Is the Death Penalty Un-Christian?

Question

Why would pervaiors of forgiveness wish death upon another?

Brian: Try answering the question next time.

Looks like Christain Hypocrasy at its best here folks!!

So let me get this right....Its ok to kill people, as long as you think God wills it. But God forgives all after youve killed them, and he forgives you for killing them too. But, you cant forgive them before you kill them and you cant forgive yourself because thats Gods Job. So I can kill who I want, Im just not allowed to forgive them. Ok.....I think Ive got it!

Answer 1

Death-penalty is un-human in my eyes, for any offence. Every human being deserves a second chance.

Every crime is in the end to blame on society in total. It's a weak society that can't educate humans enough to live a life without crime. An even weaker society needs to kill people when they can't handle the people. It's really a sign of weakness.

Since the death-penalty is un-human, and christians seem to be humans as well, mathematically it would mean that the death-penalty is also un-christian. Seeing some of the answers above, i'm not that sure if it's un-christian.

Answer 2

You might think so, since Jesus was crucified (the death penalty in His day). On the other hand, He had the power to take the forgiven thief next to Him off of the cross and rescue him. Instead, Jesus looked beyond death to the promise of everlasting life. There are two undeniable truths that all Christians ought to believe--that actions should and do reap consequences, and that God forgives them no matter what they've done. I've met convicted felons on death row who, after becoming Christians, have no problem with the death penalty--they know what they deserve for what they've done. Yet, these men were my brothers with whom I am soon to spend a very, very long eternity. The death penalty, properly exercised, is a just penalty for certain crimes. Christians should not scream for blood, nor should they avoid the "time to kill" spoken of in Eccl. 3. The balance is loving and forgiving the convicted murderer and loving him right up to the time his temporary life ends and his eternal one begins.

Answer 3

Jesus said when someone does you wrong, to turn the other cheek. When a soldier forces you to carry his gear for a mile, carry it two miles. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. (It does NOT say, as some have misquoted, "do unto others as they do unto you.")

The just thing, the fair thing, would be to give the death penalty to a murderer. But, that would not be the loving thing. The Old Testament rules tell us what is right and just. The New Testament love teaches us about the forgiveness that is available, and that message is more clear because we understand that there is a huge difference between what we deserve, and what we get.

I don't think the death penalty, as a theory, is un-Christian. It is just and fair. I think carrying it out is un-Christian. It is not loving.

Answer 4

I believe that if the person charging that penalty is SURE that the defendant killed someone, then I think it is right. But unfortunately, we can never be sure, some people have been to the point of reading their accusations on the gallows and someone rushed in with proof that he was inoscent, just in time to save the defendants life. But honestly, i wouldn't charge the death penalty to someone that killed a loved one to me, i would make them realize what a horrible thing they have done and how that person can never be replaced. I think that would be enough punishment to live with that if they truly understand how it feels.

Answer 5

No it is not un-christian for the most extreme cases. it is neither right nor wrong by the principle of double effect. The object of the dealth penalty is protecting ones self and this does not outweigh the evil according to christinan denominations. People have a right to protect themselves if the criminal is a danger to society even in prison. In most cases however, the death penalty is un-christian because alot of death row inmates arent threats once locked away in jail.

Answer 6

There are 2 important motives for the "dying Penalty" - a million. To punish the criminal, giving justice to the sufferer. 2. To be a deterrent to skill criminals. The "dying Penalty" became getting used on a regular basis interior the subculture that paJesus lived in. He even suffered being crucified. He hung on a go between 2 thieves being placed to dying. If he became in fact against it, he might have suggested so. The commandment is "Thou shall not homicide", or "Thou shall not kill (an harmless)". think of back to the subculture while the bible became translated. The dying penalty has been around for hundreds of years... If God meant "Thou shall not kill" to intend that that's consistently incorrect to take a human existence, then why did he deliver the army of Israel to kill and ruin lots interior the old testomony? human beings do not deserve forgiveness. God forgives people who confess Jesus as their savior because of the fact Jesus died to PAY for their forgiveness. we are meant to forgive human beings while they do us incorrect, yet that doesn't mean the legal outcomes are set aside. If the legal device merely enable genuinely everyone circulate and suggested "we forgive you" there may be no deterrent for crime. The "dying penalty" may be lots greater effectual interior the U.S. if it became used lots greater generally, and lots quicker. no person must be sitting on "dying row" for some years. that may not a deterrent. Executions must be painful and public. it fairly is a factor of the deterrent.

Answer 7

most Christians do not believe in the death penalty i am a christian and do not but because i believe that is an easy out those who murdered our loved ones have left this earth with their suffering in the penitentiary and we are left to mourn our loved ones until we pass on. I say let them stay in prison the rest of their natural life and then onto hell they'll go

Answer 8

I believe that God has the right to take away life, not humans. God forgives sins....shouldn't we? i mean...what if someone commited murder and he was killed for it, but the very next day if he wasnt killed he was going to confess his sins and live for God from then on.......we just ruined his chance to go to heaven. I think it is un-christian myself.

Answer 9

You have to ask yourself if God would want that kind of person running around killing people. The answer is “No”. The bible says: An eye for an eye.

Answer 10

"God told Joshua to kill every man, woman, and child, and He killed masses of people in Revelation. If that’s your ‘God of love,’ I want nothing to do with Him!"

God didn’t confine His wrath to the Canaanites, or to those mentioned in Revelation. He proclaimed the death sentence upon the whole of humanity. We will all die because we have broken God’s Law. Every one of us is waiting on death row. Instead of standing in moral judgment over Almighty God, we need to judge ourselves according to the Law of God. We will find that we have a multitude of sins and therefore are deserving of punishment. Yet God, out of love, paid the penalty for our sin so we would not have to.