argument against existence beyond this life; do you remember what it was like before you were born?

Question

this question isn't meant to say anything about the existence of a single deity.

not when you were 3 or 4 years old, b4 u were born.

Answer 1

The reason that I don't remember anything before I was born,

Is because I didn't Exist!

I will be aware of and remember things after I die because I Exist now and into forever!

Answer 2

It is said tht people can remember for some time or a long time but they must learn to talk soon to be able to express the memories. Some children can talk soon & so tell their memories of past lives but others forget before they talk.Those who remember for a long time till they talk did say things of their past lives and they were found to be true.Some die & are born soon after and so their stories can be more easily verified but, others are born much later maybe even a few hundred years & so their stories cannot easily be verified as the evidence may not exist or is difficult to get since much time has passed.

Answer 3

That's no argument at all. No Christian that I know of ever claimed existence before conception. At that point a new soul is created- there was nothing to remember before that because I didn't exist before then. Nobody does.

Answer 4

No, but on the other hand, I don't remember anything from when I was one or two, either. Maybe my life just skipped those years?

Answer 5

Yes some times I remember place I have never been and things I have never done.I don't know where these memories come from.

Answer 6

If a spirit existed independent of the body (brain) it would not be possible to sedate people and we would never "sleep."

Odd how our "spirit" has no independence of its own.

Answer 7

I remember a vague smell... but I am not shure if that is what you mean :)