Are immigrants really bad for America?

Question

In the last 5 years, undocumented workers have made over 78,000 new jobs, help generate over 3.8 billion in taxxes, reduced the deficite by 25%, raised the average U.S. wages by 18%.


Yet, the Americans want to force us out of the U.S. ... why ?

Answer 1

Understand this
LEGAL= GOOD
ILLEGAL= BAD
Has it been simplified enough for you to understand?

BTW- Check sources. Your numbers are so off it is comical.
In fact they lower wages. Try these sites

http://www.hispanicsforsecureborders.org/index.htm

http://www.cis.org/topics/illegalimmigration.html

"By increasing the supply of labor between 1980 and 2000, immigration reduced the average annual earnings of native-born men by an estimated $1,700 or roughly 4 percent.
Among natives without a high school education, who roughly correspond to the poorest tenth of the workforce, the estimated impact was even larger, reducing their wages by 7.4 percent.
The 10 million native-born workers without a high school degree face the most competition from immigrants, as do the eight million younger natives with only a high school education and 12 million younger college graduates.
The negative effect on native-born black and Hispanic workers is significantly larger than on whites because a much larger share of minorities are in direct competition with immigrants.
The reduction in earnings occurs regardless of whether the immigrants are legal or illegal, permanent or temporary. It is the presence of additional workers that reduces wages, not their legal status.... "- Center for Immigration Studies

Furthermore it states," Based on Census Bureau data, this study finds that, when all taxes paid (direct and indirect) and all costs are considered, illegal households created a net fiscal deficit at the federal level of more than $10 billion in 2002. We also estimate that, if there was an amnesty for illegal aliens, the net fiscal deficit would grow to nearly $29 billion."
"Although legalization would increase average tax payments by 77 percent, average costs would rise by 118 percent."
http://www.cis.org/articles/2004/fiscalexec.html

Answer 2

Whered You Get Those Numbers From
A Comic Book??

Anybody Can Make Up Statistics
Do Some Research
And Come Back With Some Real Data

I TOLD You 6 Questions Ago

GET AN EDUCATION

Answer 3

The real question is, where did you get your "facts"' Please tell us how illegal aliens created 78000 jobs? They may have filled that many, illegally by the way. I doubt that they have generated taxes in proportion to the number working under the table,"off the books". Do you really think they reported income earned as unreported day workers or unreported domestics? They have certainly not raised the average U.S wage but have hurt it, lowered it, by working cheap and pulling other wages down with them, into the gutter. Why did you make up this information. Why do you find it necessary to lie about it? Ridiculous.

Answer 4

Chupa... you are completely wrong! In fact, the American citizens pay over 50 billion dollars a year supporting illegal immigrants. In Arizona alone, 1.8 billion dollars of American tax money goes to illegal Mexicans. That means that I pay about 700 dollars a year for them to have their babies and get free health care. Did anyone ask me if my money could be used for that? NO! This money is taken from me without my consent by bleeding heart liberals that think illegal Mexicans flooding into this country is cute. They do not create more jobs, they take them away. They do not raise wages, in fact... if you pay any attention to the news at all, they drive wages down. You really need to wake up! Illegal immigrants (from Mexico) are saturating our health care system. The poor people of this country is what our 'free' health care is designed for. But, it is being overwhelmed with illegal Mexicans. I know many doctors and believe me when I say that they complain on a daily basis that they have to hire interpreters just to communicate with all the illegal Mexicans. They can't give good health care to Americans because their offices are run like assembly lines, just passing so many illegal Mexicans through day to day. Just because Mexicans overpopulated their own country, does not give them the right to come here and do the same thing to our country. They lack education, they can't speak our language and they have no job skills. So tell me, how are they helping America? In a recent study, it was found that Latinos in general have more babies than all the other races put together. They are the most prolific race on the planet. Why? Because they are ignorant of what their actions are doing to the world. Mexicans need to grow up and get a clue. They also need to stop coming here...because we don't want them here! I have some Mexican friends... They came here 'legally'! They did the paperwork, jumped through the hoops etc. I have no problem with that. But when your people flood across our borders by the MILLIONS, steal our childrens identities through your contacts in the social security offices, don't pay taxes (how could you if you are not legally employed), commit crimes such as welfare fraud, employment fraud, identity theft, etc..why do we want them here? Some of my friends are on the police force. They complain, telling me that more than 90 percent of all drunk drivers are illegal Mexican immigrants. I can't go anywhere in my town without seeing illegal Mexicans drinking beer while driving or on the job site. Mostly, they are just standing around while everyone else is working. Hard working people? Sorry..don't see it. So tell me... how do your people make our country better? If your people have problems in their own country, then stay there and solve them. Don't run away to America and expect Americans to give you a free ride. If your people would stop having so many babies...then maybe you wouldn't have an over population issue. Keep it in your pants! Don't make us pay for your blind stupidity!

Answer 5

What part of illegal don't you understand. You mentioned 3.8 billion in generated taxes, that is a lot of money, but when you consider that California itself paid over 21 BILLION dollars just in uncompensated medical costs for illegal immigrants, that 3.8 billion isn't a drop in the hat, not to mention the 9 billion it cost California in welfare for illegal immigrants. You need to get your facts straight. Do you know that the Mexican government is in its "twelth edition" of pamphlets that read 'HOW TO GET INTO AMERICA AND GET FREE STUFF"

Answer 6

why can't immigrants come to America the right way if they want to be here so bad??? The come here and take over jobs where Americans have lived all there lives. I don't think it right, if you want the chance of freedom and you want to be here then do it the right way and no one will ***** at you. I think is crap that we have low life Americans here that will be immigrants crappy pay because they know they are desperate for cash, but do sell yourself short come here the right way and get a good job and be somebody. that's all we ask.

Answer 7

Ya buddy, your statistics make you look REAL SMART...NOT! Get your facts and questions straight! I know you mean illegals, and you're wrong, they REDUCE the average U.S. wages dumbass! If I ever find out where you live, I will report you to the authorities and they will send you back to Mexico. Isn't that what you want?

Answer 8

There are legitimate numbers available. Why make them up?

We pay tens of billions each year for education and services for illegals, and the vast numbers of them are degrading education and services for our own people.

A smaller number would have been a smaller problem. However, this is a huge number and a huge problem.

Enough is enough.

Answer 9

The US IS immigrants. The only people that have a right to ***** about immigrants are Native Americans.

People are just instinctively territorial, and many are xenophobic. They'll get over it.

Answer 10

If immigrants were taken out of the workforce our farms would fail and where would that leave us. There is an excellent article in Texas Farm Bureau's July issue. Farms are not making alot of money as it is.