A frequent argument in favor of illegal immigration is that it boosts the economy. What's your view?

Question

Is the 'boost our economy' argument valid, or just so much hyperbole? What social/economic impact do you think illegal immigration has on your community?

Answer 1

thats bull.....the reason why the economy is so strong right now is becuse we are at war and it is a fact that war is profitable.it hasnt been proven that illigals have made the econmy stronger,that sounds kinda crazy.illigal activist are trying to spread that notion around to try and confuse americans into letting them stay.

Answer 2

each of the Arizona regulation does in make sure the federal regulation handed in 1996 the position a community police officer stops someone for a diverse reason and the officer suspects the fellow should be in the country illegally, that individual should be delivered in and put in the front of a federal immigration reputable. After that the federal officer ought to take care of the issue as they do now. they could run the fellow's suggestions by ability of a pc to substantiate no matter if or not they are criminal or not. At that element it really is as a lot because the federal authorities because immigration is a federal remember. This works interior an same way even as a community officer suspects unlawful drugs, the suspect should be grew to grow to be over to federal officials. The Arizona justice equipment will deport no individual as thay is a US federal duty and the federal authorities will come to a call each case.

Answer 3

The united States was built on the back of low cost illegal immigrants. Without them costs, especially regarding agricultural, will increase. Yes there are some that abuse the system, but that is not 100 percent of them. Find and expel those that are a drain, and let those that just want to work stay. Building a wall is not the answer, because a tunnel can always be built. Companies are hiring these people to cut costs, and thus leave more money for reinvestment, which is better for the economy

Answer 4

If an illegal immigrant spends a dollar on a Slurpee at the 7-11, then the economy has been boosted. But whenever a dollar goes from the economy to an illegal immigrant, the economy is harmed.

An illegal immigrant takes in X number of dollars through labor, government handouts, charity, services, etc. If the amount of money he puts back into the U.S. economy doesn't equal or exceed what he takes in, then how is it good for the economy?

He/she does work for little pay, that's for sure. But does that mean that we're getting the product of his labor cheaper, or does it mean that his employer is making a fatter profit?

What happens to the money that he wires to his family in Mexico? What does that do for the U.S. economy? Does money leaving our country = economy boost?

As you can see, I don't have answers on this one; just more questions.

Answer 5

this issue goes both ways. some, Yes SOME not ALL, do burden society when it comes to medical care, but they also help to keep costs down on everyday needs like produce, meat/poultry, etc. i think this issue has been a major issue for 15 or so yrs, they didn't all jump the border overnight. but since our gvmt & politicians want us to turn our heads on Iraq & gas, well i guess this arguement will keep us busy until elections. how much is this war costing us? if produce & meat was double or triple, how many families would b able to drive their SUV's or pay their mortgages- i'm guessing lower & middle class would have a bit of trouble keeping up. Socially, well most Americans these days r just out right ignorant, rude, self righteous & lack morals. socially this country is going to h*ll in a hand basket. kids r raising kids, parents don't have time or care what's going on in their children's lives & try to buy their love with playstation & gameboys. i do have to say that illegals-mexican, indian, etc.- do value family more than the average American. Americans think its easy to cut all ties & drop the divorce ball once a problem comes up, other nationalities r not as quick to do the same. our country is being divided by an issue that has been & will continue to burden us for many yrs to come, but now politicians r making it a 2-sided issue-its either love em or HATE em. oh well, thats the good ol USA. sigh...

Answer 6

No not valid the only thing illegal aliens boost is the employers that they work for...cheaper labor means bigger profits. Take that in with all the state aid (food stamps, health care etc.) not to mention schooling for their kids then how can it possibly be a boost?? It can't ...plain and simple.
I won't even touch the tax issue......if they take, but don't put back in how is that a boost??

Answer 7

over 70% of the births in the Dallas, TX county hospital system are to illegals. None pay, including those whose babies need months and months of extensive, and expensive care. I think the millions in hospital bills might outway a few day laborers.

Answer 8

I think that "illegal immigrants" are a big part of our economy, because if you think about it how much money goes true their hands, millions and millions of dollars. they pay taxes they buy homes, cars etc etc.

Answer 9

it costs us approx. 55,000 a year for each illegal in this country...for housing, medical services, welfare, foos stamps and other govt services

that doersnt count the loss to private citizens from their crime, illegal driving, drugs, diseases.....

doesnt seem like they are as productive and giving as some illegal alien supporters would have you believe...

Answer 10

Results are out there--they are destroying it as on a whole.

Like it or not-the results show their a drain.