. God said that Ninevah would be destroyed and over time it did.

Answer 4

the big fish is widely accepted to be a whale. it's the only situation in which Jonah could have existed 3 days without being digested, before being upchucked by said fish on the shores of Ninevah.

Is it right for God to be angry, even unto death? Well, that depends. Do you believe in God as the creator of mankind and the universe? If you don't, then no it isn't. What right does he have to determine who should live and die based on different causes? However, if you do believe he is the creator of everything, then yes, he has that right because it is his creation.

An artist has the right to burn every painting he ever made and didn't sell away to someone else. In that same way, God has the right to uncreate, or advance the stage, or any creation he still owns. Since he never sold us away to anyone, we still belong to him as his creation. It is his right to do as he pleases, and he is pleased to do so.

Answer 5

This changed into no longer only any "fish"! The verse you stated suggested, "The Lord had prepared an fantastically good fish..."! This turned right into a creature that changed into prepared by using God for this purpose! seeing that God "prepared" this creature, He might want to have prepared a fashion that Jonah might want to have survived, both by using making waiting the creature in this style of fashion, or by using providing for Jonah's secure practices. Jonah’s survival after being interior a sea creature isn't any more effective incredible than Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego surviving the “burning fiery furnace” (Daniel 3:27). honestly, the Hebrew word it fairly is translated as "fish" might want to be any type of sea creature (fish, whale, "leviathan", etc.). Jesus of route believed the account because He spoke about it in Matthew 12:38-40-one. in case you do not believe it, then you really ought to believe Jesus changed into both flawed or mendacity. in case you do not believe this, then why believe any of the miracles or workings of God defined interior the Bible (Jesus starting to be from the useless, healing unwell, the creation account, the virgin start, etc.)? in case you do not believe God is efficient sufficient to do any of this stuff, do you fairly believe in God? The God i experience in is waiting to prepare a creature that would want to swallow a guy and function the guy live on for 3 days! .

Answer 6

Jesus was not only the Son of God though he was send to fix the World he will not be able to do it by been politically correct, because at the time most all the political leaders were HOMOSEXUALS, and so they persecuted him because he was THE MOST BEAUTIFUL, PERFECT AND AWESOME MAN IN HISTORY, and then the Jew's were fill with Jealousy, and because Jesus didn't give then money or material wealth, they plan his death with the help of the Fag's AND HOMOSEXUALS, the Roman empire was fill with at the time., and that is why God is a very angry God, and you are making HIM angrier by the minute.

Answer 7

As someone pointed out, it was Jonah that said he was angry, even to death. I like that you are researching the Bible. God truly does care for us and wants what is best for us. If we believe in Him and obey Him, He has a home prepared for us.

Answer 8

Jonah didn't do what he was asked to do from God. So, God created a big fish to swallow him to make him learn his lesson and to listen to what he was told to do. God could've used a blue whale or something that was in the ocean to swallow him. Jonah didn't have much of a right to be mad at God because he was disobeying what he was told to do and God was trying to punish him for what he did wrong. God showed some mercy on him and let him have the plant to shade him from his misery. Because of the fact that God took the plant away he wanted to die because he had to experience his misery from not obeying God.
God has a right to be mad at us to the death. I think God is more hurt than mad at some of us. He asked to follow his rules and to live in his ways of life and to become more like him. He told us that if we live according to his rules that he will bless us with many things and that we will have a happy life and get a big reward in the end for listening and doing what we are told to do. God has a right to mad at us for not listening to him and doing what he asked out of us to do for him. He created us in his own image and he is the reason that we are all here and alive today. I because he put us here. He put us here , and he can take us away. You can ask God for repentance and he will be pleased with you and he will forget the wrong things that you did. God has a right to be displeased and upset with his people for disobeying and rejecting their existence of their creator.

Answer 9

so many fish in the sea an i guess that the one which swallowed Jonah was in the right pace at the right time

Answer 10

From the sea.
It is Jonah who said "It is right to be angry, even to death"