What do you think would happen if 12-20 million of America's poorest and neediest citizens moved to Mexico?

Question

And starting demanding rights, jobs and public assistance would Mexico welcome these people and would the church do it's part and provide for these people. Would Mexico then have Press 1 for spanish.Press 2 for english?? Would the Country of Mexico be upset over Americans taking their jobs?

Answer 1

They might make it a better nation-they know how.

Answer 2

The differencce bet. Mexico's poorest and America's poorest is that the mexicans work their butts off in America. They may demand a lot but without them a lot of cities would stop functioning.

I have never seen an american make an effort till now to learn another language. Even those that live in Europe expect the locals to speak english and act irritated when a german e.g. doesn't speak perfect english to them..!!

So yes, if 12 million poor americans did the following:
1) go and do some useful work in mexico, even illegally
2) didn't learn the language

the mexican govt. would have no choice but to make Press 1 for Spanish Press 2 for English.

Answer 3

It will teach the Mexican new government to clean up the corruption in the country and soliciting the corporations to have more plants in Mexico then the people can earn their fair living.I wish a good thing happens in Mexico.It about time that The U.S. support the Mexican government and prepare to help so we will reduce the trade deficit from China if we give the different to Mexico instead.I have no idea what is the Republican is going to deal with 12-13 million of our illegal friends.What can i say it is economic than politics? In my opinion,we let the immigration problem slight and no one wants to talk about and now we are poor because, we spent our money to war,I have been told it is 1 trillion and I am not sure about our future and how are we going to pay for and it is going to be the same as how the Mexican will pay for our poor12-20 million American move to Mexico.

Answer 4

Great question. Here's what would happen...

Mexico would utilize their surging population by investing in heavy manufactuting and exporting their products to the world, especially the US, and the enormous demand for jobs would decrease labor prices. These factories would then export to the US, whose small working-class population would not be able to support the consumer demand of the upper class. This would cause mexican factories to increase prices, which it would be able to do since the US would have no way to increase internal production. Thus, more international firms would set up in Mexico taking advantage of all the excess labor (just like in China). The mexican economy would grow for years at a 10% growth rate (just like China), and it would threaten to become the largest, most powerful economy in the world. The American migrants would realize that if they ever wanted to better themselves, they would have to adapt to Mexican culture, so they would. After 2 or 3 generations, the migrant populations would have effectively "Mexicanized" and the descendents of migrants would move up the social and economic ladders in the country to become engineers and executives of all the huge, new corporations that were operating in Mexico.

If the US was smart, it would embrace migrants and their overall positive effect on our economy. Read the Economist (Magazine). The most brilliant economic minds in world think our country is out of its mind for trying to keep out workers that we desperately need to sustain our aged population.

Answer 5

unlawful immigration motives many complications that's for certain. that's an incontrovertible reality. Given your estimate of 20 million illegals enable's proceed from there. enable's say even a million/3 of them are preserving jobs. that's almost 7 million human beings contained in the artwork force. Contributing to the tax base etc. that would go away 7 million job vacancies. would our us of a be able to administration that many leaving the artwork force? probable no longer. would individuals step into those jobs for the pay provided? probable no longer. organizations base line is income. would they develop wages to get individuals to artwork those jobs? probable no longer. extra organizations would commence to outsource. to that end leaving many individuals out of jobs that now carry jobs. Our total us of a would fall down and the excellent melancholy would look like a cakewalk. As i have pronounced unlawful immigration is incorrect and desires to end. yet we also want to be sensible on deporting as you're saying 20 million human beings. trust me...that is not any longer going to ensue for distinct motives. So we could flow ahead and picture of sensible methods to administration the difficulty at hand and likewise insure the unlawful difficulty is stemmed contained in the destiny. better border safe practices and visa structures want to be dealt with first and preferable so the difficulty would not gradually worsen. once the flow is stopped we may be able to then artwork on what to do with those already right here.

Answer 6

Well I'm sure Mexico would demand money from America to suppport them because mexico can't even support it's own people. I'm sure they wouldn't cater to us like they expect to be catered to.

Answer 7

Um, no, because they would be a) rounded up and/or b) shot.

Take a look at Mexico's laws.

Even worse, take a look at Mexico's PRACTICES when it comes to illegal immigrants.

Answer 8

Well, considering Mexico is not afraid to enforce their own laws, which are strict with harsh penalties, I am guessing that wouldn't fly. We'd just get them back.

Answer 9

if americans started moving to mexico they wouldnt make it far enough to get a job... they would get shot the minute they crossed the border

Answer 10

Why always the same quiestion...?
thanx 4 the 2 pts...

Answer 11

I think they'd get their butts sent back to america, post-haste, and you'd never hear the end of it...