English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

If he is the word of God, and is Almasih, why are we not obeying him?

If he is from Heaven, he should know the way to heaven, and who else from Heaven but God?

If he will come to judge, who can judge but God?

If he is declare as sinless, who else is sinless but God?

I am very suprised of this finding, and all my muslim friends avoided me on this issue. Many told me not to look into this, and the Imam are not helping as well.

Any Imam wish to explain this to me please? Sorry, i really am not here to pick a fight, but to learn.

2006-06-18 17:01:43 · 10 answers · asked by Melvin C 5 in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

I am not a Muslim. I am a Christian, asking my muslim friends. All these terms are taught by them.

2006-06-18 23:33:35 · update #1

10 answers

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmitullahi wa bartakatu,

Alhamdulillah, that you are asking questions. however, I would recommend that from now on these types of questions should be directed to sheiookh directly.

1. if he is the Word of God, why are we not obeying him?

We are obeying him in the sense that he came with the exact same message Muhammad Salallahu alayhi wa sallam came with, which is to Worship Allah Alone.

However, since Muhammad sallalahu alayhi wa sallam is the seal of the Prophets, his Prophethood Supercedes the others.

For example, When the Prophet Salallalhu alayhi wa sallam ascended to al-ma3raj. He led the other Prophets in 2 rakat of Salat. Which was a clear indication that he is the leader of the Prophets. and When Isa (as) will come down, he will be governing inshaAllah with the shariyah (laws) of Muhammad Salallahu alayhi wa sallam.

so yes, we still are following him. but we follow the shariyah of Muhammad SAlallahu alayhi wa salam. because his supercedes the rest. wallahu alem.

#2. Is he from Heaven? indeed all human beings are origninally from where? Jannah. why? because our Father Adam was origninally from Jannah. However, it must be noted that we are mere human beings, and it is not correct to say that Allah is "from" Jannah, because he Created Jannah. Allah subhana wa ta'ala is high above that. wallahu ta'ala alem.

#3. if he will come to judge, who can judge but God?

He will come to down to govern with the shariah of Muhammad salaAllahu alayhi wasallam. and when inshaallah he comes back, not other religion will be accepted but Islam. we can have judges on earth. but the ULTIMATE judge is Allah. as that is one of his names and attributes he is The Judge. truely, no one can judge what is in the hearts of Man except for Allah, and no one can give everyone their dues and rewards except for Allah on the day of Judgment.

if he is declared as sinless, who else is sinless but God?

He (alayhil salam) was human. therefore, he also made mistakes. For truely, no one is perfect but Allah. but Allah FORGIVES the mistakes and sins of his prophets.


WAllahu ta'ala alem.

I hope that helped akhi. I ask Allah subhana wa ta'ala to guide you to the strait path. ameen. and remember to always make dua to Allah to guide you.

2006-06-18 20:39:34 · answer #1 · answered by Shirien 3 · 0 1

Isa and Jesus were two different people. Once you realize this, the answer to your questions will all come quickly. The Qu'ran speaks of Isa. The Bible speaks of Jesus, so let us compare the two...

Isa was created, not eternal. He did not create anything.
Jesus is the Alpha and Omega, the eternal Creator. - Ephesians 3:9, Colossians 1:16, Revelation 2:8

Isa is a created human.
Jesus was God incarnate. - John 10:30-33

Isa is NOT the Lamb of God who was slain.
Jesus IS the Lamb of God who was slain. - John 1:29, John 1:36, Revelation 5:6

Isa will not return until Judgment Day.
Jesus WILL return before Judgment Day. - Matthew 25:31, John 14:3

Isa prophesied the coming of Mohammed.
Jesus warned of prophets that will come. - Matthew 7:15, Matthew 24:11

Isa did NOT send the Holy Spirit.
Jesus sent the Holy Spirit - John 15:26

Salvation is found only in the Five Pillars of Islam.
Salvation can only come through Jesus. - Acts 4:10-12

Isa is a slave to Allah.
Jesus is by on the right-hand of the Father. - Matthew 26:64, Mark 12:36, Mark 16:19, Acts 5:31

Isa did not die on the cross, and was not resurrected.
Jesus died on the cross and rose on the third day.- Romans 14:9

Isa is predicted to return in the end times but to break the cross, deny that he is the son of god and point worship to the Islamic Messiah The Mahdi.
Jesus will return to save Israel from her enemies and establish the Throne of David and rule with a rod of iron.- Revelation 19:15

Isa is a prophet like Mohammad and like Moses.
Jesus is the "I AM" who was before Mohammad, before Moses, and before Abraham - John 8:58

Isa is NOT God in the flesh.
Jesus is God in the flesh. - John 1:14

Isa CANNOT be worshipped for He is NOT God.
Jesus is God and worthy of worship. - Matthew 14:33

Isa is not fit to be any kind of intercessor.
Jesus is the only mediator between God and man. - 1 Timothy 2:5

Isa will judge by the laws of Islam, not by the Gospel.
Jesus will judge in righteousness according to response to the Gospel. - 1 Peter 4:5-6, Acts 17:31

Isa is simply another prophet.
Jesus is the Almighty. - Revelation 1:8

Isa returns in yellow garments, not white.
Jesus returns in garments stained with blood. - Isaiah 63:2-4, Revelation 19:13

Isa lands on a minaret in Damascus, Syria.
Jesus sets foot on the Mount of Olives - Zechariah 14:4

Isa returns on the wings of two angels.
Jesus returns riding a white horse. - Revelation 19:11

Isa is not pierced when He returns (like the Bible teaches).
Jesus bears His scars when He returns. - Revelation 5:6

Isa will marry a woman and have children. - Zechariah 13:6

Isa will break every cross.
Jesus will come to reign. - Revelation 11:15

Isa will kill all the Jews and Christians at Armaggedon.
Jesus will save the Jews from the Antichrist. - Isaiah 63:1
Jesus will gather His elect before the tribulation. - John 14:3, 2 Thessalonians 2
Jesus will destroy the armies of the enemies of His people - Revelation 19:2

Isa will die forty years after his return.
Jesus is alive for ever more - Revelation 1:18

Isa was not the Son of God. God has no son!
Jesus IS the Son of God.- Mark 1:1

Isa was the son of Mariam, the sister of Moses."
Jesus was the son of Mary, the lineage of King David.- Matthew 21:9

Isa is NOT the greatest prophet - Mohammed is!
The greatest prophet was John the Baptist, who testified Jesus being the Lamb of God. - Luke 7:28

2006-06-19 08:42:15 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

And Jesus said," None one can enter into Heaven, but through Me." I hope I said it correctly) You are suprised, why? God Sent His only Son to wash away the sins of the world. If you believe and follow God's Teaching that Jesus prerached here on Earth, then you will have obeyed Him.

2006-06-18 17:11:34 · answer #3 · answered by wayne_049 3 · 0 0

the Holy Quaran states that Jesus will come again. and His coming is a sign of the Day of Judgement. this by definition means even in Islam, Jesus is the Messiah. the Quaran states that the Gospel (Injeel) is valid. the Gospel is written that Jesus said "no one can go to the Father except through the Son." again, definition of Messiah. there is a pattern forming here. i hope you can see that Allah has decreed that the way to Him is through Isa (pbuh) and i pray you find that. asalamulakium.

2006-06-18 17:52:43 · answer #4 · answered by erukolindo 2 · 1 0

It seams sparkling to me the reply is Jesus. no remember how not straight forward the Jehovah's Witnesses attempt to push Jesus' deity out of their Bible, it really is nevertheless there. this can provide them a clue or I could say a cue. Their heritage is full of the acceptable of Jesus only a competent guy and the exclusiveness of "them". Be it certain they don't seem unique, there are countless lost souls obtainable. in the adventure that they prefer to locate salvation, they in reality could seem to Jesus no longer to those one hundred 44,000 they're going to not be a intense priest to the order of Melchizedek. translated as "my king (is) righteous(ness)") although that's Jesus who's King and makes us righteous in the previous the daddy, no longer some guy or selection of adult men, anointed perchance, yet nevertheless no longer in a position to deliver salvation to all people. If the intense clergymen of previous ought to no longer do it, why would all people imagine some mere adult men of proper this second ought to do it? ineffective, merely ineffective, some thing different then Jesus and the full works of the bypass. that's the message Paul tried to get in the course of yet some adult men have harden their heart and minds that they could and they are incorrect, merely because the Jehovah's Witness are incorrect and lost.

2016-10-14 07:12:50 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

why do you lie? what's with the psychological BS. If a muslim wants to argue a point, he uses logic and a straightforward approach. Are you so lacking in confidence in your beliefs that you have to be surreptitious? Christian missionaries sicken me.

2006-06-18 17:23:04 · answer #6 · answered by stanza 2 · 0 0

I'm not sure I perfectly understand your question. However, as Muslims, we do have deep belief in Jesus. We believe in his miraculous birth and his miracles. However, we do not believe that he is the son of God. Our belief in him as a messanger is based on two main criteria: the Quran, and the Bible. In the Quran, a beautiful sora is dedicated to Jesus and his Mother mary. The sora is actually called Mary, and it describes the life of his mother, his birth and the nature of himself and why he was sent following the thousands of other profits sent by God. In addition to the Quran, the bible describes Jesus as being a human in every aspect of the word. Jesus is described as getting hungry, thirsty, angry and impatient sometimes (even with the apostles), in addition to many other human descriptions. Jesus is descibed as eating the food the drinking water. A food that is eaten will be digested and would have to expelled from the body. I hope you can understand my drift. I'm not in any way trying to be offensive, but as Muslims, we're urged to always employ thinking and logic. If Jesus was in fact God, the message would be so clear in the bible that it wouldn't be debated hundreds of years after his death, mostly by Christians. There is not a single verse in the Bible where Jesus said that he was God and he demanded worship. There is no such a thing as the bible "according to Jesus" either. There is the bible according to many others however. As muslims, we believe God to be the creator of all things, even the thoughts in our mind. Even the idea of family was created by God and he existed far before any idea that we know of. To apply an idea created by God to describe the nature of God is in no way scientific or logical. God created space and time, so God exists beyond space or time. To say that God created us in his own image is to say that God lives in a word where he is controlled by the rules that control us. Without an atmosphere that exherts forces on our bodies, our bodies would not exist. In order for God to have a human like shape, he would have to exist in some kind of an atmosphere. God created the universe including all the forces in the universe, so all known forces were created by God. Religion, in my opinion, should not be detached from science. True religion came from God, who is the creator of all science. Blind faith, without logic or thought or scientific basis is an easy way to believe in any idea without demanding logic behind that idea. I would urge anyone to try and give an explanation of why Jesus is the Son of God. The challenge however is to do it based on logic, and without ever saying "the bible said... ". I truely hope someone would take up that challenged. As a muslim I am urged to employ logic and never to shy away from knowledge. Please enlighten me. Finally, I'd like to emphasize that as a Muslim, I have to believe in Jesus and his book - the one original bible which was the word of God. I believe in that book, the book of Musa (Moses) and the quran. Peace for everyone, and may God elighten us all.

2006-06-18 17:54:09 · answer #7 · answered by NileDiver 1 · 0 0

No, you're not surprised. You're a Christian posing as a 'curious' Muslim. We've seen people do this before.

2006-06-18 17:17:24 · answer #8 · answered by XYZ 7 · 0 0

Good point, can you send me the details of your question please?

2006-06-18 17:07:24 · answer #9 · answered by imran 3 · 0 0

What??????

2006-06-18 17:04:59 · answer #10 · answered by Dark Angel 5 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers