Why should someone pay for something they did not do?

Question

Why should ALL undocomunted immigrants pay for ONE person that had a sign in one of the marches that said "This is our continent, not yours" ?
Why should ALL undocumented immigrants pay for ONE person that had a sign that said "If you think I'm illegal because I'm a Mexican, learn the true history, because I'm in my homeland"?
WHY,WHY,AND WHY should they pay for something that they did not do? I mean, Not every undocomented feels like that! very few do, So why should other undocomented immigrats had to pay for what two or three of them did?
That stupid act that two or three of them did hurt the cause of the marches.It is not fair.

Kristi *
You need reading lessons? sorry I couldn't help it.

I know that there were more than one holding signs.

Answer 1

I'm an Albanian, albanians emigrated a lof this last 10 yrs.
When I was in Italy (as a tourist) thay said to me...oh! you albanians are all criminals...!!
is this right???
No of course!
my answer was: in the beginings of the XXth century italians emigrated to USA...wasnt they who brought there the MAfia?

We must be citizens of the WORLD who lives in one land...

Answer 2

Lemme see, how many were there at marches?

Some say a million, some say a few million, some say a few hundred thousands at each place where the "illegals" were protesting.

Now, if your an "illegal" in this Country, YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO PROTEST!

Plain and simple!! You are here illegally!

Now, if you want to go through the process of doing it like all the immigrants who come to America "legally", then go to a port of entry and come in legally, and have the full status of an American Citizen, instead of hiding out, like an illegal would, and not have to worry about being deported...

Oh, yea, I forgot, the Immigration Service doesnt "deport" you, they give you a court date, in which hardly anyone ever shows up, and they just stay in our Country illegally...hmmm

I can not go into Mexico, as an illegal, with out grave consequences. Why should you be allowed to come into this Country, with out the same grave consequences??

Your President, Fox, thinks its ok to send us all the illegals to bring back money for him, and your Country..(yes, you notice I said.."your Country", because you dont belong to the United States, because your "illegals").

I am not bigoted, or against anyone, but, I AM for the LAW! And your breaking it!

I dont speed, because its illegal. I dont steal because its illegal, I dont do a lot of things because its illegal, so, If I cant do it, then you shouldnt be able to do it...

I wish you well..

Jesse

Answer 3

The simple truth is that all Undocumented workers violated the law to get here

There is an established way to get here and legally work - They all cheated

There is no sympathy for cheaters

They did not submit fingerprints, police records or a history -
There are thousands of people all over the world trying to Immigrate here Legally

This Country needs Law abiding Immigrants - not law breakers and short cutters

The Undocumented - Illegals need to go home and do things right - Then people would welcome them

http://www.uscis.gov/graphics/index.htm

Do not ever think a law breaker has superior rights

Answer 4

That crap doesn't matter. You can call then undocumented immigrants, illegal immigrants, criminals. The fact is that they are all the same thing and breaking the law to be here. It doesn't matter how many do or do not hold up signs. They are breaking the law to be here and need to be deported!

And if you want to pull that history crap, then all of the Mexicans should give Mexico back to the people they stole it from. This is American not Mexico or some other country. If someone is not here legally then this is not their home. They are guilty and breaking into and entering my home.

DEPORT ILLEGAL ALIENS

Answer 5

Your question ponders why do all undocumented immigrants have to pay the price for one who did the things you have described in your question. The answer is simple: If one person had a sign that said, "this is our continent. . .read the true history" hangs the US flag upside down, burns it in the UNITED STATES. . . and not one person does something about it, do you not realize the message the US authorities are giving to the illegal workers when nothing is done about it?

Many people jumped on the bandwagon, including personas non grata.

Answer 6

No but they should all pay for violating the law. When I get a speeding ticket I pay the consequences. The law states if you are here illegally you are to be deported. You cannot truly love a Country enough to move there if you are not willing to follow the law. (Or learn the language. ) And when I refer to illegal aliens I refer to anyone from anywhere other than the UNITED STATES who is here illegally. Not just Mexicans. Unfortunately, Mexicans have made this about Mexicans.

Answer 7

If they would have kept their mouth shut, immigration probably would not be an issue, but they listened to their Mexican American activists organizations, like La Raza and Mencha and others and then they flu their stupid Mexican flag, now isn't that stupid flying the Mexican flag and marching for American rights, that dose not make sense, and the only reason they stoped flying the flag is because the organizations told them to, the back lash was swift from the American public, but even after the Mexican org. told them to fly the American flag their were still a lot of Mexicans that waved the Mexican flag, and I will never get the image out of my mind, it made me sick. So deport them all. Their is even an as*hole Mexican down the street from me with his Mexican flag up, He is living here with all the benefits of American society and flying his stupid Mexican flag, so I say deport as many as possible. starting with the one down the street.

Answer 8

When lots of people talk about the immigration issue they are talking about the ones that broke the laws, the ones that are on welfare, and the ones that are racist against Americans. I know there are alot of mexican americans that are great people. The only problem i have the ones that don't say hi when you go to there grocery store, the ones that talk crap about america, the ones that gripe about their job, the ones that are all stuck up, the ones that keep having babies even though they can't afford them , the ones that fail to learn the english language because they just don't care about being a part of society....etc other than that i have alot of hispanic friends. So i dont think we judge the whole race we are basically talking about the ones i just described. One way you can tell that they are not talking about you "just because your hispanic" is if they are talking about the ones on welfare and your not on welfare the you know they are not talking about you. By the way, i know lots of mexican americans that completly agree with alot of the debate on the american side.

Answer 9

Granted, that was stupid. But the illegal immigrants must face the consequences of their illegal activity. The U.S. is a nation of laws. If the laws aren't working property, like our immigration system, then you have to work to get them fixed. You can't just ignore the law and do whatever you want.

I sympathize with their issues, and that our immigration system is a mess all the way around, but there's just no excuse for breaking the law. We don't allow poor, hungry Americans to rob banks.

Answer 10

Look me being raised in louisiana and having mexican parents
I think that the world is not fair but my parents said that it is true just for 1 person people can get involved of marches.
Well some mexicans need to learn more about laws and the history.

Answer 11

Well, that is hardly the point ... the point is that there are millions of illegals here ... they have all broken our laws, namely by entering our country illegally, and KNOWINGLY broken our immigration laws ... these marches, with or without stupid slogans, will not further the cause of the illegal aliens ... if you're here illegally, you HAVE broken the law ... and if we give amnesty to law breakers, what will that signal to the rest of the world? That the United States has become an anarchy?