Should Israel give/return land for Peace??

Question

Do you think that Israel should withdraw from the Gaza Strip (which Israel just reoccupied), and from the West Bank for Peace with the Palestinians???

Also, do you also think that Israel should withdraw from the Golan Heights for Peace with Syria???

The Arabs have said on numerous occasions that thats what it would take for Peace to happen between all Arab nations and Israel.

The Palestinians want the Gaza Strip and West Bank for a future State of Palestine and East Jerusalem as their capital.

The Golan Heights is Israeli Occupied Syrian territory which Israel annexed.

Thanks for your input! :)

Answer 1

Likud party says NO
Shas says NO
Kadima says NO

worker's party doesn't say a thing

Sooooooooooo

They'll make their stand till the end...

Answer 2

You ask a good question but I don't think you have followed the news. Israel has removed their people from the Gaza Strip against the will of the people and given the land to the Palestinians. Then Israel gives up occupation and turns over the government of the Gaza Strip to the Palestinians. The hope by Israel is that both peoples can live in peace. To be safe, Israel maintains a strict vigilance of the Gaza Strip because people from there still hate Israel.

So what happens? The Palestinians kidnap an Israeli soldier and I just heard, they killed him. You can agree or disagree, but Israel is not timid like the USA. They kick butt! They have again invaded the Gaza Strip and they are going to make those who harmed them pay for it. Israel's strategy is the if they punish the Palestinians every time they attack Israel, eventually, the Palestinians may stop attacking them.

There is a lot of debate about who owns the land. Israel has the land now because they won it in war. The USA owns our land because we took it from the Native Americans. The USA will not give America back to Native Americans and Israel will not give their land back to the Palestinians.

If the Palestinians ever decide to try and live in peace, things will get better. Unfortunately, I don't think that will ever happen soon.

TX Guy

Answer 3

They already pulled out of Gaza almost a year ago and willing to give more for peace but the Palestinian instead of developing their country showing the world that they want Israel out of the middle east by keep shooting missiles and choosing terror organization to be their government.

Israel didn't want to reoccupy Gaza and they will leave in a minute if the Palestinian will return the solider they kidnapped and stop shooting missiles on Israeli citizens.

Check the link below it can answer more questions you may have.

Answer 4

Jews have contributed more to the world than all the Arab nations put together. They don't practice barbaric things like female circumcision or the preaching of death and distruction to anyone who doesn't believe like they do. Israel doesn't kill people in America just to make some radical point, either. All Israel wanted was to have their own LITTLE state, and the Arabs can go ahead and have all that other land.

Arabs, on the other hand, plan to force anyone they can into their beliefs and ways of life. If Israel hadn't come about, the same area would be just as backward and oppressive as all the other Arab states.

Answer 5

Let us look at it differently. Islam and muslims are occupying a lot of land that does not belong to them.

Why is no one making any noise about that?

Islam or muslims are killing thousands of people. How come no one is making noise about that?

I think Jews used to live in the same land as Palestinians. But were chased out. What do you think is correct?

Has anyone ever sat down and given a thought of what Arabs have done to the rest of the world and how much muslims hurt other people even today?

Why so much discussion about Palestine and Israel?

When are we really going to start discussing how much the arabs have hurt the world?

Answer 6

No. Israel has consistently and constantly, for the entire duration of the occupation of that territory, offered to return it in exchange for peace. For more than an entire generation, that peace has been steadfastly (although not universally) refused. Recently, Israel attempted a unilateral peace, giving up the land pre-emptively and asking for peace (it is a LIE to claim the arabs have offered peace in return for these lands....as in it is fundamentally untrue to the point of rejecting peace when the land is given to them first). The result has been a much emboldened and officially sanctioned open warfare against Israel....to the point of rockets being launched into civilian areas constantly. Now, the arabs claim that they have WMD and are planning to exterminate all jews. THAT is why Israel has re-occupied the territory.

Quite frankly, there is only one viable solution. And that is to drive the arabs out of the area with military force. Two generations of leniency and manipulation by marxists like you have lead to a disaster. It's time to admit that the arabs are simply evil aggressors and treat them as such. It's also time to tell the marxists to shut the hell up.

Answer 7

No, Israel should not give back anything.

The arabs will never have enough and they will just keep on wanting more and more until they get jerusalem and have their own state. So even though the arabs SAY there will be peace- there wont be, and we see this from the fact that we withdrew from gaza and they still shoot rockets into Israel.

Besides that, what kind of govenment kicks out their own people from their houses. It ruins these peoples lives...

Answer 8

When are the people on this planet going to get it?
God threw the Israelites off that land in the year 70.
The current incarnation of Israel has nothing to do with the covenant Israel.
1. No Priest Class.(Legitimately, no one can truthfully claim to have descended from the Levites).
2. There is no Temple.
3. NO Animal Sacrifices.
4. They do not have a theocratic government.
5. They have faith in manmade weapons, not Almighty God.
I am sure people have other things to add to this list.
This is one point on which I totally agree with the islamists.
Throw the dam b jews out of there.
God threw them out,
to say they should be there, is to oppose god's will.
Any doubt in what I said?
Look at the weapons worshiping response below mine.
But if he wants his kids to die fighting for that man made desert,
go right ahead. "NEXT!"

Answer 9

No, I think they Israelis and the Palestinians get what they deserve.

If they cannot live in peace together, then maybe all that is saying is maybe they should not LIVE (together) at all.

This issue has been burning for as long as I can remember. And a lot of people have died (AND FOR WHAT?) And a lot more will die (AND FOR WHAT???)

Maybe when all the warmongers have killed themselves off, then maybe the peaceloving survivors can finally attain peace!

RIGHT! that'll happen.

There will never be peace in that region.

NEVER!

Maybe one day, the star and the crescent will be as one - but I don't see that in this lifetime. Afterall, they are the SAME People.

WE ARE ALL THE SAME PEOPLE!

So what's the freakin' problem?

Answer 10

NO! God made a covenant with Abraham and that covenant cannot be broken. That is in Genesis. But read on!

2Ch 6:6 But I have chosen Jerusalem, that my name might be there; and have chosen David to be over my people Israel.
2Ch 7:16 For now have I chosen and sanctified this house, that my name may be there for ever: and mine eyes and mine heart shall be there perpetually.
2Ch 33:7 And he set a carved image, the idol which he had made, in the house of God, of which God had said to David and to Solomon his son, In this house, and in Jerusalem, which I have chosen before all the tribes of Israel, will I put my name for ever:
Fact is that before Islam was Jerusalem promised by God in his word for the Jews. Jerusalem is the city of God as the bible states. Jerusalem means city of peace. I think that the Arabs have far enough of the middle east and should leave that little country of Israel alone. It will never be destroyed...its Gods!
I think the Palestinians should have a land, but it should not be Israel. Used to be we called Saudi Arabia the head of the snake, however I feel it is Syria. If Arabs want peace, stop terrorism in the name of your Allah! If Arabs want peace stop denying Israels right to existence and leave them be. Stop terrorizing those who support Israel. We don't not support Arab countries, but we do support the rights of the Jews, the chosen of God. To hate them is to hate Jesus, king of the Jews.

Answer 11

Israel wants to occupying all of Palestinian lands. Remember the previous agreements between Palestinian and Zionists. They broke all of the agreements and occupied the lands step by step.
So don't wonder of Zionists acts, they abusing the opportunities that other countries are concentrated on them like Iraq, Afghanistan, etc. to killing and running out innocent unarmed Palestinian of their forefather lands. While Zionists occupied other lands like Gaza, they wasting the time (some years) to have discussion about these lands and usually they won't withdraw of lands. They want to attach all of Palestinian lands to previous occupied lands.