What's the difference between a fat white American piece of trash and an undocumented alien?

Question

What I mean is: how are trashy Americans who sit around all day on their a**, get welfare and contribute to the US population boom by popping out kids every year any better than undocumented immigrants who hold down two or three jobs, pay taxes and in general contribute to society? Shouldn't we deport the American trash that's draining us and embrace the people who come here to work?

Answer 1

Actually uneducated ppl like you should be deported.

Ever since Clinton's welfare reform in the 90s, a person can not live off of welfare for more than 3 to 5 years throughtout their entire life. (the exact year depends on your state)

Also, what is draining you is your level of ignorance to real facts. Things like the amount of money that goes into paying for incentives for big business to get richer and richer. Or like paying CEO's 40 million+ dollars. And ignorant ppl like you get mad about some disabled person living off what... $600 a month?

Geez grow up and educate yourself.

Answer 2

I'll try to keep it short because I tend to go on for like ten minutes. :D

We should stop basing this issue on legal, illegal, and other such terms. While technically it IS a legal issue, is it not more of a humanitarian issue? Who deserves the better treatment? The person who does nothing because they know they can, or the person who holds down as many jobs as he can to support his wife and children? My problem with this, being an American citizen and all, is that the Law-Makers have to stay within other laws. So, if this problem was happening in a dictatorship, first of all, the immigrants might NOT want to come in, and secondly, if they did, they wouldn't get more than two chances to do it. Eventually someone would snap and demand that all illegals are exicuted. Or on the flip-side, it could be a communisit dictatorship, an oxymoron to be sure, and only the people who deserved the support of the state would get it, and the others would be exicuted. As for this Population Boom, again, Exicute rather than Re-educate. I know this seems extremely harsh, and it really is. But if you want to maintain status-quo, then you need to maintain it with force people understand, not just "Go Back Three Steps," but "Do Not Pass Go, Do Not Collect $200...Ya know, nevermind, just come out back of this barn for about ten minutes, I have a large hole I want you to dig."

I know this is an extremely radical way of putting it, but it gets results.

Dang, too long again. Sorry.

Answer 3

The American has the legal right to prosper or fail in life as he or she sees fit. Illegals on the other hand prevent some Americans from having jobs by either taking the job out right or by keep the wages too low for an American to live on. There are 30 million working poor in this country. If there are 12 million illegals taking up jobs and keeping wages low there is bound to be some Americans that say the He** with it. If Americans sitting on their butts bother enough people then that can be addressed, as a separate issue. Illegal immigration is a separate issue affecting all Americans regardless if they are sitting around or not. But then, this is just the opinion of a "racist"

Answer 4

I agree with BeachBum completely and I'm gald she put you in your place. I would like to add though that you are not only ignorant, you are also prejudiced and narrow minded and have absolutely no clue about the world around you. Nobody likes to be on welfare. Did it ever occur to you that maybe some of these people you arrogantly refer to as a white piece of trash are on welfare because there are 12 million illegals here taking jobs that don't belong to them? Or that employers prefer to hire illegals over legal citizens because illegals can't complain about working conditions and long hours, not to mention the fact that they work for much less and these greedy employers can therefore increase their profits exponentially by hiring them? If you are concerned about people being on welfare the solution is to sanction employers and deport all illegals. But I guess your motto is to not allow the facts to get in the way of a perfectly ridiculous argument, right?

Answer 5

Well unfortunately the American piece of trash has a legal right to the welfare system and an undocumented alien does not.

Interesting thought though.

Answer 6

Perhaps the primary difference between white trash or American trash in general, and undocumented aliens is that the undocumented aliens are too busy working in unsafe environments, getting underpaid and abused, to have time to waste on the computer writing silly questions in Yahoo!.

Answer 7

Yes, they are both pretty bad examples of human existence, but guess what we can legally get rid of the illegal aliens. Unfortunately we are stuck with the welfare sucking baby mills.

Clinton started in the right direction limiting welfare to 3 to 5 years in a lifetime. It's a good start but we need to eliminate welfare completely.

Oh and by the way, the baby mills that you are describing come from all races. Don't be a racist, it only makes you personally look bad.

Answer 8

As to your fat and white comments...
Black men are the fattest Americans: http://www.healthatoz.com/healthatoz/Atoz/news/hs522848.jsp

As to your popping out babies comments...White people are the true minorities, only making up about 10% of the world's population and are in decline, including in America:
http://www.childtrendsdatabank.org/indicators/79BirthRates.cfm
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr54/nvsr54_08.pdf

Because of poor diet and fewer opportunities, the poor are actually fatter than the rich:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2005-05-02-obesity-affluent_x.htm

Although blacks are the most obese, obese white women are more discriminated against:
http://www.news.cornell.edu/releases/Oct01/weight.income.ssl.html

As to your welfare verses work comments...
I haven't read this yet, but have read papers like this. These are well known facts to anyone who has ever studied a minimal amount of sociology, poverty, women's issues, etc. Even if you just read the front page of this and don't go to the links you will have learned something:
http://www.apa.org/pi/wpo/welfaretoworkhom.html

Here's the search I got it from, showing other articles on the subject:
http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=most+welfare+recipients+are+poor+white+women&prssweb=Search&ei=UTF-8&fr=ush-ans&x=wrt

And, last, but definitely not least, any working class American can tell you this. We poor white trash Americans have always done those dirty jobs that other Americans won't do. We don't need Mexicans for that. So if they are going to come here, they need to be Americans. Period.
http://www.washtimes.com/op-ed/20051201-081528-7276r.htm

Answer 9

The illegal works 14 hours a day, pays all taxes(I DO!) and the legal black makes a baby after baby, gets free housing without ever having to work.
Lazy blacks are the real problem, not hardworking illegals.
No illegal lives off welfare and pops out a baby after baby!

Answer 10

I'm not white but i am an American(African American)and my whole family is upset about those law breaking non tax paying free loading unable to understand English on & on.....welfare is not as much as you think it is, and after 3 years they have to get off of it and when they go back to work that's when they pay it back though taxes.Americans pay 4 it and should have this when needed only.