Do Prison's Really Rehabilitate Criminals?

Question

or do they just learn more tricks of the trade while in the big house?

Answer 1

NO NO NO Prisons do not rehabilitate criminals-SOME prisons offer education, but how is this rehabilitation? Some offer trade classes, this is not rehabilitaion. Just becuase they teach you a trade or educate you as in education per se, this is not rehabilitation. The feds have a drug program for dealers, this is as close to rehab anyone is going to get. Do you think the prisons are teaching Murders how to NOT want to murder anyone when they get out? Are the teaching rapists how NOT to rape when they get out? NO NO NO

The prisons are not even teaching them how to redirect there anger or how to deal with something the appropriate way. They need to counsel prisoners, put them in groups sesions and make it mandatory that they attened. Yes prison is for punishment, however they need to teach them how to better theselves and how to deal with situations.

I have about 25 guys on my site and another 30 that are not on my site that I am working with-We are putting together books, art shows, fundraisers and so on. I teach them how to redirect there attention and how to be as productive as possible while they are doing there time. I am only one person but I teach them the meaning of compassion, understanding, self worth, respect, friendship and give them an outlet for there talents and show them there are other things out there besides crime.

Just imagine how many have no one, they had no one to begin with-if you give them someone than they learn to value life a little more and are more apt to stop the cycle. No one wants to give them the time of day-so don't only blame the prisons and the law, blame society.

Answer 2

It's not the job of the prison to rehabilitate inmates. The inmates have to want to be rehabilitate therefore most inmates learn absolutely nothing useful in prisons. They are however offered trade learning, as well as high school GED programs. Some college courses are also offered with a fee. So really only those who take advantage to the system can truly accept rehabilitation.

Answer 3

i believe that there is a few rehabilitation that takes position. Many will emerge from penal complex as persons which could be a benefit to society if society provides them a danger. yet there are a selection of issues that exist. We as a society can not honestly ignore that someone has been a prisoner and we carry that above their head for some thing else of their existence. also, the acts that take position in penal complex are missed by using the equipment. particular gangs that exist, means that particular ones and gangs have contained in the walls, sexual misconduct both forced and passive, drugs and so on. those moves make contributions to someone's stay in penal complex in a unfavorable experience. till those acts are addressed head on, we shouldn't anticipate a variety of of reliable to come back from our inmates. yet, we shouldn't position each and every of the blame on them.

Answer 4

Some do get the tools they need to function in an acceptable manner when released. And some do learn how to be better at what got them there in the first place. It is part of the individual's mindset. Some don't want rehabilitating, others do. I used to work as an officer, and there was this one who kept a picture of a sports car, a beautiful woman and a picture of a bottle of whiskey. He said he lost control to those things and wanted to learn to over come the temptations so he wouldn't break his momma's heart and slide again. I hope it worked for him.

Answer 5

NO!! Our prison system doesn't do anything but give people 3 square meals, and exercse room and "free" cable TV, and a bed to sleep in. They get out and cannot function in the real world, they can't get a job because no one wants to hire them, so they break the law again just so they go back. I know this from some of my former classmate who have been in prison. What I think we should do is send all of the prisoners over to Iraq and Afhganistan and tell the Lifers and Death row inmates to go and find Osama and he would be caught within a week.

Answer 6

Afraid there is more "learning tricks of the trade" than rehabilitation going on. . .

Answer 7

there was a time that they did....sort of in the 70's to the early 90's it seemed they were doing so but now as more and more prisons are privatly run they are less about rehabilitating then they are about legal slavery.....kinda makes you wonder why noone seems to help these guys when they get out, guess they make more money for them inside huh.

Answer 8

They do not rehabilitate just punish. You can't learn anything in prison accept to stay alive. I can do that on the streets.

Answer 9

Nope

The Idea of prisons as punishment in the mainstream is relatively new (within the last 250 years) If you look at the track record of released prisoners in the U.S. , over 70% re-offend within the first 12 months of being released....

Cant really argue that it works can you?

I'm with the arabs on this one - cut off their hands!!!

Answer 10

I personally don't believe that it does, to most criminals, it might change a few who were not really "hardcore" to begin with. Like the petty thief who was just trying to survive on the streets compared to the gangster/thug/drug dealer who has had at least 5 convictions to his name already. And also if you believe in Hollywood movies, then yes they do learn to be better criminals in there. I can't think of any alternative solution right now, though. Perhaps a better solution might be to have them fight in a war in order to regain their freedom? At least for those who are not already murderers and rapists. For those, they're better off as "cannon fodder" saves the cost of electrocuting them or gassing them.