What is your Opinion for CREATING ONE MUSLIM COUNTRY BY ABOLISHING EXISTING SEVERAL MUSLIM COUNTYIES?

Question

As per prophet Muhammad(SAL) authenticated hadees, it is must, all Muslim (nation) should unite and consider as one country, under one kalipah or amir. Then only it is possible retaliate enemy of Islam.

But now Islamic world has divided approximately 56 countries,

My advice is, all Muslim country should unite as one country, select an kalipah according to quean (and sunnah), allocate the province according to muslim cultural and language.

Country name should be UNITED STATES OF ISLAM with several Islamic provinces such as
PROVINCE OF ARABIA= for arab speaking people(SA, OMAN, JORDAN, SYRIA, EGYPT)
PROVINCE OF KURDISH= for kurdish people (IRAQ)
PROVINCE OF SHIITE= for shitte belief muslim/culture(IRAN)
PROVINCE OF URDU= for urdu speaking people (Pakistan, Afganistan)

and allocate the province according to cultural and language.

Answer 1

Definately.

This will also end terrorism.

Bye ...................

Answer 2

Fascinating question. I don't think it is a good idea. Countries and people need autonomy to function well. There is long-developed history and different sub-cultures within the Muslim world, and superficial division should not be used to try and create unity or rule more effectively. Ask South Africa, it does not make sense to divide people who belong together under one constitution! Your suggestion does not abolish the existing geographical division, it simply introduce cultural and ethnical division - which is worse.

This will not lead to the unity you desire, but will lead to further conflict - not only in opinion and practice, but also between existing countries with regards to scarce resources. Furthermore, how do you define the new collective 'enemy'? Is it the enemy of the previous countries, the new states or simply the enemy of the ideological belief? In this, there is no united thinking or practice between countries.

Simply not do-able... in my opinion!

Answer 3

Okkkk? My worry there is that you used the word retaliate. Do you want that for peace, or just to unite so you stand a better chance?? In a way I don't think it would solve the problems either way. Just look at the tribes of Israel, over 2000 years later and they're still trying to bash each other heads in. Let's just get rid of organized religion, period.

Answer 4

That would be exactly the same as creating one big Christian country instead of all the Christian countries existing today.

Nationality is not just about religions. Have you not seen what's happening now of the many newly created countries in Eastern Europe as a consequence of the War? They're all falling apart, and with considerable bloodshed, too.

Answer 5

Whatever you say.. You're speaking of peace right? but your promoting a genocide. the reason you people fight amongst each other is for control and to see who has more sand in their Dunes... How would you people be able to control the "United States of Islam"?? (<----- very original by the way) you should work for Hallmark..

Answer 6

You can't even stop fighting between the two sects, shiite, and suni, how do you expect to unite 56 countries

Answer 7

You guys can't even get along within your own country, and many Muslim countries still don't even have democracy, how do you expect to form a consented sovereign Muslim state?

Answer 8

Are they the creator of heaven and earth or living human kind like you and me.
Who made blunders with slip-ups and human errors on planet earth.
Different community have different kitchen's ettiquette.
Would you follow others kitchen's ettiquette of another community on planet earth?
Trace back how the blunders with slip-ups and human errors was created in the past.

Answer 9

Good idea, but it is never going to happen.
Muslims are divided even more than Christians are, and they seem to be willing to kill for it. Just look at the Shiia/Sunni split. They will never come together.

Answer 10

I would agree as long as they had no access to rest of the world..at least we wouldn't have to keep killing innocent people to reach them.

AND, just WHY would they have to retaliate? They would still be trying to take over others?

Chit! just blow them up when we get them in one place....go ahead, make your muslim country......

Answer 11

great theocratic country. Look at any government that is based on religion (USA, Israel, Saudi...etc) and see if it is really a perfect example?