read the whole question before answering: why were the jews given/sent back to isreal after ww2?

Question

it seems more logical they should have been give germany.. they were already ,by their choice in europe, they deserved germany after the holacost.. if you tell me that isreal is threir homeland ... please tell me why thy were in europe, why they didnt go to isreal in 1920, 1900 ,1800? why aftre so many years away why was the desition to make isreal the home of the jews.. and who made that desicion... i think they should have been give germany. i think they got screwed... and because a bad desicion was made only bed things came of it .tell me why?

..ok after vreading the 1st 3 responses let me add this : please only respond if you can read and write english??????what the heck are these 3 talking about???read the question , answere the question...if you disagree w/ my premis thats fine, say so and respond in kind.

well then jose', why were they all over europe?? maybe i'm not being clear.. they could have gone to isreal 100 years before the holecost but they choose to live in europe.."WHO" decided they should go back to isreal and not be given germany as a "spoil" of war???

well "saigonese" i tell you what i think, i think you were supposed to be on vacation! lol, take a break , give "answers" a rest an enjoi nyc. lol.. that said ..good answere... but i'll say this, if we gave iraq to kuate[sp] after the 1st gulf war we wouldnt be in todays mess... to the victor goes the spoils.. anyway, did you know all that off the top of your head??? ban biet NHIEU!

Answer 1

It's believed that the Hebrews, through some of the oldest known evidence of agriculture & of primitive town life, probably arrived in the land now known as Israel in the 3rd millennium BC. Under King David & his successors (100 BC-597 BC), Judaism was developed & secured.
After being conquered by the Babylonians, Persians & Greeks, an independent Jewish Kingdom was revived around 168 BC. Rome took effective control in the next century, suppressed the Jewish revolts, and renamed it Judea Palestine.
Palestine was invaded by the Arabs in 636, within a few centuries, the region was overtaken by the presence of the Arabic language & the religion of islam. Though remained a Jewish minority, a majority of Jews fled into exiles & scattered all over the world.
The land was ruled from the 11th century as part of non-Arab empires by Seljuks, Mamluks & Ottoman (present day Turkey).
After 4 centuries of Ottoman rule, during which the Jews population declined to a low of 350,000 (in 1785), the land was taken in 1917 by Britain, which pledged to support a Jewish national homeland there. A British Palestine Mandate was recognized In 1920.
Jewish repatriation & immigration's begun in the late 19th century, swelled in the 1930s w/ Jewish refugees from the Nazis; at the same time, heavy Arabs immigration from Syria & Lebanon also occurred.
The UN General Assembly voted in 1947 to partition Palestine into an Arab & a Jewish state. Britain withdrew in 1948.
Israel was declared an independence state in May 14th, 1948 in spite of the rejection of the Arab states. Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq & Saudi Arabia, formed an Arab states alliance & launched a massive invasion, but failed to destroy Israel. Israel, in the other hand, not only defeated the invaders but also gained more teritory....

Giving Germany to the Jews doesn't sound logically like a good idea. It's like saying that, the Vienamese were suppressed by the Chinese for centuries, let the Vietnamese be granted China as their homeland of choice.(It sounds like a good idea knowing the fact that, according to accient history of Asia, land that historically belonged to Vietnam used to be further up north, deep into China, by the present day HK & Kowloon peninsula. After thousands of years being invaded by the Chinese, the Vietnamese were gradually driven southwards - which in turn invaded & eventually annexed the Kingdom of Champa in 1832 by emperor Minh Mang)

Having viewed a brief history of the State of Israel, I think the land is historically & rightfully belongs to the Jewish people. No ones but he Jews themselves made the decision to establish their own sovereign nation, since they've always longed to be nowhere else but to be back to the holy land of their ancestors. What do you think Ong Jon ?

Answer 2

if u want to occupy land u can use religion

Europeans tried to occupy that area from roman till England
and in some era they used Christianity as a reason
i will give u a reasons that those people are not israelians as past

1 ) look to the race u can find black Jew from Ethiopia and very white Jew from Russian and races is from millions of years not from 5000 years

2 ) Egypt for example were Christians and talking qept language after Arabs enter all Egyptians became moslimes and spoke Arabic

also Palestinians they converted to christian in the era of christian Romans
and then they converted to Islam and spoke Arabic
u can notice that there is Christians and moslimes in Palestinians its not a religions its a country
Israel tried to stole lands by religion even history they also say that Jew who build pyramids
i think they need pyramids to ride it

Answer 3

as far as I know Jews don´t like to mix with other cultures they don't eat the same things the local people eat, they don't marry the local people, they live together in neighborhoods where other people is not accepted. Of course they interact with local. I think that Israel was a good solution , it was their homeland at least in their religion.

Answer 4

because Israel is the homeland of jews. it was given to abraham and all of his decendents by G-d and they wanted to return. before wolrd war 2 the jewish ppl were exiled out of Israel many many times so they just wanted to return. and they weren't sent their they went and they won it back in a battel.

Answer 5

chao ong jon! ong jon dao nay khoe khong? chau xin loi, chau khong biet tra loi cau nay....lol lol hahahahahaha

Answer 6

A racist solution to a racist problem is no solution at all.