Brady or Manning? Whose better with everything considered?

Answer 1

Payton Manning.(period)

Answer 2

People can say oh its because Tom Brady is on a better team. The question you still have to ask yourself is, "Who got the job done." and that is Tom Brady. I love Manning more, but Brady got the job done. He is the one that is the leader of the team, and the leader of the offense. It wasnt just luck either, it was 3 superbowl rings. Manning had a really good shot last year, and he choked and got shut down. As of this moment Brady is better with everything considered. But in time Manning could add a few rings on his finger.

Answer 3

Manning has better recievers and a better Offensive line. While both QBs statistically have the same qualities, Manning has better support. I'd pick Manning over Brady. Plus Brady is playing hurt for the past 2 years, not many people know that. So, you dont know when he will need a week's rest or two.

Answer 4

Brady, Manning may have the better stats but its all about the rings and Brady has 3 Manning has 0

Answer 5

Manning, undoubtedly. The only reason Brady has the championship and Manning does not is that Brady has been on much, much better teams. Brady is a really good quarterback, but Manning is an all-timer.

Answer 6

I think that Brady is on a better team than Peyton Manning because Brady won three rings with The Pats. and Manning with none with the Colts. Besides that I think that Brandy is better because when he is in tough situation he can over come it no matter what. Look at Brandy playoffs record and look at Manning. Brandy has a way better record because he is a great quaterback and can lead his team to victory not like Manning who can't. Tom Brandy is better than Manning. Even though Brandy was a 7th round draft pick and Manning was 1st overall. LOL, it doesn't matter when you get drafted it defends who well you play in the NFL.

Answer 7

Well if you mean Tom Brady then he is.

OK dude what are you smoking that you say Brady has been on much, much, better teams. Seriously. Ok Brady has a better defense. Manning has the better offense. Manning has been on the better overall team. There weren't the constant injuries. There weren't the problems with having to bring guys off defense to suddenly be recievers. Manning KNEW his recievers. He also had pro-bowl recievers, and everyone KNEW their names. Want me to go on? Face it Manning has the better team. He has the better targets. As to Brady's coach HAHAHAHHAHAHAHA. Don't give that man undue credit. Look at his carrer in Cleveland for proof of it being Brady more then it being Bellichick.

Answer 8

Peyton manning wins 12-14 games a year peyton and an offense there is no defense in indy. Brady had one of the best defences in the league every time he went to the superbowl. Offense wins games Defense wins championships, case in point, indy or pittsburgh, give indy the patriots defense or even a mediocre defense and it could be a 16-0 team

Answer 9

Brady is better than Manning,
brady just wins thats all you can say,
manning might set records but he doesnt do anything when it counts and thats in big games, brady just keeps winning. manning has better receivers around him than brady ever had. manning can throw all touchdowns he wants and he is great qb during the regular season. but he cant and wont win the big one, not with the colts anyway.

Answer 10

Manning has the numbers...but where are his rings?

Tom Brady is better...and if he can get the Pats to the playoffs this year without all those players they lost, then he's definately one of the best ever, that'd be a miracle. I definately don't expect the Patriots back into the playoffs...but weirder things have happened.