5 differences between treatment of human rights in Guantanamo (now) and laboratory of Mengele (WW2)?

Question

May you add also answers/comments to my question placd at http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AikUOaL81fjnoo6cCuTnMy_sy6IX?qid=20060607152921AATkJn7 ?

There were not such think like Mengele camps. Mengele just had people for his experiments by application to them. People for experiments were hold to reach the aim of investogator (so not necessarily were starving).
Both hold people without decision of the court. In a territory where are no laws in fact. WW2 lasted 4 years, many of concentration camp prisoners who survived passed less time in them than Guantanamo prisoners. And that was a time of exhausting war in these states. With limited food production.

Answer 1

1) In principle, the Geneva Convention is being followed, with guidelines for humane treatment of detainees
2) There is media scrutiiny on Gitmo, especially with the 5 suicides reported today
3) Religious rights of detainees are respected, at least in theory
4) There is no intentional medical experimentation on the Gitmo detainees
5) Detainees at Gitmo are still considered to be human (vs. test subjects) and there are limits placed on interrogation methods

Answer 2

1. In the Mengele laboratories, prisoners were starved if it served the purpose of the experiment. In Guantanamo, they choose to have hunger strikes.

2. In the Mengele labs, prisoners were used for experimentation.
In Guantanamo, they are given needed medical treatment.

3. The Mengele laboratories were shrouded in secrecy, in Guantanamo the inmates meet with representatives of the Red Cross, have lawyers and are the subject of press attention.

4. The Mengele labs had no respect for the inmates religion,
in Guantanamo care is taken to respect their Koran and insure their diet is not in violation of their religious beliefs.

5. The government that ran and sanctioned the Mengele experiments would not tolerate a question like this being asked, the government that runs Guantanamo does not silence those who express concern that any of the human rights of its detainees are being violated.

Answer 3

1) Now the whole world is just watching
2)Now the so-called super democratic country is doing it
3) Now it is being done on Arabs while Mengele did it on Jews
4) Now it is being done after 60 years since WW2
5) Noe it is being done by the country who codismantled Mengele Lab.

Answer 4

There's a US soldier that hasn't even been formally charged or accused of any wrongdoing and he is in shackles.

Why are you worrying about a bunch of suspected terrorists' "rights?"

Worry about our own first.