Are student loans a scam to pump more money into a schools coffers?

Question

What I understand is your stuck with the debt regardless what happens and the schools make their money.

What erks me is how public schools push students into getting loans to go to school when the students themselves haven't even had a chance earning real world money and lacking and understanding of it.

Answer 1

No, student loans are a way to get your degree at a time when you can not afford to pay for classes, etc, and the interest is deferred until later when hopefully you have a better job. Sure you are stuck with the debt, you took out a loan! You do not have to take out four years worth if you do not want to, you can apply for a new loan each semester or year - and it is up to you to attend classes, by the time you are in college you are considered a responsible adult, so if you are in school act like one and study! Get the best grades you can, work hard at the courses, and it pays off in the end. Much better than messing around, only to get stuck with a loan and then blame it on the school because you did not apply yourself.
If you don't want to go through the hassles, don't bother with college at all, I know there are lots of jobs out there... if you don't want to make a lot.

Answer 2

Despite the other loaded, pollyannish answers on here, yes they are. But college like anything else is a business and getting an education is a commodity, your student loan is equity. I would try college before playing the lottery. Joining the military right now or dowries are asinine ideas also.

You can't tell me there's not some screwy stuff going on there though. For instance, my college "doesn't offer" the Direct Student Loan Program through the Dept. of Ed. WTF is that?! There's a kickback from Bank of America in there somewhere.

Answer 3

They only get what you pay them. Student loans are just like regular loans that go towards paying for school. If you flunk or whatever, then YOU didn't get your money's worth. That's not the school's fault.

Answer 4

Yes, they are destroying the very possibilities the young have ahead of them to be free and successful.

Do some serious research. Student Loans are hurting people beyond belief. There is plenty of free money, even a few years in the military is a better alternative. Here is an article from CNN/Money magazine:

Student loans - a life sentence
Forget about getting married and buying a home. This generation is thinking about next month's payment.
By Christian Zappone, CNNMoney.com staff writer
May 1, 2006: 4:25 PM EDT
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) - Mayrose Wegmann, 25, should have been starting on her dream career as a political consultant by now. And saving toward her first home.
Instead, Wegmann, who graduated with a degree in political science and journalism from the University of Iowa in 2004 and moved to Washington, D.C., is working at a non-profit because it pays significantly more than entry-level politics work. And she won't even consider buying a home for several more years.
In fact, she won't consider much except how to meet the $300 a month she owes on her $34,000 student loan balance.
"The school debt makes you decide [about your career] based on the money factor. Not based on what you want to do," said Wegmann.
The Class of 2006, set to graduate this month, will soon be in the same boat.
Approximately two-thirds of all students use loans to pay for their higher education, according to the Center for Economic and Policy Research. The average debt is $15,500 for public schools and $24,600 for private – many students rack up even more on their credit cards.
Call it a reverse dowry: college debt diverts careers and delays or impedes graduates' plans to get married, buy a home or even to start a family. The effects can last years.
A 22-year old student graduating this year who consolidates their $40,000 loan at 6.125 percent will need to pay $243 a month...until they're 52. By that time, they will have paid $47,494 in interest alone.
A reverse dowry
"My student loan debt is my biggest source of stress in my life at the moment," said Steve Desroches, a 2002 graduate from Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism. "I live paycheck to paycheck."
The degree left Desroches, who works for a newspaper on Cape Cod, $50,000 in debt with no savings. He's unable to buy a needed car or to even think about entering Massachusetts's "out of control" real estate market.
The repayments were so financially restrictive he briefly considered declaring bankruptcy, until he learned it wouldn't affect his student loans because they're federally guaranteed.
"My feelings about my degree now? My graduate education was invaluable [to my career], but it wasn't worth $50,000, or more accurately, it isn't worth the debt. My options are definitely limited."
Christine Moellenberndt of Sacramento, California has given up on the idea of owning a home, at least anytime in the next 10-15 years. She graduated last June from the University of California, Santa Cruz with a degree in anthropology, and moved back in with her mother when she realized not doing so would mean living paycheck to paycheck with no chance of paying down her debts.
"That $675 I could be spending in rent could also be a good chunk of a credit card payment, or a huge payment for my student loans. I see that as a bit of a better investment than living on my own and struggling paycheck to paycheck."
Moellenberndt says at least half her monthly income working at a state regulatory agency goes to pay off her $18k in federal student loans. And although the debt is daunting, her plans to become a community college professor call for an advanced degree...hiking her debt in the future.
A growing issue for the economy and society
The cumulative effect of such student debt on graduates is unclear, although few would argue that its impact will be positive for the graduates, the economy or society.
"We've never done this to a generation of young people before," said Dr. Heather Boushey, Senior Economist at the progressive Center for Economic and Policy Research. "We've never put a generation in their 20s in debt they can't get out of before they started their work life."
"The normal approach in any healthy society is to help young married couples get started in life through marital gifts, dowries, and the like," Allan Carlson of the socially-conservative Howard Center for Family, Religion, and Society said.
"We now burden many young adults with student debt, sometimes massive in nature; the price being paid includes marriages delayed or foregone and fewer children. This is foolish public policy."