who is the 10 th best player in the nfl?

Question

#1 ladanian tominlinson
#2 shaun alexander
#3 peyton manning
#4 larry johnson
#5 chad johnson
#6 tom brady
#7 mike vick
#8 steve smith
#9 Carson palmer
#10 TBA

i do not pick the players the person with the majority of the votes gets the spot and the only way i pick is if two or more people are tied then i pick so please dont blame me blame the people the voted

Answer 1

Randy Moss

Answer 2

1 Reggie Bush
2 Deuce McAlister
3 Ladamian Tominlinson
4 Shaun Alexander
5 Tom Brady
6 Chad Johnson
7 Peyton Manning
8 Vince Young
9 Steve Smith
10 Micheal Vick

Answer 3

First off That list is really bad. Your looking for the 10 best players....well why do you give these guys those positions? I mean Tom brady lead his team to alot alot alot of victories. Ben Rothensburger isnt on there and he took his last seeded team to a superbowl victory. Now if this is a list by the people...than the people are not doing too well. The number one Reciver isnt even on there (Terrel Owens) Sorry Champ but that list..is wack. For number ten position though. I'd give it to Warren Sapp.

Answer 4

To answer your question..I'll say Tiki Barber...based on his stats from the past few years (nearly 1900 rushing yards last year, I think he got 11 TD's combined)...and his importance to his team. Without him, the Giants offense wouldn't go anywhere...having a running back like Barber was vital in Manning's development, as it made sure there was a viable option to execute the offense in case Manning couldn't get the job done. This fact, combined with the fact that Barber has led the league in yards from scrimmage for the past two years, makes him the most productive player (statistically and in his ability to lead his team to victories) not on the list; and thus, I believe Tiki Barber should be the 10th "best" player in the league.

However, it's impossible to quantify or rank together players of different positions all in one list. Are you asking for "best" in terms of statistical production? Or perhaps "best" in the sense that they are the emotional leaders of a team and they provide unmeasurable intangibles necessary for their team to win?

I understand that these are people's opinions,,,but who is to say that Michael Vick is a "better" player than Carson Palmer? What is he better than Palmer at? 40-yd dash? 20 yd shuttle? leaping ability? his ability to lead his team to victory? again... There's no way to judge who is the "best" unless you specify among positions and statistics...ex: If I said Greg Jones is a better player than Peyton Manning because Jones rushed for 530 more yards than Manning did...would you agree? A more realistic comparison would be...say among QB's...who's better in terms of passing yards/TD's/passer rating etc...

Answer 5

defense deserves some mention here. ray lewis anyone? top three athletes ever to play the game possibly. shaun taylor...absolutly vicious. derrick brooks, a lot of people forget he was defensive player of the year a few years back. give the young bucks like shawn merriman, bob sanders and madieu williams some love as well.

Answer 6

Clinton Portis

Answer 7

Tony Gonzales

Answer 8

Bart Starr

Answer 9

Torry Holt

Answer 10

That is messed up as I said before but I do not blame you, I blame the idiotic voters.

Clinton Portis

Answer 11

Isn't it weird that every 'best' list never inlcudes DEFENSE? How about Ed Reed on your list? Julius Peppers? Urlacher has to be in there somewhre.