Should Amnesty be given to Ilegal imigrants......yes ...No?

Answer 1

This is my answer;

First who are you(in General) This country was build up for immigrants. You are judging the people without papers, but what happend with many of puerto rican people living for free collecting money from the government (welfare) it is a big % of this people living like this. What about the black people must of them criminals, killers. What about the white people, where they comming from(Italy, Ireland, Germany, from differents countries) "but they aren't inmigrants because they are whites", blue eyes. You are americans because you were born in this country. Please don't judge the others if you don't know them. Many of the inmigrants are a good people; they work very hard.
Just take your time and think about it. Don't be racist. you and me are inmigrants.

Answer 2

I think it must be done on a case by case basis. No most of the time. But what about somebody that has been here for 20 or 30 years and has family and career and has never commited a crime (except for illegaly entering country)? I think we should probably levy a fine on them, or find some other kind of punishment besides deportation.

Answer 3

With the housing marketplace out for lunch, illegals were hit extremely not basic. As an American living in Mexico, i'm getting to ascertain it from the different aspect. I search for suggestion from from those who say their kin up contained in the States (criminal or unlawful) are making plans to come back living house. those who had considered going to the U. S. (legally or illegally) 2 years in the past have now placed those plans on carry. So, amnesty received't help the monetary equipment, because many Latino immigrants artwork contained in the living house structure/upkeep marketplace (structure, portray, landscaping, and so on.). in spite of the indisputable fact that, amnesty will actual encourage better unlawful immigration. human beings could have a reason to bypass as a lot because the States illegally. that they'd say, "properly, the monetary equipment is undesirable, in spite of the indisputable fact that the prospect of me starting to be a US citizen is wisely worth it, so we are going." P.S. the undeniable reality that illegals are leaving the U. S. ought to look large, in spite of the indisputable fact that it truly is amazingly indicative of how undesirable the monetary equipment quite is.

Answer 4

NO ....how many times are we supposed to hand out the amnesty prize?? Reagan handed out the amnesty prize and now look at where we are at, debating the issue once again. Reagan said this is a one time deal, that amnesty wouldn't be handed out again. Now look at us back at friggin square 1, yet again.

Answer 5

yes
Secure the border.
Screen the illegals.
Deport the undesirables.
Give the rest Amnesty.

Answer 6

No, because suppose Bin Laden wants amnesty?

Answer 7

Yet no one is talking amnesty are they? The proposed law is not giving a clean slate to all illegals, so your question is moot.

Answer 8

NO, they should have to do it the same way many people before them had to. They still should be able to come here though. Unless you were native american, many of the ancestors of the us citizens today were immigrants.

Answer 9

If they have a legitamate reason as defined by Ins yes without exception.

Answer 10

No, that's rewarding criminal behavior. Do you give someone a million dollars that murdered someone? NO! I think we should deport all the losers back to the hole they crawled out of.

Answer 11

NO WAY!!! You DO NOT reward criminals!

Proud member of the Minutemen!

ARTHUR HAGLUND for President '08
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AhU8nSNdeCnAhYV4HemoOZ7sy6IX?qid=20060708113758AAY6CAB

DEPORT ILLEGAL ALIENS!

ENGLISH ONLY IN AMERICA!