English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

dont tell me its allah ok, i need answers based on reason and commonsense. give me the historical details

2006-07-12 01:19:32 · 12 answers · asked by s21181 1 in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

i heard that mohomed's were illiterate too

2006-07-12 01:23:16 · update #1

mohomed's friends too were illiterate

2006-07-12 01:23:46 · update #2

12 answers

Dictated by God to Muhammad (pbuh)then repeated to the people. They would then write down the message he had received. It would be written on anything handy Camel shoulder bone, leather and papyrus

The Quran was put into book form after the death of the Prophet it was placed in book form.

2006-07-12 01:32:55 · answer #1 · answered by Layla 6 · 3 0

He is called by the angle Cebrail (Gabriel) that he is a prophet at the age of 40. The first word was " Read." He replied he was illiterate. The Gabriel hug him so tight that he tought he was going to die. This happened three times. After he asked what he is going to read. The Gabriel said the full sentence.
"Yaratan Rabbının adıyla oku,
O, insanı kan pıhtısından yarattı,
Oku, Rabbin nihayetsiz kerem sahibidir.
Kalemle yazmayı öğreten O'dur. İnsana bilmediğini O öğretti."
I cannot translate it exactly. It is something like that "Read in the name of your creator. He created the human from a blood clot. Your creator is the owner of endless knowledge. He is who tought writing. He tougt the human that he did not know."

He was memorizing every ayet the Gabriel brings him. They were repeating at Ramadan days.
The first muslims learned it memorizing. After the death of the prophet, the director of the islam community Osman asked literets to write it down. All other copies refer to this first hand written book. You can see it in Topkapi Palace in Istanbul Turkiye.
You may think it could be changed. But Allah mentiones that he gave us this book and he is whom will protect it endlessly.

2006-07-12 08:48:21 · answer #2 · answered by tapsev 3 · 0 0

well , you know .... i have been asking that question though i am not a Muslim. but i red the book and you know what , when you read it , you feel that it is telling you stories that actual happened maybe couple of decades ago and in a way tells you story to come , so it can not be man written.... it has to be written by a more power full being ... in fact it has been collected a very long time ago... however, there are those verses that tells you about aids and that was not prevalent at the time it was written .. and it argues what a man can not predicate and when mentioned , it said , the future, what are in the wombs of women and rain ... but now we can know the gender of the child and we can now whether it will hail or not ... but i have an explanation to that , you can know the gender but you can not know how those kids will turn out to be ... you can predicates if it is going to rain Tom. but you do not know what time exactly ... it was also mentioned in that book , that iron will fly ,,, and it did , we have space shuttles and airplanes .. there is something mystic about this book ,, read it and you will know

2006-07-12 08:25:45 · answer #3 · answered by interested 4 · 0 0

God, but it was written down around the time of the Caliph Uthman.

By the way. Muhammed was NOT illiterate. He was a merchant which means that he must have been able to read receipts at least in Arabic and also, probably in several other languages. His friends were certainly not illiterate (certainly not Uthman, a great patron of literacy).

2006-07-12 08:22:48 · answer #4 · answered by quadrophenic1973 1 · 0 0

Interesting,the Quran as you can see is almost equivalent to Bible,and considering the writing one can not say that it is from God no;the Quran like the Bible has a history, along the line when all these hypothesis started, there is always a chance that this type os prophets or self proclaimed servants of God have a kind of secretary who follows them and write things as they see or told.
It is not fake neither is it real but the writings were for real and the contents happened just like the Bible.
I hope you are relieved with this answer.
Thanks.

2006-07-12 08:33:38 · answer #5 · answered by stace s 1 · 0 0

For ur Kind information Mohammad didnt Lean in any School but he was not illiterate. He was provided all the worlds Knowledge the Past ,Present and the future.

Never say what u dont know and dont share wrong Knowledge

2006-07-12 08:25:07 · answer #6 · answered by mdshamim2 2 · 0 0

Muhammed's first wife, Khadijah. I've taken several college history courses that did overviews of the origin of Islam, and they all said that Mohammed memorized the quaran as Gabriel told it to him and then recited it to his wife who copied it down.

2006-07-12 08:28:40 · answer #7 · answered by Hunter S. Thompson 3 · 0 0

i am Muslim.the Koran revealed to the prophet during 23 years . he had many companions. some of them wrote the Koran .they are not all illiterate.who wrote the Koran shared in the accumulation .one of them his name zaid ibn thabt. he was the writer and the chief in the collecting and wrote it all with evidences refared that any verses were in koran are koranic verses

2006-07-12 09:34:45 · answer #8 · answered by hussein a182 2 · 0 0

Friends of Muhammed, because he was illiterate.

2006-07-12 08:22:14 · answer #9 · answered by arewethereyet 7 · 0 0

It's a book. Books are written by Man. That's as common sense as it gets.

2006-07-12 08:23:41 · answer #10 · answered by Ricky J. 6 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers