If prophet Muhammad convert to christian when he was a pagan would ISLAM exist ?

Answer 1

No, it wouldn't. The Quran was written by Muhammad. If he were to have become a Christian, then he wouldn't have written the Quran--therefore, there would have been no Islam.

What's your point?

Answer 2

Islam means peace, submission, and surrender. Most common definition of the word is "submission to God". That is why it's easy to say that former prophets were Muslims (which means "those who submit to God") rather than Christians (which is a word developed after Jesus died, a word derived from "Christ"), or even Jews (which is a term that wasn't used until a few hundred years before Jesus was born).

If Muhamad had "converted to Christianity", Islam would exist simply because it existed even before Muhamad. But saying that Muhamad might have converted to Christianity is saying that God's plans have flaws, which is not so.

The above poster claims that Muhamad "stole" things from Christianity and Judaism. A classic example of ignorance. If that was so, then why don't you also claim that Jesus stole things from Judaism AND the pagan religion of the Sun god? Hypocrisy is a very ugly thing, and you're flaunting it pitifully.

Answer 3

uhh... Pagan? He was never pagan. Now if he had converted to Christianity (which is highly unlikely after all the stuff he supposedly went through), Islam would not exist, because he would not have wrote the Qu'ran, which is the basic element of Islam.

Answer 4

Yes, Islam would still exist. It was the will of God to give Islam to mankind, and when God wills, He makes it happen. If Pr Muhammad (pbuh) converted to Christianity before that time, he would still have been visited by the angel Gabriel and would have still been given the Qur'an to recite to the scribes.

Answer 5

Muhammad didn't convert and ISLAM exists. Let us not worry about what didn't happen but worry about how we can help and change what is currently going on in the mid East and all over the world.

Answer 6

In the Middle East, there were many Christians who honored Mary. They nearly made Mary a Goddess. They considered Mary the greatest of all women. A Christian sect even said that the Trinity is composed of Father, mother and Son, (i.e. God, Mary and Jesus.) No Christian church today believes such things. Because Muhammad wanted to please the Christians in order to convince the Christians to become Muslims, he dialogued with them about theological issues. In the process, Muhammad came to believe the Christian Triune God was three gods made up of Father, mother and Son. Muhammad's so-called revelation (Sura 5:116), in which he rejects this false trinity, reflects his personal unawareness due to false information acquired from a Christian sect.


Muhammad tried his best to appear to the Jews as a Jew, to the Christians as a Christian and to the Animists as an Animist in order to make Muslims of them all. Consequently he adopted such things from the Jews, the Christians and from various different sects. He included all of these mistakes in the Qur’an as revelation of Allah and now Muslims claim these sectarian thoughts as the revealed truth of God. The source of these mistakes is not Muhammad; it is those who taught him these things.
c) Enmity between the Jews and Christians was another source of confusion in Muhammad's search to know God. The Christians fought the Jews because the Jews said, “Christ is not the Messiah,” and “Christ is not the Son of God.” The Jews fought the Christians because the Christians said, “You don’t know who God really is” and “You do not know the Spirit of God, you are only in the old covenant and do not know the new covenant of God.” They quarreled in front of Muhammad. It is written in the Qur’an, “The Jews say, the Christians are nothings and the Christians say, the Jews are nothings” (Sura 2:113). Out of this enmity, all of what one said against the other was incorporated into the Qur’an. Muhammad said: “God will punish you at the day of judgement for the differences you have among you.” He really wanted to know the truth and what he found were differences between Jews and Christians, as well as differences between right-wing Christians and left-wing Christians. He was very puzzled. Therefore, he accepted what he heard. He thought about these things and incorporated them into his own beliefs. In essence, he formed his own dough with ingredients from other religions and baked his own bread.

Answer 7

Who told you that there was a religion known as "Christianity" did Jesus PBUH once called him self a Christian or called you Christians ??!! All Prophets came with the religion of submission to ALLAH, the religion of Peace ISLAM

Answer 8

yes it would still exist ... because he was choosen by God ...

for more info about Islam you can follow these links:
Introducing Islam:
http://www.islamonline.net/english/introducingislam/index.shtml
http://www.understandingislam.org/0031_Islam.html
http://www.beconvinced.com/en/main.php
http://www.submission.org
Audio/Video/Documentary materials about Islam:
http://msa.evansville.edu/PagesForNonMuslims/index2.html
and certainly everything about Islam Prophet Muhammad:
http://www.muhammad.net/
http://muhammad.islamonline.net/English/index.shtml
http://www.cair.com/Muhammad/page.asp?pageid=atc
Muhammad's life in 10 languages:
http://www.islamway.com/mohammad/?lang=eng
Islam and attacking Foreigners:
http://www.islamonline.net/English/In_Depth/ShariahAndHumanity/Articles/2006/04/02.shtml
This website offers links to variouse other websites .. nice:
http://www.sultan.org/
Nearly everything about Islam:
http://www.islamworld.net/
A Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam:
http://www.islam-guide.com/
This page gives so much materials about Islam in 29 different languages (a wonderful website and well-designed too):
http://www.harunyahya.com/
Miracles in Quran and Sunnah:
http://www.miraclesofthequran.com/
http://www.55a.net/firas/english/index.php
The midical miracles of the Holy Quran:
http://www.islamicmedicine.org/medmiraclesofquran/medmiracleseng.htm
Woman in Islam:
http://jannah.org/sisters
http://www.iad.org/books/S-women.html
and this link contains the Quran text in 20 different languages and provides the ability to search:
http://quran.nu
To search for tafseer(Meanings or Explanations) for any verse of the Quran:
http://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=0&tSoraNo=1&tAyahNo=1&tDisplay=no
Ask questions about Islam and get professional answers:
http://askmuslims.com/
[e-mail]
Ask questions about Islam and get professional answers in 7 languages:
http://www.islam-qa.com/
Islamic websites in 44 languages:
http://islamfajr.com/z.htm
Videos - Scientists Comments on the Quran
http://islamyesterday.com/science/
get free islamic books in more than 70 languages from Conveying Islamic Message Society. Just send ur postal address on this Email
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Free Islamic Books in different Languages and sent by mail:
http://www.sultan.org/books/

For more information about Islam feel free to contact me on [e-mail]

Answer 9

I never heard of him being a pagan in the first place....

Answer 10

mohmed rasoul alah didn't wrote the quraan !!! it was from allah !!
if u don't believe in islam its oky its ur own damn business but at least sheck ur stupid information befor spell it