O no I made a ___________ but instead of __________ I used _______ by mistake?

Question

what happen next

Answer 1

Oh no, I made a Mutter Utter Cake, but instead of Milk, I used vinegar by mistake. I really thought recipe called for vinegar. It looked so pretty on the crystal platter. I just could not wait until the guests arrived.
After dinner I served the Mutter Utter Cake with coffee. One of the guest said it taste lemony and other said it tastes like a salad. Then I took a bite and made a smooch sound because it was sour tasty. The guests finished the cake and as they were leaving their stomachs were growling. Probably gonna end up with diarrhea

Answer 2

And *poof* it became Koko Crunch