Leave illegals alone and go after the employers?

Question

Will this work?
How?
Won't the government still have to actively identify the illegals?
Won't this still take job from the illegals?
Won't the illegals still be here looking for more illegals work?
Wn't this bring about more illegals trying to get welfare?
Won't this bring an even bigger cry of, "If you are not going after the illegal, how can you go after the guy who hires him, aren't they two sides of the same coin?"
How will fining ONLY the employers but not punishing the tax-evading illegals help?
Can anyone answer these questions?

Answer 1

Nope, the points of argument are all yours. Do you have a possible solution? Maybe putting some Americans who have lived for generations on welfare to work doing the jobs the illegals came for.?

I say just wait, the next great depression is coming and the situation will resolve itself. No work is too hard or dirty when your family is starving.

Answer 2

Employment falls into the science of economy. As long as there is a demand side, the supply side will follow. A growing economy needs to supply what society demands. What we are facing is a corrupt demand side, employers who rather pay cheap labor than pay what our society demands. The problem must be solved there before the supply factor can weaken to make it viable once more to hire legally and pay wages that are required by its economy. A country is ruled by three powers; economic, government and the media. If the first two are "partners" to ruling the country using a system that is illegal and is hurting its citizens, the third power must be used to be heard by the people and for the people!

Answer 3

Sure it will, if the Immigration And Naturalization Service is funded and backed up .

Illegals won't come if there are no jobs. Employing illegals is a big time graft..where do you think all the "Withholding" goes? Much of never gets any further than the employers pocket. If it does go the government, it stays there. Illegals don't file taxes. If they did they'd get caught. Most of them are paid minimum wage or less.
I'd like to see truckloads of our whining welfare white trash trucked to the farmlands of California and told to get to picking or no more hand outs. At least Mexicans come here to work!

Answer 4

Both.
With stiff stiff penalties on employers. And I would check those tax records.
Both our breaking the law.

Both and all should be held accountable. They made choices-they must face the road they took.

This will bring backlash to our welfare system-who is already in trouble.
And in that many suffer unless benefits are cut off too.

It is sad that many will suffer-because laws were not obeyed . And many are suffering now because the cost of living for SSD and SS have not been getting enough cost of living rises to live right (call any hospital anywhere and ask if someone is there who couldn't affort medicine on SSD or SS). Because the money was going out to fast.

This is where the sins of the father is passed to the children comes from. It is a snowball effect. If laws were followed to begin with -less people would be injured-sadly Illegal and legals will all feel some effect, Thanks to those who didn't follow law to begin with.

Answer 5

Well you ask ALOT of questions in one question SO I will give you MY thoughts on the subject and again this is MY answer to THIS question.

I feel going after employer who hire "illegals" is one step in a long process of solving this problem NOW. Should we leave the illegals alone.....no of course not, we should grant them amnesty (after securing the border and stopping any further flow.......perhaps some guidelines in the Amnesty bill as well that limits state and federal aid.....I am undecided about that). They will be able to find work with good and honest employers and pay taxes.

Answer 6

I'm with Sashie here, too. She is on the money and to the point. Seal the borders up tight, then deal with the illicit employers, then the illegal immigrants currently in the country. Step-by-step, and it will all work out. Get rid of the main reason for their coming, and the rest will take care of itself.

Answer 7

The first and most important step is to seal the border. Going after the employers is a big part of it - but illegals must also be deported.

Answer 8

Heck no, we can't leave the illegals alone and ONLY go after the cheapskates who hire them .. they will still be here, stealing identities and creaming off society ... so no, a three pronged approach - seal the borders, fine cheapskating employers HEAVILY, and DEPORT the illegals!!

Answer 9

The whole system is backwards and messed up. The way I see it, this country was FOUNDED ON IMMIGRANTS. Unless you are 100% Native American, then at some point one of your ancestors came here from another country! That is what our country is all about - a better life than your country could offer you! Our government is so stupid.

Answer 10

We Mexicans particular have been given a brilliant number of guts annoying stuff from the u . s ., yet we are all cowards in Mexico. i desire to take back Mexico, yet no person will come south of the border with me and march and demand rights in our very own united states. We blame each and every thing on united statesa. and individuals. i'm ashamed of my very own human beings, for no longer status as much as our very own government. The White human beings made this an incredible united states, made a surprising invoice of rights and shape and we use it against them. No ask your self they're all mad and spiteful of Mexicans. They advised england and the Queen to ##### off and went there very own way. we are in a place to try this too in Mexico. Come on brothers and sisters, its time for us to take back Mexico from the corrupt government. contain me, arise. we've a eye-catching united states, the land is greater proper and richer than united statesa., we could circulate back and get it what belongs to us already.