Police questioning passangers?

Question

If I am driving and lets say forget to use my turn signal and I get pulled over and I have people in the car and nothing illegal besides my incorrect turn is going on do the cops have the right to ask everyone in the car for id and the such even though they themselves did nothing wrong and dont appear to be drunk high or anything like that. I live in Michigan if it matters

Answer 1

No, liberals the following in Arizona do no longer imagine that each and each one law enforcement officials are white and racist. that is glaring that they don't look. it really is not any longer the element of the regulation it truly is troubling. For us the following in AZ, the nice and cozy button is contained in the "useful suspicion" component of the wording. For a at the same time as now, we've had a series of sweeps made which have accumulated regularly unlawful extraterrestrial beings. The "useful suspicion" provided has many cases been some thing like "flawed use of the horn" or non-operating vehicle plate mild. also, the sweeps were made in neighborhoods that were regularly Hispanic. we've considered some cases the position a US citizen has been arrested and deported and landed in Mexico unable to even communicate Spanish. finally, the structure provides the federal authorities the right to modify immigration, no longer the states. That brings up the question of even if the regulation will bypass muster as constitutional. that is not any longer as sparkling-shrink because it ought to look from the exterior. there is also an economic effect. there has been one cancellation of a significant convention, and a number of different communities are speaking about or have easily started a boycott of the state. some organizations which have catered to the Hispanic marketplace have presented that they'll be ultimate or shifting to a special state. back, no longer as basic because it ought to sound.

Answer 2

Technically no, this is a violation of their 4th amendment rights which are an illegal search and seizure has been committed by this officer against your passengers. But most state governments toss that to the wind, by enacting statutory laws that require residents of any particular state to produce government issued photo ID whenever requested by a law enforcement official. For further info, I suggest typing 'lawyerdude' into your search engine, he has a goldmine of info on this particular subject. I also wanted to add after reading some of the other posts, that the act of the officer asking you for your ID is a seizure or arrest in and of itself, you are not allowed to ignore the officer and start walking away from him(which you would have the perfect right to do, if you were not under arrest or seizure, just try walking away after being asked for your ID and see what happens.) He is asking for the ID and expecting you to give it to him because when you signed for that ID, in whatever state you live in, you gave implied consent that you would voluntarily show your ID to peace officers when requested. If you do not do as requested, then you are in violation of the legal contract ((i.e. your drivers license or id) YES IT IS A LEGAL CONTRACT, do the research.) that you have with the state and subject to penalties. And one other thing, after reading the other posts to your question, don't take too much stock in what they have to say, judging from their answers they are uneducated and one of the biggest reasons why we live in a police state today. Remember, ignorance is bliss. GET EDUCATED IN THE WAYS OF OUR PATRIOT FOREFATHERS AND TAKE THIS COUNTRY BACK! OUR FOREFATHERS WOULD BE ASHAMED OF US! GET FED UP WITH THE SYSTEM AND HELP CHANGE IT! ARE YOU A SOVEREIGN BEING OR A CORPORATE ENTITY OF THE GOVERNMENT. Remember this , there is no mention of statutory law in the U.S. Constitution, and all state constitutions are modeled around it.

Answer 3

Yes, unfortunatly they now have the "Patriot Act" wich is in every state in the U.S.
They can pull you over and question everyone in the car without even having a reason..
I have had it happen and Im a 29 yr old female with no criminal record..
Its 2006..thats our life now..

Answer 4

yes the police can ask the drivers in the car for identification. the purpose of that is usually to run their names for a warrant check or other types of background checks. mostly the police ask for identification just to make sure everyone has an ID or to see the persons response to being asked for it. if a person acts frivilous about showing their ID they usually have something to hide.

Answer 5

Since passengers don't have to carry id, the police can ask all they want, the passengers have to give them thier names.

this is normally done when and if they belive something else is going on, drugs, hookers ( looking for) and so on.

Answer 6

Yes they can, they are being cautious especially if a "load" of people are out riding around. They do this in our small town to the teens all the time

Answer 7

Of course they have the right to "ask". Its "demanding" they can't do without a reason.

Answer 8

probable cause it what they would say it is my friend .but know your right s.don't let them search you car .if you no your clean then make them get a warrant

Answer 9

Only if they have reasonable cause. As long as you have nothing to hide don't worry about it.

Answer 10

Yes they have the right.