if u r a catholic can u join an adventist choral? Pls inform me?

Question

cause i auditioned in a choire and passed but i didnt say my religion my cousin said i cant cause i am not from ther religion...
pls tell me!

the point is will it be embarrassing if i do and will be kicked off...?

i am not an active in catholicsm its just when i was born...

Answer 1

The beliefs of the Seventh-day Adventist Church differ quite a bit from the beliefs of the Catholic Church.

You sound like you are unsure of which Church you should attend. Just about all Churches have choirs looking for good singers.

I suggest you make a thorough and prayerful search for the place where God is calling you to worship.

Please do not exclude your childhood home, the Catholic Church, in your search. The choir at your local Catholic Church is probably also looking for singers.

With love and prayers in Christ.

Answer 2

Do you go to Mass on Sundays and Holy Days? How about receiving the sacraments of the Catholic Church?
I am a Catholic and I know of no specific rule in the Church that would prevent you from participating in another church's choir--as long as your participation would not keep you from fulfilling the obligations of the Catholic Faith. However, the Adventists may have rules or expectations. You probably ought to talk to your parish priest about this opportunity--then talk to the Adventist church folks, too. Also, check out the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Good luck!

Answer 3

I assume you mean that the choral sings during their services. If that is the case...(if it is just singing at concerts, ignore my answer and seek other advice)

The answer is No.

First the Adventists probably will not let you.

Secondly, Catholics are not allowed to actively participate in the normal worship of non-Catholics/Orthodox because you are implying that you agree with their doctrine and faith and are in communion with them, which is false (and thus you would be bearing false witness). Given that the choral actively participates in the services of that denomination, that is something that you cannot do. Also given the hostility of Adventists to Catholicism, this is not something that you should do.

Answer 4

Of course u can join (just like u could rob someone) but if u go by what a catholic should do the answer is no because u r not suppose to actively participate in any other service.

Answer 5

A true Catholic is not even supposed to ENTER a church of some other denomination. I remember when I was a kid, our Brownie troop met in the basement of a church, and the Catholic girls were not allowed to join because of that. They had their own separate troop. We thought it was funny because it was the basement, not the sanctuary, but they said they could not be in the same building. When we went to a different building for Girl Scouts, they were allowed to join.

Answer 6

The truth will be out sooner or later. And it may cause you more heartaches if later.

Suggest you come clean with it. I see no reason why a catholic cannot sing worship songs in adventist assembly.

Answer 7

I'm an Adventist.I think it is up to the rules and regulations of the chorale you are joining.

Answer 8

If you came to my church, you would be very welcome as long as you have a good voice and, more important, the willingness to praise God. I know God would accept you and if someone from that specific church would decide you are not suitable, it would be most shameful.


An Adventist

Answer 9

In my opinion, you can do whatever you want to do
Dont let a religion define who you are or what you choose to do